On The Beach

I don't get who likes this. If he sang in tune then it wouldn't be bad, but he's basically tone deaf.

Для фона

Entretenido

not for me and it keeps glityching

Always interesting lyricist, not sure this is my favorite

As someone generally likes Neil Yong this was not good at all.

A couple of songs at the beginning were noteworthy, but it soon turned into okay background music. Obsessed with the album art though. 2.5 starfishes.

Pretty unremarkable

sounds exactly like the songs i make up for my cat

Didn't leave an impression

The list of people that can sing but make great music is quite long, Lou Reed, Bob Dylan, Iggy Pop, Tom Waits, Leonard Cohen, maybe we can add Neil Young to this list…unfortunately not. It’s kind of like when I watched Tokyo Godfather’s in July or saw Macy Gray in an ice hockey rink in Canada; context is everything. The second half the of the album is not actually bad and I could see myself enjoying it sat in a bar dingy bar, drinking whiskey late at night anywhere, else it’s no. It’s only this that saves it from being a 1.

This album was not for me. Way too laid back and relaxed for my taste.

Pretty boring

Just because it’s Neil does not mean it’s good, a disappointing thing I’ve had to accept more than once. This is like including Leonardo’s sketches alongside his master paintings, why? Sure some people want to peer behind the scenes of genius, but keep it from these kinds of lists. Admittedly I’m biased against celebrities wrestling with their fame, most times it just comes off as pretentious or self absorbed. It was probably helpful for Neil to work his own shit out creatively, but please keep it from my ears. It does have Turnstiles though. And the solo on Revolution Blues is pretty cool

So so from Neil Young, the 1st one that is not up to his high standard

This is my 4th Neil Young album this month, 5th overall. Still one to go, and that doesn't count any CSNY or anything else he might be involved in. I like Neil Young. He has some great songs. None of them are on this album.

I just didn't like it

Kept wanting to like it but weren’t really any standout songs, maybe On The Beach at a push, not for me overall

3/10 Not my genre

Okay

You know that scene in a movie after an emotional bombshell is dropped on the main character, or perhaps they've had a dark epiphany of some sort. That next scene fades in. Character is on the beach, looking a bit haggard and deep in thought. They toss a stone into the ocean as they stare at the empty horizon. Then as they slowly walk along the shoreline a look of acceptance appears on their face, perhaps the beginning of a smile....you know they'll be okay....roll credits Go ahead a pick a song on this depressing ass album and you have the soundtrack for that scene.

Its okay

I've never really loved Neil Young's voice, he has some nice Harmony in there and I get why he's a classic but it's just not my thing

Fine, I wasn't overly impressed

first listen it was meh to me i really liked the song “on the beach” tho

tipico rock and roll clasico tranquilo, ta bien pero nada del otro mundo

Just ok

Pretty nice, the drumming is awful though. I love Neil’s songwriting and vocals tho. The other musicians are ok.

Wasn't familiar with this album. Not all that memorable, but I didn't dislike it.

Love Neil but not this album

More Neil Young, just a day after Rust? Sorry, the voice just grates. 2 again for his influence

As someone who generally enjoys folk music, this didn't do it for me. The only thing keeping me rating it lower is that the last two tracks of the album were pretty damn good. So it at least ended on a good note. Otherwise though, it felt bland as hell.

Yeah, Neil Young. Never really my thing. OK, I suppose.

There's songs that I love by Neil Young, but man this album really was boring. Not really anything memorable outside of 2 songs, and even then those weren't anywhere close to his best. I can't say this really gave me beach vibes either. 2/5

Notable Textzeile: Yes, that was me with the doves, setting them free near the factory Where you build your computer love I hope you get the connection 'cause I can't take the rejection I won't deceive you, I just don't believe you Langsam gewöhne ich mich an Neil Young, und ich weiß gar nicht ob ich das möchte. Aber dieses Album geht deutlich besser als viele andere die mir hier reingestopft wurden. Irgendwann wird das aber selbst bei 39 Min lang, der Punkt bei mir war genau in der Mitte von „On the beach“. Warum ist das 7 Minuten. Warum ist das überhaupt. Vielleicht hätte er öfter 2 oder mehr Jahre Pause machen sollen zwischen Alben? Ich hab wirklich überlegt dem 3 Sterne zu geben, aber da wurden es doch wieder nur 2. Weil dieser Mensch einfach zu viel schreibt und zu oft hier drauf ist.

Neil Young is the Trina Vega of soft-rock - the music behind him is actually not bad, clearly there is genuine musical talent here, but he's singing like someone who thinks they're really really good, when they're really not. His voice is tinny and feeble, which makes everything whiny and limp. Give it up, Delicious, keep that microphone on the guitar, make the album fully instrumental, and we'll call it square.

187. ok

Rather underwhelmed with this album. I love Harvest Moon but know little else from Neil Young. This felt very middle of the road and uninspiring.

Some of the jams are good but a bit of a dull back to back listen.

Benlik değil

Fand ich öde.

Neil Young isn't really my bag. I find his vocal quality just north of, say, Bob Dylan? I got into maybe one track, 'revolution blues.' Possibly the only song here with any real energy.

How did this guy get 6 albums on the list? CanCon popularity?

This didn’t sound like the beach at all. Worse yet, it was terribly boring. I’ve had about five albums Neil Young is in some way credited on and this has got to be the driest….just like the sand of the beach? Was that what he was going for?

Sons muito bons e letras legais

I found this album slightly boring, if I'm being honest. There wasn't much pulling me in, and nothing to really keep me wanting to listen. I think the vocals were okay, but the main thing that stood out to me was the sort of classic synth sound used in a few of the tracks. It added a nice layer to the songs. Unfortunately, that didn't make up for the lack of interest I had throughout the album. It's a shame, as I was really wanting to enjoy this. Songs that stood out: See the Sky About to Rain For the Turnstiles Motion Pictures (For Carrie)

My 2nd Neil Young album and I am not a fan of the guy. Have no idea how he got 7 albums on here while making some of the blandest songs ever made. His voice irritates me so much, especially on slower songs. I liked some of the instrumental, but any enjoyment I would have is ruined by Neil's whiny voice. Favorite Track - Revolution Blues Least Favorite Track - For The Turnstiles ⭐️⭐️

One of the Neil Young albums of all time

Really wanted to like this more. Just didn't. Sorry.

Oh god, not looking forward to this… oh f*. That album cover is torture. Oh… I am going to try to be open minded, really. Om Man, this is saved in my albums, so I made myself listen to this already. Well… can you tell I am not feeling Neil? Idk. I need to stop flailing about and just dive in… You know Neil, you ARE a vampire. Sucking the joy from my very being. I know, I know, how can I say that about NEIL YOUNG? The beloved NEIL YOUNG. Well you know what? He doesn’t get better for me. He gets more annoying and aggravating. He needs a crowd of people, but he can’t face them day to day. Yeah. I hear you. It’s like me facing this album. God, he’ll get a 2. I want to give him a 1, but I can’t. He’s insightful. I mean I get it. But the delivery brings me down. And buries me beneath the sand. Boolean: yes mom, I suppose so

So far, we have made many sober observations about Neil Young. But a long, bank holiday weekend is no time for sobriety. Neither is there time to waste in thinking too hard about On the Beach, when there is a beach near-by and two dogs that need walking. Better than Ragged Glory. Not so good as Rust Never Sleeps. The appearance of Levon Helm and Rick Danko genuinely makes a difference on their one song, but it is only one song, which is not enough. 1.5 Thank goodness we got a Neil Young album this weekend. I was devoting so much time and thought to why I don’t like Pet Shop Boys’ Actually that I was very grateful for an album that I could prejudge so easily. Still - Neil is just about as good as he gets when he is being morose, as he is on the second half of this album. He’s a dreadful guitar player but it works for him when he is in that mood. The pitiable saw-work of his right hand on Motion Pictures or the laborious picking on Ambulance Blues sits nicely with the image of an old man - the arthritis pushing between him and his venerable acoustic - sitting ill-postured on the porch thinking back on his victories and regrets. While the ducks are callin’. Oh to be 29 and shit at guitar. And singing of course. 1.5/5

Another Neil Young. I'm not sure what this is doing here tbh. It's fine as it is, but I don't see it contributing anything that isn't done better by another NY album. It's probably perfectly fine in isolation, but I got to the end and shrugged. Gets a 2 because it's not utterly offensive, just a bit dull.

possibly the best of the neil young albums we've had, though thats not saying much

meh

the goats are The Board

ok

You can tell that Mike Scott has heard this. Revolution Blues is the mother of Be My Enemy.

The combination of whiny vocals and more or less the same arrangements every song. Certainly an acquired taste

Bit dull for me might have to give it a relisten as it seems to have really good reviews but imo its incredibly slow and lacks a bit of edge. Loved the song ambulance blues though the vocal melody was brilliant

It was not for me

4/10 - unfortunately quite boring, luckily it's not too long

Had interesting moments. But I think I need to face it — this project isn’t going to make me love Neil Young or Bob Dylan, no matter how many albums it forces me to listen to. I thought this album was different. I even kind of enjoyed the first couple of songs. But then it alternated between whiny and boring. I don’t know. I guess I’m an uncultured swine. 3/10 Ho Hum

I wasn't paying enough attention while listening to this album, but when I was, it was not very interesting

Do I know Neil young? Yes. Could I name a song? No. Did I enjoy this album? Also no.

de grote hoeveelheid neil young in de lijst doet erg af aan de ervaring, en die is al niet veel soeps

it's fine

I liked this album. I listened to it as I was packing up to move out from my student house. I liked the following songs: Walk On Vampire Blues

Look, I get that this list is full of Young aficionados, but 1001 is making me realize I like his music LESS than I previously thought. If any one of us with a guitar and three chords TRIED to get a listen from any label with these songs, we'd legitimately get thrown out on our ass. I know some Young, I didn't know this album, and came away realizing I didn't need to. All love to those who like NY, but it would be a very long pitch to get me over to your side with LPs like this.

I went in with an open mind and wow. The vibes were right, the singing was not. This album would gain an extra 2 stars if it was just instrumentals instead of his out of tune singing. Maybe I’ll come back to this, will have to see how his other work is. Always baffles me how these people can get famous on such mediocre skill.

2 Neil Young albums in a row? REALLY???

Another Neil Young album - but this one was a little bit better. I still don't like Neil Young.

It's hard to tell if Neil Young is angry sometimes. He certainly doesn't sound the part. The theme here wasn't missed on me or anything, as Mr. Young was obviously successful at this point already and I sure he struggled to grapple with each of the things (good or bad) that came with said success and stardom. I guess it just isn't the most relatable piece of work. When undergoing this album challenge, you simply have no choice but to be exposed to Neil Young and I think his more spirited works were behind him at this point.

If Bob Dylan was more melancholic. Not a bad album but a bit drawn out imo. I like the album cover though, very nice image. Favourite tracks: For The Turnstiles, Vampire Blues 2.5/5

Neil young is proof you don’t need to be able to sing or play guitar to be a successful singing guitarist

hm, i think it was a decent album. musically it was amazing and really sets a "sitting in front of the porch, drinking iced tea" vibe, not too much beach imo. liked, but wouldn't rave about it!

Not so much my style. The album cover though!

Listening to this feels like the sonic equivalent to the episode of Documentary Now! where Hader freeassociates the entire episode

Why is Neil back again. Please leave. I guess this record in particular is a little bit better than the rest, but still I hate this guys voice.

Whether he's on a stash, with a horse, whether it's tonight, or on a beach, I just can't get into Neil Young. Every time I think "this has to be the last time I will listen to albums with Neil Young in it", just to find out they're like Russian Nesting dolls. Look, I really want to like Neil Young's music. I grew up listening to "Southern Man", and "Ohio", he was ahead of his time, and from a political standpoint, he's adept. However, his clever songwriting is brought down by his extremely dull instrumental play, and lifeless production. Favorite Track: "For The Turnstiles".

I had never heard this before, although I had heard _of_ it. I like "Vampire Blues." Overall, though, it doesn't grab me enough to want to listen to it again right away. Maybe it just doesn't fit my mental state today. The album cover does exactly match the vibe of the music, though.

I can only guess the nasal drawl comes from having a stick so far up his arse its exiting a nostril?

Kind of forgettable.

Ittje denne stranda....

I don't know what makes this special? Fine, I guess.

Ok

Walk on was fave tune

no sería mi primera opción pero es un buen album

Neil young just doesn't do it for me. Boring, whiny, not my vibe.

Boring

Ok

Walk on On the beach Revolution blues Vampire blues

Not great. It's like a shit Rolling Stones for me.

I...I didn't hate this?

Yup it’s a Neil Young album.

Sets the bar high with walk on. Doesnt come close after that.

Not for me.

Meh, it's okay.

a primeira música é bem boa, mas vai caindo no decorrer do álbum. neil young não é mesmo para mim.

meh. mid. the carrie soundtrack one and the one about vampires kind of saved it

This was ok but not something I would Go back to

Huh. I thought I liked Neil Young more than this. Disappointing.

Hippy wallowing. Annoying drone.

Not for me, didn't mind some of the blues-y tracks but nothing that blew me away. 0/8 songs liked.

Mid album from an amazing artist.

Not my cup of tea. Never really liked Neil Young and I tried to go into this album with an open mind, but I just couldn't get into it

I think the songwriting is pretty good here and an improvement on the early stuff, but I can't get behind Neil Young as a frontman at all. Was highly anticipating the last song as I've heard some good covers but it was not enjoyable to listen to. Just disappointing, I think better than the early stuff but still not there yet

Boring

..

Ну опять скукотень. Это лучший альбом Янга?. Почему он в этом списке7

Very '70s. The sound of this era irritates me. Quite boring.

he has better ones for sure why is this here

A collection of ordinary and mostly dull rock songs, lacking the distinctive songcraft of *After The Gold Rush* or *Harvest*. (When three of the song titles are "Revolution Blues", "Vampire Blues" and "Ambulance Blues", the outlook for any kind of inventive rock and roll is pretty dire.) Only the title track conjures up any kind of atmosphere (though the lyrics are typical rock star navel-gazing.)

Never been a huge fan of Neil Young, not sure this album changes anything. Decent music but his voice just grates one me. I mean pretty boring stuff but would probably be a chill album to listen to if you were on the beach. Nothing offensive but nothing that really stands out either.

great, now there are *two* beaches that can make you old.

Dit klinkt niet veel beter dan het bandje van zestigers dat op je lokale wijkfeest staat op te treden terwijl zo'n 3 buurmannen met een biertje in de hand hun hoofd net uit de maat staan mee te knikken. 2/5

Some good songs, but ultimately held back by Neil Young's atrocious singing.

Ok

If he just had someone else sing his songs, they could be so good.

No

Being a huge fan of Neil Young I was disappointed by the album. The album opens with the song walk on and quickly goes downhill from there.

Always ends up near the top when people rank Neil Young but it’s just kinda there for me. Still Neil Young so still better than most things.

Solid songwriting and guitar tones. But oof, Neil Young’s voice was grating me on this one.

Oh Neil Young again🙄

A little ramshackle and insecure. But in a good way. I am an avowed Neil fan, but I had never heard much from this album. I'm not surprised by its obscurity.

Grating

Didn’t quite do something for me. Although the turnstiles song is fun, I could hear the influence he had on Jack White

Sounds like music I’d listen to at a geezer pub. Best paired with low energy and a proper ale

“It was such a drag to hear him whining all night long” van het liedje revolution blues is lowkey hoe ik me voelde toen ik naar dit album luisterde

Neil Young's voice isn't for me.

Neil Young's voice went from bad to worse as this album went through, and the quality of music following IMO. He's kind of approaching Bob Dylan territory for me.

Just kinda meh tbh, there's really nothing that good here

I have to be in the mood to listen to Neil Young, sometimes he makes me sleepy

Meh. I didn’t dislike this as much as I thought I would but I didn’t like it either. While I enjoy Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, I never really got into Neil Young. His voice is a bit too whiny for me and the music all blends together. Nothing for my ears to hold onto. Standout song: Walk On. 01-09-2026 My puzzle nook, The Tree of Life 500pc

not exactly my type but vibey

I liked Vampire Blues. Not really my style

I used to really like him, his banjo and guitar are good, but boy his voice gets on my nerves

Not as good as the other album

Whelming album. I do like Neil Young and to be fair I think his music is the sort to build appreciation of over many listens, but I'm a braindead zombie zoomer (zoombie?) with no time nor attention span. fav tracks: See the Sky About to Rain, Vampire Blues

Revolution Blues landed! The rest didn't...

This was just boring man, I mean the opener was pretty good but otherwise it kind of just faded into the background and didn't make much of an impression on me at all. Not gonna come back to this one even if it wasn't the worst

This album is easy listening except it’s not easy. No standouts, instrumentals are okay but his voice does not sound good.

Neil Young is at his best when he is angry and that angst comes through in the songs, and I didn't hear nearly enough of that on this record. Revolution Blues was an excellent track, but that was about it for me on this record. Many of the softer/slower songs just weren't that good. Part of it is that Young's voice is so unique, which can be a cool thing at times, but I found it just off putting on this record.

Not my kind of music. Nice voice though.

This would be such a great list if you enjoyed Neil Young. Its just too much Neil Young for me.

I'm informed that this "is a folk rock album exploring themes of anger, alienation, nihilism and cautious optimism." Oh great, that with Neil Young's whiny voice. For some reason I find him less whiny and annoying here than usual. Still didn't like it though.

j'ai pas trop aimé

I can see why people like this, and I enjoyed a couple of the songs, but for the most part I found this pretty boring. On the Beach (the song) drags on forever. I have come to the conclusion that American folk music is unrelatable to me. Idk why exactly, but when folk music relies so much on relatibility, that makes most of the genre a pretty tough listen. I like other forms of folk music, there's some great Aussie folk music out there, and Irish folk music, but US folk sucks. I think it might be because a lot of US folk music has this self importance to it that makes me just wanna throw up.

I’m not crazy about Neil Young… and this did very little to move the needle for me. That said, I recognize Neil’s contributions and importance. It’s just not for me. Southern man didn’t need him ‘round anyhow.

Just not interesting to me at all. Not bad sounding by any means though.

Please stop with this man. We’ve got 1001 albums to listen to and he deserves TWO?!

Neil’s voice is grating at times

149 Stop trying to make Neil Young happen. Sabía que había escuchado algo de él antes, pero fue el Harvest que me gustó harto, por la producción que tenía. Ahora tuve que tomar como 10 espressos para terminar de escucharlo.

Sooooooo boring

Neil Young.... It got a 2 star because it was somehow better than expected... But barely.

Ett mediokert dussinalbum av Neil, trots en del fina medmusikanter. Men avsaknaden av bra låtar är markant. Det låter Neil Young men inte mer än så. Knappt godkänt

Ovanligt albumval ur Young-katalogen. Jag tror aldrig jag hört den. See the sky är bra med sitt tremolopiano och steelgitarr. Titelspåret är också bra, men håller inte riktigt i 7 minuter. I övrigt låter det tyvärr rätt ofärdigt och ogenomarbetat. Inga riktiga arrangemang i låtarna, de bara pågår.

En lite souligare Neil. Inte utan att man tänker på Van the man. Om än på en lägre nivå. Trivsamt utan att riktigt tända till.

Kind of meh. Niel Young was better when he was with CSNY

It was fine … Neil Young may be a great songwriter, but he is not a great singer.

Some of it's pretty good. Some of it is even more whiney than regular Neil Young.

Köyhän miehen Bob Dylan! No ei kai, ihan menevää folk country mitälie samanlaista

1. uualk - 1 2. zky -1.5 3. bluez -1.5 4. turn - 1.5 5. vampire - 1 6. beach - 1.5 7. motion -1.5 8. ambulance - 1.5

2 out of 5 Pretty slow.

- Bwa, niet slecht maar ook niet memorabel - 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM - 0 nummer al toegevoegd aan MMMM - 2*

Bit too soft and slow

How much more Neil Young will I be forced to endure?

Songs to fall asleep on the beach too. Beware, Melatonin Blues was a working title!

Nothing standing out much tbh

I really don't know what to think about this album. I'm a Neil Young fan much like I'm a Bob Dylan fan. I think they are both musical geniuses, but I would not go to their concerts or listen to a whole album. I prefer the 5-6 iconic songs they each sing and the many other songs they wrote that other artists sing.

Eh

Not bad to have on in the background.

Clunky, uninspiring, and has done nothing to dispel my dislike of his rather feeble voice. There were one or two brighter moments but then I realised these were the adverts.

Some of this is quite funky (for dad music) and others of it is jingly jangly nasal ennui.

Another Neil Young album...meh. The final track is terrible and drones on for nearly 9 minutes. Thank goodness it's over

Ok

I didn’t like this at all. I actually dreaded it after about 3 mins in.

Alright. Not my thing

Hoo boy that was a slog. Just such. Slow. Music. And I guess I don't like his voice that much.

Cuppa, this is not.

This sounds like Neil Young. Albeit a bit more chipper, at least at the start. Having heard another of his (or is it two) from this list already, I do feel that if you've heard on, you've heard them all. Seventies rock. Not really my thing.

Neil Young has better albums than this. It was not that exciting.

Hate his voice.

one million dune buggies. The last song was good

Not that anyone reads these, but if they did, I would be chased outta town for saying this: Neil Young is the most overrated singer/songwriter/rocker in history. I do not, for the most part, enjoy his music, regardless of the iteration. This album is no different.

A couple of tracks on this are OK because he doesn't sing much.

Pretty good, but not quite there yet. It does have an intriguing cover though.

This album was almost interesting

I know the guy's a legend, but entire Neil Young albums all the way through kind of bore me. For this one, I feel like if you asked a reasonably robust AI to craft a Neil Young album circa 1973-1974 this is what it'd come up with.

Ugh. I know he is revered and all that but I just can’t past his whiney old man vocals. Do not like.

I gave it an extra star with the hopes that it is celebrating the last fucking Neil Young album I have to listen to. Used to go to the bridge school show's when they were a thing in the Bay Area. A great thing about Neil Young closing every show was that it was a great way to beat the traffic leaving the shoreline amphitheater.

Neil young is a silly liberal

Pretty mid but easy listening while I was working on a project 5/10

Good for background music; sad, a bit wistful music.

I still just don't particularly care for Neil Young. I wish I saw what so many others seem to. He just doesn't grab me and I guess I'm missing out.

you again? I thought I liked Neil. I don't know why but he's starting to annoy me.

Fun cover. Miserable album

Not sure how I feel this album, certain parts were good, others felt too repetitive and boring. It’s not album that I would replay or add into my playlist.

I have never really given Neil Young much time. This was enjoyable, but forgettable.

2,5/5. Могло быть интереснее, будь я любителем жанра.

Ok

Meh

Is that his real voice?

More warbling from Neil Young. I really liked track 2, but what else will I remember from one casual cursory stroll on the beach? It’s monotonous after awhile.

Quebecois's Review : Moi qui déteste amèrement tout le travail de Niel Young, c'est son album le plus écoutable. Translation : I do hate all the work of Niel Young, but this is his most listenable album.

Why are there so many Neil Young albums on this list!!!! I just don’t get it

This has got to be the most boring music of all time.

Ikke min smak

Another Young album, and I still cannot fathom his voice. Additionally, this is way too much country folk for my taste.

Whining voice, hated it

3/10

Look, I'm just not a big Neil Young fan, okay? So maybe let's pump the brakes a little bit, just pick one or two of his albums, and be done with it. I actually liked a few of these songs more I than I thought I would. I attribute this to the stellar musicians around him, rather than Young himself.

Just like every Neil Young album. Drab and pretentious.

It kind of just came and went I was listening to it. I'm not that familiar with Neil Young's entire output but I don't think this particular album belongs on this list and the rating reflects that stance. It's not particularly bad sounding to me but it doesn't stand out.

This albums sounds was kinda all over the place. The second half was better than the first, surprisingly.

meh

C’est non pour moi, je comprends l’intérêt mais ça me fait chier

Meh

Sorry, this just isn't doing it for me. I can tell it's not that bad or anything, just... really not my cup of tea.

At first it had good vibes, then it almost put me to sleep. Blah.

Neil Young was sadly not the vibe today. Now, the instrumentations and atmosphere were actually pretty great! I just don't think they were unique enough to warrant tolerating Young's singing style, which felt more like rambling than anything else. For The Turnstiles was an especially rough listen. I'm sure I could eventually warm up to this album and enjoy it, because it certainly had some cool stuff going on. Maybe a future Neil Young project will win me over, who knows. Standout: On The Beach

Folk-y, country-esque, rock. It was fine, didn't really stick out to me. 2.4

..

Not gonna lie, when I saw that 3 songs on this album ended in the word ‘blues’, I shouted ‘Oh Fuck Off!’ Out loud (to no one in my empty flat). First half of this album is fairly listenable. Second half is utterly bland and forgettable. Some of the guitar work was fun, and Neil is a good singer. But yet another early 70s artist cranking out album after album of pure mid who would have been far better served dropping and album ever 2-3 years and actually saving the ‘good’ tracks for a better album. Do we really need an 8 minute track about riding in a fucking ambulance?! Walk On (7/10) See the Sky About to Rain (7/10) Revolution Blues (7/10) For the Turnstiles (7/10) Vampire Blues (5/10) On the Beach (5/10) Motion Pictures (For Carrie) (5/10) Ambulance Blues (5/10) 6/10

bit of a snoozefest really...

They should really call this the 956 Albums To Hear Before You Die Plus Neil Young’s Whole Fucking Discography. Christ all mighty, how many of this cunt’s albums do I really need to hear????

Nice!

To dull. So are some of Young's albums that I like. But nothing hit me on this album.

Lovely! Not exactly my jam, but I appreciate the artistry.

Really should’ve given this album a little more time, only gave it one quick listen. I thought I few of the songs were pretty similar to the Beatles but apart from that I found it underwhelming. My favourite song was ‘motion pictures(for Carrie)

Unimpressive

Meh, not my jam, but not terrible. I did find myself wanting it to be over though.

I think Neil Young is a twitter yapper born 50 years too early. There seems to be a lot of vague jabs at critics, lots of lyrics coming from a bitter place. I’m not too sure this deserves a spot on the list. Unless you’re involved in the career drama of Neil Young, a lot of this might pass right through your ears - it did for me. I liked the twangy guitar and the baseball reference on “For The Turnstiles”. I also appreciated the melancholy, low-lying mood of “Motion Pictures”. That’s about it though. I don’t have much to say for this one, nothing stuck with me.

Man, it must be hard to fill out a list this long.

I like Neil Young but I have no idea why this particular album made the list.

I generally have a high tolerance for Neil but this cut right through it.

This was fine. A little too "laid back" for me. Neil Young's voice to me is often wavering and is almost whiny in this album (he has some songs that counter this that are not on this record.) It isn't bad. I just found myself bored at times. The instrumentals are solid. Nothing flashy, but not bad. "Walk On" was the best track. Liked Songs: "Walk On" , "Revolution Blues" , "Motion Pictures (For Carrie)"

Clearly the best at what he does but I've no interest

He has much better albums.

I have not heard much Neil Young. I am familiar with the hits that were standard fare on the classic rock stations but have never listened to an entire album by him. I find this ok. The music is pleasing especially the acoustic guitar playing. The lyrics on the majority of the songs are just so-so to me. 2.25/5

Neil Young a big blind spot for me. I think I have liked all the Neil Young songs I have heard in my life, but I have never done a deep dive or even listened to a full album, I don't think? Excited for this one. Walk On > See The Sky About To Rain > Ambulance Blues > For the Turnstiles > Revolution Blues > Vampire Blues > On The Beach > Motion Pictures for Carrie Oh yeah okay there are some duds on here but wow the first two tracks had me thinking this was gonna be a 4. Walk On is really good. Also an 8 song album? Come on, where's the value, Neil my man??

not really a fan of his voice

I don't like these types of songs. Listened to 2 songs, find it very boring. Sorry for not being cool xD

I grew up listening to Neil Young, but my dad never played this album for me. It's Neil's blues album, which is fine. However, I prefer his music that's closer to rock n roll. The only track that stood out was Revolution Blues.

Didn't reach the highs of Harvest Moon

Not a fan

Meh. Neil Young's got some good songs, and I used to be into him much more. Now, all I hear is whining. 2/5.

None of these tracks do it for me, nothing memorable and far too slow. I can see the appeal but definitely not for me.

Pretty laid-back album. Had a good vibe, just not crazy about his voice all the way through. I fell asleep at the end too. 2/5

Nie echt zo mijn ding

3eme album avec NY proposé par le générateur. Pas mieux que les deux autres, rien d'original. J'ai vite fait autre chose en le laissant en musique de fond. =>2/5

Meh, I don’t think this is Neil’s greatest work. I’m not a huge fan, but I’m not not a fan either…this just seemed pretty run-of-the-mill to Me.

Pretty dull.

Not his best album

He's had better.

Honestly so mid. Wouldn't relisten

Why is there so much Neil Young on this list?! It's not bad, but it just doesn't do anything for me. He has always felt kind of whiney to me. I like his stuff better that he did with CSNY. I kind of dug the mellow guitar and bongo drums on "On the Beach" though. Good laid back summer night kind of song.

not that into it

Didn't appeal to me, 1.7

What the fuck is this list's deal with this fucking guy?

It's ok

One or two relatively bright moments amongst a monotony of shite! I really don't understand how this list has so many of his albums (including Crazy Horse etc). His singing voice just grates. Musically, the vast majority of what he churns out could be made by countless 'geezer and a guitar' types up and down the country. I did listen to the whole album, so it gets 2 stars. But please, no more Neil Young on this list, please, I beg you!

Guitar licenses should be revoked after a certain age

headache blues

Average

ok

Really get nothing out of this, he has better stuff

Never really listened to Neil Young, he removed his music from Spotify about a year ago in protest and tbh I probably wouldn’t have noticed it’s disappearance. Anyway it’s back now as he must’ve ran out of money after realising maybe he isn’t as relevant as he thinks. On to the actual album, it was listenable, the lyrics always seemed a bit random. Maybe I just don’t get it but I feel I don’t get that same energy as I do from other people in his genre. I probably wouldn’t care to listen again, but I suppose the title track was ok. But that’s about it, not revolutionary, not interesting, and no real good tunes to add to any playlists.

Reminded me of CCR, Cat Stevens, and Bob Dylan. I liked it but not enough that I'd listen to it again.

Honestly this album is so…. Bland? Nor much to talk about it is good background music lmao Fav: Revolution Blues

Alright but not my deal

70er yoar musi und klingt ois gleich heast

I can't make my mind up about Neil Young. I keep wanting to write him off, then there'll be a track that piques my interest, and then the harmonica hits... argh!

Not for me

If I was to have a Neil Young album which I truly liked and put it into my top 20 it would be a self compiled compilation from all his many releases. I can just about find one album’s worth of great track from his complete discography. None of the tracks on this album would make it which is the problem I have with Neil Young. I find the majority of his work self indulgent and boring. As many have commented his voice is on the whiny side and becomes annoying after a while. But every so often (but not recently) he comes up with a stellar song which goes way beyond his standard stuff. As I say not on this album though. Great album cover which has more of a British seaside vibe than I guess a USA one where it was actually taken. 2/5 12/1/25

Not bad but not that interesting. I don’t think I will be listening to this album again any time soon. Best track: See the sky about to rain (although this has a very similar tune to “Heart of Gold”, which is better)

It was okay

not really my vibe but ok. i like motion pictures for carrie

Man I really don’t like Neil Young’s more rock focused albums. Someone should have taken this guys amps away from him a long long time ago. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, Neil Young should only perform or record by himself with an acoustic guitar. I’m not even sure what it is, but the second you put a band behind this guy he becomes almost unlistenable to me. I liked the banjo in “For The Turnstiles”. Didn’t care for the exaggerated off key vocal style. “Vampire Blues” is a hypocritical hit piece aimed squarely at the oil industry, I wonder what Neil would have his records pressed on if we didn’t have vinyl anymore. “Motion Pictures(for Carrie)” and “Ambulancee Blues” are the only redeeming tracks on the record. Much simpler and stripped down music that lends itself very well to Neil’s musical talent, and frankly the forte he should have always stuck to. 2*

The song “On the Beach” was good in spite of Neil’s vocals. The rest of the album isn’t interesting enough to get past that whiny warble.

I love Neil Young, but this was boring as shit.

I think the story about the making of this album is far more entertaining than this album. For the Turnstiles was a cool song.

Whiney bob Dylan. The more I listen to him the less I like him

This was fine, I guess.

Dont love neil young

I just can’t listen to his voice.

One day I will understand the appeal of Neil Young.

Liked it better than the 90s one but I just can't get into his voice

Snooze

did not enjoy

Not a fan and I don't care for Neil Young's voice. Some of the music was ok, then he'd start singing and ruin it for me.

Honestly I just find Neil Young boring.

Starts off so promising, thinking maybe I finally "get" the Neil Young hype. Then it goes into his usual drivel with almost terrible instrumentation *sigh* Fuck is he doing with so many goddamn albums on here? Also it is not a 1 purely because there are a couple shining moments, so it wasn't purely crap. That the Neil Young experience. 2 good songs. Yay

Was kinda surprised by how much he sounds like John Lennon at times. As interesting as that is, I didn't love this. 2/5

I wasn't looking forward to yet another endurance test of whether I could go the distance having to endure Neil's shitty voice. This one was a real surprise, because midway through he abandoned his nasally whine for a lower register, which was *great*. Unfortunately, he did so in service of some of the most boring and meandering songs I've ever heard. Not sure what was beach-like about it. Music to drown yourself to?

Whiny Blues Rock.

такой прям софт софт софт, у меня к сожалению сегодня настроение было на хард хард хард

Lo tenia de fondo, no presté mucha atención. Ni bien ni mal

ugh, more boring, boomer-nostalgia drivel from neil. i think this is the sixth album of his I've listened to on this list so far and I've liked one of them. there's just nothing interesting here. all the songs sound the same. the lyrics are uninspired. his voice is in its typical annoying form. i listened all the way through and found that i hadn't liked a single song, so i listened to a few more and found the least boring, walk on, to include in my favorites. lol. also lol at the top commenter who gave this two stars because they felt personally attacked that his music wasn't on spotify. how DARE neil young take a stance against a predatory megacorporation that doesn't pay its artists fairly! didn't he stop to think about how this would affect ME? favorites: walk on

a little dull

STANDOUTS: n/a and DNF OVERALL: 2/5; no critical thoughts. Just bland.