Reviews (page 3 of 7)
Liked Randy Newman for his comedic novelty songs and musical scores, but was not aware of this album. Good Old Boys is an anthology of the American Songbook that we Americans would like to sweep under the rug. An all too poignant look at American history through the clear eyes of a poet willing to expose the uncomfortable truths.
Strong songwriting that’s well delivered. The level of satire is just a little too high for me, but definitely a worthy inclusion.
It's hard to hate Randy Newman.. Just fun music. Love it.
Rednecks almost permits me to forgive Randy Newman for Short People which, as a very small kid, was traumatizing. The rest of the record is pure Newman which is to say really well crafted vignettes which veer from biting to funny to sweet sung in his sort-of-New Orleans tinged rasp to his piano.
Didn't know anything about this other than Randy Newman was the guy who did the songs for Toy Story. That said, I was surprised by how much I liked this. It was funny, biting, and a little mean. But I really enjoyed it.
Much better than I expected. Easy to listen to. Well written album when you know it's satirical
Un equilibrio perfecto entre canciones divertidas y hermosas baladas. Unidas por un clásico sonido de piano Jazz. Las canciones más alegres me hacen acordar a "yo soy tu amigo fiel" de Toy Story
Talk about getting hit with it off the bat with Randy throwing down the n-word. The whole concept of the album is unique and he puts together a solid indictment of how we treat race relations, and relations between the north and the south in this country. Probably won't listen to this too much in the future, but definitely well done.
Only knew Randy Newman from the Toy Story song so to hear Rednecks for the first time was real whip lash. Great concept album, beautiful music
Toy Story Songs - My dad loved "short people" by him, so we listen to him a lot growing up. Being short, we totally laughed about it.
A compelling chronicle of the South. This album has a cinematic feel, a foreshadowing of Newman's move into film soundtracks later in his career.
Randy coming in hot with the hottest diss track of 1974! Made me chuckle quite a bit how tongue in cheek and over the top some of the southerner POV lyrics are. 7/10
Letkeetä saluuna rockia. Hyvää rekkailumusaa. Parhaat: Rednecks, Kingfish
Enjoyable. The first song would probably get him canceled today.
One of the all time greatest American songwriters.
Ok, wow, "Rednecks" made my eyebrows jump up over my scalp and end up on the back of my head. 😆 I'm grateful to the reviewer that mentioned Newman set out to make "dinner party music that you can’t play at dinner parties", because that adds some great context. I definitely need to revisit "Sail Away" as it was one of the very first albums I got through this project and at that point I was giving them a single listen, and was distracted to boot. This one I gave two spins, but still, it was while working and I probably need to be paying more attention to the lyrics. Fave track - as well as "Rednecks", "Back On My Feet Again" and "Rollin'" stood out...
Like most people, I only knew Randy Newman as the Toy Story guy... Omg did I have my expectations smashed apart and then run over. Shocked in a good way, that I had to stop and listen/read the lyrics and research references. Department store music you definitely can't actually play at a department store.
Randy Newman's 1974 album "Good Old Boys" is a masterful exploration of the American South, delivering a poignant and satirical take on its cultural, political, and societal nuances. Through a blend of clever lyrics, distinctive music, and meticulous production, Newman crafts a complex narrative that simultaneously entertains and challenges listeners. Lyrics: One of the standout features of "Good Old Boys" is Newman's exceptional songwriting. The lyrics are a potent mix of biting satire, social commentary, and vivid storytelling. The album is essentially a character study, with Newman adopting various personas to explore the complexities of Southern life. Tracks like "Rednecks" and "Birmingham" showcase his ability to delve into controversial subjects, addressing racism and prejudice with a sharp wit that both confronts and disarms. The use of irony and humor throughout the album adds depth, making the lyrics simultaneously thought-provoking and entertaining. Music: Musically, "Good Old Boys" is a rich tapestry that weaves together elements of Americana, country, and blues. Newman's piano-centric arrangements provide a distinctive backdrop, complemented by skilled instrumentation that captures the essence of the Southern landscape. The use of horns, strings, and a variety of traditional instruments adds layers to the sound, creating a dynamic listening experience. Newman's soulful and emotive vocals bring the characters to life, enhancing the storytelling aspect of the album. Production: Produced by Lenny Waronker and Russ Titelman, "Good Old Boys" benefits from a meticulous and well-crafted production. The careful balance between Newman's vocals and the instrumental arrangements allows each element to shine. The production captures the raw, authentic feel of the Southern environment while maintaining a polished and professional sound. The attention to detail is evident, enhancing the narrative and emotional impact of each track. Themes: The thematic core of "Good Old Boys" revolves around the complexities of Southern identity, politics, and culture. Newman dissects the contradictions and challenges of the region, offering a nuanced perspective that goes beyond stereotypes. The album delves into issues such as racism, poverty, and the clash between tradition and progress. Newman's exploration of the Southern psyche is both critical and compassionate, revealing the multifaceted nature of the characters and themes he presents. Influence: "Good Old Boys" stands as a significant influence on subsequent generations of musicians and songwriters. Newman's ability to blend humor and social commentary has been a hallmark of his career, and this album showcases that skill at its peak. The storytelling approach, combined with the diverse musical elements, has inspired artists across genres. The impact of "Good Old Boys" can be heard in the works of musicians who appreciate the power of lyrics to convey profound messages within a musical framework. Pros: Lyrical Brilliance: The album's lyrics are a standout feature, showcasing Newman's ability to address serious issues with intelligence and humor. Musical Diversity: The blend of Americana, country, and blues creates a unique and engaging musical landscape. Narrative Cohesion: The album's thematic consistency and character-driven approach contribute to a cohesive and immersive listening experience. Innovative Production: The meticulous production enhances the emotional impact of the songs, capturing the essence of the Southern setting. Cons: Polarizing Content: Some listeners may find the album's exploration of controversial topics uncomfortable or divisive. Acquired Taste: Newman's vocal style and the album's satirical approach may not resonate with everyone, requiring an open mind and appreciation for nuanced storytelling. In conclusion, "Good Old Boys" is a timeless and influential work that continues to captivate audiences with its lyrical depth, musical richness, and social commentary. Randy Newman's ability to navigate complex themes with a blend of satire and sincerity makes this album a classic that transcends its time and remains relevant in the broader landscape of American music.
When I woke up this morning I did not expect to be listening to an album referencing Huey Long, Lester Maddox, and the 1927 Louisiana flood but this was great. Lots to unpack here but the first track really stiff out to me. A searing indictment of both southern racism and northern hypocrisy, if you replaced “Maddox” with “trump” is could work today. “Mr. President” could too. I would have to assume he would not use the n word so liberally today. However I’m not certain what the relistenability of this is so it won’t get a 5.
woke
Album #48 I knew Randy Newman from Toy Story and "Short People", but nothing more. I was very entertained by this. It seemed like good-hearted satire meets Tom Waits writing. Excellent, sometimes uncomfortable writing and very soulful. 4* 4*
Felt like every song had a double meaning. Fun listen.
Classic example of Newman songwriting, storytelling, and satire.
Strange tone.
you got a friend in me, Randy
Randy is interesting. His voice is unique and he's one of those artists where the lyrics are huge. That said I don't love this. I think if I listened to it more it could grow on me. Was going to give it a 3, but I do enjoy some of those lyrics. I'm not a southerner, but I am a rural guy and some of those songs resonated. Give it a 4.
Yeah, what can I say, I love randy
Vähän Lou Reed -viboja.
he says the gamer word
I liked the southern accent paired with the piano. The overall quality was very good.
Enjoyed
Ik mag die Randy wel. Heb hem een keer live mogen zien in de schouwburg. Was een mooi optreden
Has this guy ever done anything else than the toy story sound? Oh well, I really like the toy story sound anyway
Pretty good. Liked it a lot. Love his voice, so distinct. Questionable lyrics at times. But some good songs, good variety despite utilizing the same instruments/sounds.
Listened Before? N This was really interesting. I've heard of him but as far as I know I've never heard a song by him. The first song just rolled out a whole lot of slurs, but with good reason. It really catches your attention and makes you listen to the record. Deep still somewhat relevant political meanings mixed with history. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Naked Man
4.0 - As expected, there are beautiful songs on here showcasing Newman's uncanny knack for writing and performing instant classics. But I don't know that this comes together as a fully fleshed out concept album. I think the album title oversells the Deep South theme. Obviously there are nods throughout but Newman doesn't delve deep. I was expecting some full-on character analysis but instead I got a couple jabs of acerbic satire via "Rednecks." Still a nice record, though.
Randy Newman is nothing if not interesting! I have to say that first song took me by surprise. I was thinking it was going to be a defense of "rednecks", but maybe not so much. Held my interest throughout. 4 stars.
Nice skiva
Kinda reminds me of toy story
Bit of a funny one, kind of smooth and easy but with something to say. Didn’t expect so many N bombs getting dropped here. It made me tap my toes and smile a few times along the way.
4/5. Quite an interesting album. Each song is filled with dread and sadness despite the amazing songwriting of Newman. It is quite unfortunate that the catchiest song is Rednecks. The only fault is that a few songs sound pretty similar and have similar themes. Very close to a 5 though.
Pretty much what I was expecting; Leonard Cohen-esque moody singer-songwritering. Not bad though, and he does have a unique voice and some of the subjects are right on. I do wonder how someone who uses the N-word and sings about cocaine ended up writing "You've Got a Friend in Me," though.
This is great
hey is this the guy from toy story???
That first track a doozy though.
There's a 99% chance you'll how this album starts. Pretty good too.
What an interesting album. So beautiful and touching and after reading about it the lyrics are a lot less shocking. That said, would I listen to this album repeatedly? I’m not sure about that.
Not sure i can sing along with that... a pretty incredible storyteller type album, both satire and situational. Randy Newman has a great casual delivery that hides the seriousness and dark wit. Strong music and melody. This is good.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAerKsv-BvM
didn't know he was the toy story guy, not bad at all
Corrupted Disney. I did like the musical arrangements, but "rednecks" was a shock to the system.
Randy Newman is awesome. How many years ago and "Rednecks" still applies. "we don't know our ass from a hole in the ground" - doesn't apply to the South alone in America, not by a longshot... This music is great - the second Randy album we've had in the first ~500 - again, the kind of music I would have stopped listening to around age 9 and re-appreciated in middle age. Melodic, purposeful, piano-driven, outstanding musical composition, and hilarious (in a sigh-goddammit-pour-a-whiskey way). First pass through it didn't hit me quite as hard as "Sail Away" did but further listens have gotten me to listen more deeply - feel like it will keep growing on me. worthy of a keeper and a very high 4 at minimum... 9/10 4 stars.
Oh, he’s good.
Rollicking and clever. I confess that as wonderful as I find him, Randy Newman songs tend to blend together but in this case I found all the tracks distinct.
Solid concept album. Weird to hear as someone who grew up in the 2000's because all I hear when he speaks is Monsters Inc. and Toy Story. I actually though thought that this album had no bad tracks. My personal favorites here were "Kingfish", "Marie", "Rollin'", "Rednecks" and "Every Man A King". A really great album that I completely unexpected because of my personal experiences with the artist. A solid 8.5/10.
I liked the concept. Not every song was great but there were enough interesting ones to keep my attention. Rednecks is the best one.
It all sounds the same, but it's a nice listen.
Randy shooting buckshot into American culture
Great album great vibes did not expect the hard r
Marie makes me cry, Randy Newman its a completely interpreter, his background band it helps a lot to become emotional while you listen the album. Some songs are just Toy Story soundtrack and i cant think of anything else.
A great listen from Randy as usual. Not a spectacular album but a nice listen from an artist that knows to use words and melody in a very clever way.
My first real listen to Randy Newman. I kept waiting for Buzz and Woody to pop out... He has one of the easiest voices ever and I'll likely check out some other works.
Coming out the gate running with a song that lampoons Southern tropes and frequently uses the N-word, Good Old Boys is Randy Newman at his most historical and illustrative; mapping out the South with his fascinating character studies and stories that would doubtless garner perspective from the listener. If one chooses to get past Rednecks, Good Old Boys will prove itself to be a gem worth hearing. Favorites: Rednecks, Birmingham, Marie, Guilty, Kingfish, Naked Man, A Wedding in Cherokee County, Back on My Feet Again.
J’ai adore l’ecout et bien aime. 4
Really good singer song writer. Good vibe on the album. Unknown artist in Europe for my part.
Not just a soundtrack singer. Who knew?
De eerste keer dat ik een heel album van Randy luister. Mijn introductie tot de man kreeg ik in de voorstelling 'Jan Rot zingt Randy Newman', en in vertaling en met de uitleg van wijlen Jan kreeg je een beeld van wat Newman eigenlijk voor muziek maakt. Nogal ironische teksten op dit album. Het luistert dus het beste om even te teksten te googelen en mee te lezen. Vaak zingt hij in de eerste persoon namens een ander, meestal rechtse types uit de zuidelijke staten van Amerika die hij zo te kakken zet (zie al het eerste nummer, We're rednecks). Louisiana 1927 gaat over een watersnood (had vertaald moeten worden als Zeeland 1953?) De eerste drie nummers zijn door Jan Rot vertaald als Mooi Drenthe, Roosendaal en Marie. Aanrader om die nog ff te luisteren, en in één moeite door het hele album: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XjGd-htIels&list=OLAK5uy_l4S8eDOxnTTV66G6QVFEoagUEYRisBZ78
Part satire of, part sympathy for its subjects, Newman walks a complex tightrope not always with success. For example, if you could listen to Rednecks and sing it as an anthem about yourself, surely the inherent criticism within the satire has failed? And surely there are people proud to stick it to the northern liberal elite by ‘keeping the n-words down‘? Notwithstanding that even in the same song, Newman can’t help but point out the ghettoisation of blacks in northern cities and the conditions in which they live is hardly the success liberals pretend it to be, thus giving further cover to the Redneck racist pride. And if you have to add further songs such as Louisiana to try and explain what you actually think then maybe reconsider what you said in the first place… Newman’s music is sublime throughout, though, taking bluesy roots and New Orleans jazz to concoct an often jovial soundscape in contrast to dark subject matter. And fair enough he wants to explore these subjects and make the audience give some thought to them.
Oh! Randy Newman! The Toy Story guy! This will be a lighthearted romp through stories of friendship! [30 minutes later] Gosh. Well. I didn't expect that. Absolutely vicious lyrics.
3.5/5
Another fantastic album from Randy Newman that is steeped in American history and explores difficult subjects with his trademark caustic sarcasm. The album opens with “Rednecks” which is VERY confronting. The topic would be tackled in a different way today but the lyrics are clearly spoken by a character tied to a very specific event and time in the past. Like all of Randy Newmans lyrics they tackle the issue effectively and are full of hidden meaning. Unless you lived in America in the 70s and have a good memory of US political events at the time, it really helps to have wikipedia open whilst listening to this album to get the most out of it! 😂 I would like to give Randy Newman himself a 5 but I think the 2 albums on here fall just short of a 5 for me because although I enjoy interpreting and reading up about the songs and I do find them enjoyable to listen to I feel the actual music, is somehow secondary to the lyrics. 4/5
Well... This is the most offensively thoughtful album I've heard in a long time. I'd vaguely heard that the Toy Story guy had this in his ouevre but wasn't prepared for this. The sad thing is, it's as relevant today as it was at its release. You don't want it to be, but it is. This review space is too short to get into a debate on what should and shouldn't be said, and by whom, but this album makes a strong case for less policing of speech.
Don't tell my friends, but I love Randy's N-word album!
The shine could wear off this one, but it's exactly in an uncomfortable vein of music which is extremely valuable. The vignettes on Good Old Boys don't form a single narrative, but they stretch across multiple songs. Newman's voice is Disneyfied, now, and that casts a pall over everything. But the South of the record is a particular one, with significant authenticity. Few melodies, a lot of words, but so many colors.
Was really surprised how good this was.
Instantly recognisable. Distinctive voice, piano high in the mix. It's all pleasant and comforting, somehow familiar even on tracks never previously heard. There's nothing not to like, but it's not for me. Being so distinctive had its downsides - It all sounds like 'You've got a friend in me' from Monsters Inc.
language is problematic now, but at the time ...
I don’t think he’s country, but he’s something adjacent. I liked this, found it pleasant
Love Randy newman. Love this record
I think it was a good album, with lyrics that really paint a picture. “Guilty” was an awesome song, and “A Wedding in Cherokee County” was very entertaining. Political statements were not over bearing but we’re obvious enough. “Kingfish” was a completely correct description of some of the towns in Louisiana, New Orleans included, at least prior to Katrina. This album was wiser than it’s getting credit for.
I love that Randy Newman largely eschews rock and roll for a more timeless sound. I consider him one of the most sophisticated and intelligent songwriters in all of music. He is able to examine and reflect on US history (as well as contemporary life) in a way that makes it seem so natural and compelling as a subject. He can also write these incredibly intimate songs about human relationships, or even just particular mindsets, that touch these uncomfortable places in a way that is painful but honest (and often funny). His details are so fleshed out and human - flaws and all. He is able to embody the complexity of so many characters so convincingly that it's uncanny. I think his folksy vocal style is his secret weapon. It's so effortlessly expressive that I find it relatable even if he's playing some asshole character (as he often is). This album is a remarkable achievement in creating a portrait of a place and the people in it. I can listen to it over and over.
Newman manages to cast such simple music in a socially critical setting. Love it (7/10) FT: Louisiana 1927, Birmingham, Mr. President
pretty cutting stuff for 73.
Muito bom.
Country for the working class! Prefs: Rednecks, Birmingham, Mr. President (Have Pity on the Working Man), Louisiana 1927, Kingfish, Naked Man, Back on My Feet Again Moins pref: Marie
Definitely an important work. A lot of times the lyrics, while simple, are deeply profound. There is a point though where you can get too much Randy Newman. All the songs start to sound a lot alike and a lot like every other Randy Newman song. This is one of those albums where I'd listen to the whole thing if it was on, but I probably wouldn't go seek it out.
27th January 2022 Listened while going to and from the gym mainly. Love the simplicity, humour and warmth. 4.5 if I could.
I need more time to.lusten to it. I think I like it.
I know Randy from his film scores. Pretty good album!
This was a nice surprise. I only knew Political Science of his songs and didn't expect this to be so good. I couldn't believe the lyrics in the first song. I listened to the whole thing twice in a row
Folk-rock con piano. Está bien.
Damn. Randy Newman is a great lyricist and composer. I always thought of him as the piano playing Kenny Loggins for all his movie scores but it's good stuff. I really enjoyed the wit and bite in his lyrics. Rednecks could never be written now but what a commentary on both the North and the South. I also really liked A Wedding in Cherokee County and Guilty. Not sure exactly what it is about his voice and piano that works, but it mixes well.
Certainly a controversial album. If you know Newman then you know what this album is going to sound like - the difficulty for some is recognising that he sings as a different characters in each song. Best Tracks: Rednecks; Guilty; Back On My Feet Again
Wow what an jntelligent, witty engaging listen this album is. Randy Nrwman" pop sensibilities are finely honed. I just wish there were less string arrangements which I feel sweetens things up too much, but it's always tastefully done and serves the song well. 4.5 🌟
Risky language for 2021, but the message stands
This is a super interesting concept album. The backing tracks sound great and they easily evoke the emotion they're going for. However, the lyrics are what make this album unique as most of them are from the viewpoint of a white guy from the Deep South. The narrator (or narrators) generally don't seem like agreeable people, and this creates a great dichotomy between the political lyrics and soothing music. Although this isn't an album that I would listen to casually, it's still worth a listen. Favorite track: Marie
Really good...refreshing Wasnt really into in 70's...but I knew some cool folk who were
really easy listen
The first song being rednecks is kinda wild. Obviously an important thing about this album is that Randy Newman writes from the perspective of a shitty person or people, not his own views. I think the album was really weirdly good honestly.
Never heard this side of randy before. The use of the N word in the first track was quite a shock. Very original album.
I like
This was a really enjoyable album that I had a lot of fun with. I haven’t listened to much Randy Newman, but I could see liking him.
The relax and chill album with simple and pretty song texts.
So I finish my review of Beau B with the words "Good Ole boys" and 5 seconds later see the title of this album. First couple of songs have me saying "Fuck Yeah!" When I heard Birmingham I couldn't help but think this is what Tom Waits would sound like if he didn't drink or smoke. There are many brand names playing on this album. I did a double take when I saw that Randy Newman also conducted the orchestra. This good ole boy knows music better than most and it shows. Funny thing is a friend came over and said it sounds like a song from the movie Toy Story. Correctamundo!
Well "Rednecks" is one way to start an album. That was insanely jarring coming form the voice of "You got a Friend In Me." Obviously satire and a damning view of racist American thinking but its still a curious choice. I did think it was interesting to see Newman's love/hate relationship play out with his childhood homeland of Louisiana in songs like "Rednecks" vs. "Louisiana 1927" and "Kingfish." It seems his composition style hasn't changed much over the years, and I don't blame him. His style is signature and recognizable and it works especially well for his country drawl voice. I felt that this album had a really cohesive vision and executed it perfectly, and even though a lot of these songs sounded the same I think that let the vision of the work come through crystal clear.
I've got a few of his albums. This one is wild! Rednecks is, accurate, hilarious, and sad all at the same time. This is the first gem to get uncovered by 1001 that I didn't already know about.
I like Randy Newman. He's not my favorite but it's easy to listen to.
Shows off his charm as a songwriter
Liked it more than I thought I would
Pretty solid
decent, didin't expect egregious N-word, but i digress
Imagine a state fair in South Arkansas or North Louisiana, all the deep-fried cheese, the rubbery corndogs, the maybe not-so-safe pop-up carnival rides, the drunk and high carneys tired of handing out damp stuffed bears to screaming kids and lustful teens. Now imagine it's 107F and 90% humidity and you can smell the grass wilting, the mud boiling, and the blood in the thousands of mosquitos congealing. That's what this album sounds like. It's a commentary on the most uncomfortable parts of the American Deep South and the undertones of racism, contradiction, and festering corrupt politics that ignore the constituents they represent. The music is cheerful and hopeful but the message in the lyrics is clear: This sucks and no one is coming to help, the only way things are getting better is if you start the movement yourself. The album opens with "Redneck" a pretty shock & awe display of in-your-face slurs and political commentary about the state of affairs in post-Civil Rights movement America. Politicians promising one thing but doing another, the deep south white population still deeply racist and hateful despite their political and moral defeat with segregation and Jim Crowe laws being abolished. "Mr. President (Have Pity on the Working Man)" is a pretty relevant song today as it was in 1974. Apparently, sentiments haven't changed much and people who make it to DC forget that there's 50 states they should be helping make better. "Kingfish" is an ode to the Governor Huey "Kingfish" Long who was an incredibly influential and before-his-time populist politician known for aggressive prosecution against massive oil corporations and representing poor and often powerless defendants in court against rich & corporate bullies. Aside from the music, the world needs more politicians like Huey Long. It's clear that although Newman's methods are bizarre, the message is clear: He is of the people, for the people, and against those who abuse the people. I was hesitant when this album opened up so strong with "Redneck" but listening to the lyrics and the references throughout made the album stand out. This is a very politically potent album, and I understand why it deserves its spot on this list. I'm interested if there's going to be music counter to this further in. I will gladly give this album a 7/10.
Superada la "impresión" del uso de la N-palabra, es un disco country-folky entretenido con canciones bonitas como la de Marie.
Not to be confused with Gary Numan, or more distantly, Paul Newman. Randy Newman's sound does feel a little quaint here, but there's enough depth that he eventually overcomes this. His deep voiced, crooner thing feels like more of a punchline than anything in 2026, but he *really* does sell it. I will say, there's some pretty remarkable social commentary here as well. Rednecks has some smart observations, based in some solid satire, and even if Randy Newman says some words he shouldn't along the way, he has some really worthwhile insights that live beyond the character piece. After this, it's pretty much surprisingly enjoyable songs, with surprisingly sharp writing the whole way. And even if this was never going to be a favorite, due to aesthetics, this is definitely still a very worthwhile listen, solidly showing that Randy Newman has more depth than you'd think.
3.5
I think I preferred Sail Away to this one. Partly because this is the album that has racial slurs on it and I don't really care that it's all, "But I'm doing parody and it's not what I think or say. I'm clever!" Rednecks is not a bad song but it does feel like Randy Newman feels himself to be so liberal and enlightened that he can use racial slurs. Regardless, this album is much like Sail Away, except I did not enjoy the semi-concept of this one as much. It's intended to be a concept album, except not really. There are a lot of Louisiana and Deep South references, so I guess that's the context. I could have probably used just one Randy Newman album in the book. Favorite songs: Rednecks Birmingham Mr. President (Have Pity on the Working Man) Louisiana 1927 Kingfish Back on My Feet Again
The music wasn't quite as good. The lyrics were okay.
This was REALLY good. A lot of fun and I love this style in music. He was a little too comfortable saying some slurs, but I know that it was a part of the story and a very anti-racism album. Every Song sounds a little similar, but not bad. Actual Rating...3.5 Liked Songs: "Rednecks" , "Birmingham" , "Marie" , "Mr. President (Have Pity on the Working Man)" , "Guilty" , "Every Man a King" , "Kingfish" , "Naked Man" , "A Wedding in Cherokee County" , "Back on My Feet Again"
Jesus Randy my kids listen to this show... I don't know how to rate this given the dated language but its otherwise pleasant?
Fun album for a Sunday morning. Favourite track: Marie
6/10 Mais respect pcq c’est lui qui a fait tôt story
I liked it, wasn’t as impressed as with Sail Away. He’s a much smarter songwriter than his sound suggests.
Great record
I get what he’s going for, I do. Doesn’t mean that I like hearing him spout the slurs though but it does add to the authenticity. Music isn’t 100% my thing but the production is quite nice (Marie in particular) Solid 6/10
Randy är en synnerligen god berättare. Louisiana 1927. Som kronan på verket (Howard Tates version inspelad efter Kathrina måste naturligtvis rekommenderas i sammanhanget). Musikaliskt är det väl både högt och lågt. Emellertid övervägande positivt.
Damnit… more Randy Newman. It’s not a bad thing… but small doses of Randy are so much more enjoyable. Birmingham is a bop for sure… but sticking with 3.0
Didn’t have Randy Newman singing the n-word on my bingo card. I didn’t give this as close a listen as Sail Away, and my feelings about it suffer as a result. Musically, it doesn’t particularly draw me, but what I did catch of the lyrics continues to show biting satire. 7/10 Pretty Good
Musique de films, tu sens que c'est l'amérique, assez poétique et entrainant. Très pop et rythmé, avec orchestre et assez jazzy (cuivres et piano). La voix de Randy Newman ne va pas avec l'image que l'on se fait de lui, assez soul et afro-américaine. Très New Orleans R&B alors que c'est un parolier avec des musiques acides et dénonciatrices. Les chansons portent sur divers travers passés du Sud des États-Unis tels que l'esclavage, le racisme et la pauvreté, mais avec un ton ironique
Rednecks Guilty Birmingham Louisiana 1927
solidna folk (pučka?) glazba. dosta mi se svidjela "marie". ostatak mi je bio slabiji, ali nipošto zanemariv. ipak ne mogu reći da ću baš ponovo htjeti slušati. stoga jedna prava visoka trojčetina za randolfa novačića!
Huumori musiikkia? Kantaaottavaa musiikkia. Räikeää kieltä nykyaikaa?
Lovely
I always want to like Randy Newman but it’s just too grown up for me. Maybe one day I’ll be a grown-up amazing lyrics. That first song is a little jarring, but obviously it’s hard is in the right place.
Trevligt.
Gad vide om det her album gjorde at Pixar var betænkelige ved at hyre ham til toy story
His voice isn't as insufferable on this record than some of his others. This was a decent record!
Sounds like Toy Story era Newman, only using the N word with the hard R.
I was not expecting to hear so many slurs from the "You've Got A Friend In Me" guy. I did try to put that aside considering the satire here and how none of it felt mean spirited, but that was hard because of how frequent it is. Randy sure has gravitas and panache, but him saying the n word for the nth time torpedoes it. Leaving the fact that this album hasn't aged well aside, it's fine. I think saying the name of southern states with a solemn voice would hit harder if I was from the US so it did little for me. Glad I listened to it, but I am unlikely to go back to it or check out the rest of Randy's back catalogue
Good, but I never need to hear it again.
I find Randy Newman's music soothing. Toy Story and The Princess and the Frog were well loved in my home, so with those soundtracks as an introduction, how could his voice not be a source of comfort? I also love a sprawling, storytelling album with lots of characters, and if it deals with complex subjects that make for some tough conversations, all the better. This album gave me the opportunity to examine the purpose of discomfort in art. I was uncomfortable with the slurs used the same way I was uncomfortable when Leo said them in Django Unchained, the same as when I read Mark Twain's stories about Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn, the same as when I saw my friend's nephew dressed as a Nazi for their high school play about Anne Frank. The discomfort is the point. I read the Wikipedia page on the opening track, Rednecks, and learned some historical context I may otherwise not have known. The song is about the hypocrisy of northern liberals claiming to have set free the very people they were forcing into unofficially but still very markedly segregated urban areas - Harlem, the South Side of Chicago, Roxbury in Boston. We never have and still don't live in the land of equal opportunity for all. There's an abundance of art made with the intent to evoke specific emotions and bring attention to this fact. It's a smack in the face in a way statistics and journalistic reporting simply can't be. It can be the bridge to a disconnect from emotion, and that looks different for every person. This isn't an album for passive listening, but I still enjoyed it. I learned something new and got to wrestle with some difficult questions. Won't be relistening any time soon if ever.
Wow. Rednecks. Strange song.
Noteworthy satire that belongs on this list but his repeated use if the “n” word made me incredibly uncomfortable from the outset. Surprised that this was a commercial success given its tone.
3 stars
A sharp criticism about racism in America, even if it is a bit coarse by firing off slurs like a minigun.
Gotta appreciate the dig at racism in all parts of america with Rednecks and the accompanying follow-ups. It would be easy listening, save for that some of the slurs made me a bit apprehensive that anyone would ask what I was listening to. Apparently he was always nervous bringing these songs, same as the listeners. Takes guts, but not for everyday.
Wow, that was unexpected! I settled in to listen to the 'Toy story' song dude. That's on me!! I enjoyed this, almost like a piece of theater. The characters (?) singing the songs add an authenticity to the album, although the slurs make it difficult to listen to without headphones!
kinda repetitive, not bad though
Ok, but it does not move me beyond ★★★.
#945. I mean, it's fine I guess, but I can't imagine a situation where I would ever want to listen to it again. 3/5: acceptable
This was crazy fast and interesting. Lot of incoherent thoughts about this album I will need time to put together. I like what he has to say on this album and it feels incredibly relevant today as it did when it came out.
Ain’t nothing changed
Well the first song has a substantial amount of n-words (despite what is explicitly an anti-racist overall message). Kind of jarring, but he connects it to antisemitism as well as to the overall theme of the album. The rest of the album is really interesting and builds on some specific themes that are meaningful. I liked it but didn't love it.
First track threw me a bit - had to stop and think, surely, this must be satire. Even so, quite painful to listen to. Louisiana 1927 is a great example of his songwriting skill. Knew the song, had no idea it was his. I think his talent overcomes the parts that don’t hold up so well from 1973 or thereabouts.
It's OK (Fallout-ish sounding album)
Another Louisiana special. First Dr. John & now Randy Newman. He has such a unique voice and style. So different from what anyone else was doing in 1974. Great rootsy heartsy, storytelling. I can appreciate the artistry, but not something I’d come back to.
Karakter fuld stemmer. Jeg gik ventede bare på disney sangene. Som dog udeblev fra det her album
Jeg kan virkelig godt lide Randy Newmans vokal. Den musik han laver kan jeg lide lidt mindre.
у меня нет сил слушать американские мемы. голос красивый
3/5
Color me surprised. It was a lot of fun and silly. Good stuff. Not many bops but entertaining nonetheless
friend in me
When people said Randy’s vocals are slurred, that’s not what I expected
Cool voice boring songs
That first one was kinda crazy
Overall Rating - 3.10/5 (6.20/10). Bit of a weird feel to this album, Randy Newman writing and singing songs about people and places in the old South. A Wedding in Cherokee County and Back on My Feet Again had me cackling with laughter.
3/5 ⭐️ 117/1089
intersting stuff. just a little too monotonous.
I find myself a little conflicted, because a lot of these songs are pretty great. Randy is a fun songwriter and singer with some really solid production (I especially like the uneasy woodwinds in the song Guilty). His voice has an appeal and his wit is biting and acerbic. But that also leads to songs like Rednecks, which aged like milk in a summer junkyard. The intentions were pure, and the message is pretty clear, but that one's still rough to listen to.
Interest album, and yes - listen to the Malcolm Gladwell Revisionist History podcast about it.
Toy Story 2 was ok
Normalito no me fascinó pero tampoco me pareció malo, mid tier. 6/10
As white people the least we can do is not say it... but putting that aside the music is mid anyway lol. 3
Something warm and cuddly about Mr. Toy Story's music.
His piano driven country rock sound is so distinctive and easy to listen to, but I'm not sure if I really like it. It seems like the album is about life in the south, with plenty of criticism and plenty of sincerity. It was fun for a one time listen but probably not something I'll return to.
3 - decent
I must say, Good Old Boys was a pretty nice listen. It's honestly been quite a while since i last heard Sail Away so i don't exactly know how this one compares to that one but due to recency bias, i think i prefer this one. The songs here still have that very Disney/Pixar jazz sounding tone to them and that is something i enjoy to see this style in an earlier fashion. I also think that some of the lyrical themes are pretty interesting with some of them being about various historical events and as someone who enjoys history, i really do get a kick out of this. It isn't perfect as most of the songs can get pretty samey but i still enjoyed my time with this one. Best Song: Louisiana 1927 Worst Song: Naked Man
Well. You wait for one for ages and then two come along at once. By which I mean a Randy Newman album where the opening track contains slurs but for seemingly benevolent reasons (or as least as benevolent as it's possible to be while throwing out the n-word multiple times - once again, Mr Newman is very much anti-slave trade). Yesterday's Generator album was Sail Away by Randy Newman, today it's Good Old Boys by Randy Newman. I really liked the way the music on Guilty seemed as slurred as the drunken and high narrator must have been - it was a fun way to add to the story. I like Randy Newman's (technically poor) voice as much as I did yesterday. I like the piano as much as I did yesterday. And the orchestral bits. But today's album features fewer songs I already knew (and loved) so it didn't hit as much for me. I appreciate the concept of loosely telling the stories of a certain place and a certain time, but I'd rather listen to Simon Smith and His Amazing Dancing Bear. More a 3.5 for me, but I'm plumping for a 3. 3/5 P.S. I nearly got through two Randy Newman albums without mentioning Toy Story, but I cannot imagine the shock some parents must have listening to this after You Got A Friend In Me...
i dunno man it's aight Will I listen to again: 5%
Southern satire against jingles. I liked the piano, probably will never listen again though.
Respect his talent, but not for me.
норм
Прикольно, не уныло, классная обложка, в целом послушать приятно, но опять не мое
It's hard to imagine Randy Newman as anything but a Disney soundtrack man, which is a huge honor but also an anchor
In 2026, we would not use the N-word even in the service of satire. And that's probably as it should be. 1974 was a much different time. "All In the Family" featured and satirized Archie Bunker, an overtly racist protagonist living in Queens. 1974 was also soon after the Civil Rights era of the 1960s when white racists were still feeling free to use the N-word as a demeaning epithet. Now, in 2026, with the Trump back in the White House, in part because young white men wanted to be free to say the N-word, Randy Newman's satire seems more fitting than ever. The music is classic Randy Newman.
I have understand the theme of the album and it was ell written. I am just not a big fan of his voice
An interesting listen - lyrics don't quite match the music if you know what I mean
An ok album. Good for the background.
I saw Randy Newman perform on John Mulaney's talk show recently and that made me see his appeal a bit more, but I still don't think I really get his music.
This guy is always going to make me think of toy story
A solid album by Randy Newman who brings some swing to all kinds of different songs, but which are firmly based in southern music with a piano at the centre. I think it swings, but I wouldn't consider it necessarily a classic.
I know that the song rednecks is mocking rednecks, and all, but Randy’s use of the N-word really caught me off guard. It kind of sets the tone for the rest of the album, which isn’t bad but not what I was expecting.
Every song sounds like it's from Toy Story, but then you hear the lyrics.
This is pretty good but his voice kind of gets a bit annoying 3/4 way through
I feel like I need to be more intimately familiar with 20th-century Louisiana politics before I really get this album. I love how it sounds! Interesting songs, and some good social criticism.
Kinda crooner-ish singer songwriter
Ah, stemmen fra Toy story og barndom, en stemme der er svær ikke at holde af :)) et album med noget på hjerte fra sydstaterne med emner som slaveri og racisme, og ret straightforward og satiriske tekster der var ret fede. ville give 3.5 ish
Some interesting use of slurs in this… actually didn’t mind it musically though
Has more rocky billy joel energy if it was satire, pastiche, definitely dated, concept album about the American South. Unfortunate use of slurs that's absolutely not cool if made today, but they make sense in the context of a satirical taking the piss album about racists from the period. I get the point he is making, but it's good to acknowledge that while it may have entertained non-southerners or progressive southerners at the time it's not the way to address these problems today. Music is easy rocky pop with orchestral touches, has a southern-flavoured slowness and references to it
cozy jazzy ranch rock? still need a ranch and a rocking chair to enjoy this. it's okayish, but i wouldn't go that far to say i enjoy it...
Even in a take down on institutionalized racism, it's wild to hear Randy Newman drop hard Rs
Rednecks kind of lost me. Could never put that song out today. Otherwise, good sound. What I’d expect out of Randy Newman
Although this was far from my usual taste in music, and with “The Family Guy” jokes in my head, I still did not dislike this album. I wouldn’t go so far as to say I enjoyed it but I didn’t hate it.
Pretty much what I would expect from a Randy Newman album
Classical, a bit repetitive for me to listen all in one sitting. Gives that american old nostalgia vibes.
People use to make fun of this guys voice and I see it now. It's funky and definitely iconic for him. Otherwise it's a piano and vocal album. Pretty chill. Not my thing but not bad.
Looking at the lyrics of the first song it's more of just how everyone put down blacks in this time period. Northerns and Southerns but yeah yikes using the slur hasn't aged well at all. The rest of the album is fine I definitely wouldn't listen to this one on my own but it was fine to listen to once. 3 stars.
I feel his entire vibe is a 3 by design
A reminder from the past. It didn’t inspire me then. It was pleasant listening.
Songs were ok. Nothing that stood out to me. Not my thing.
I enjoy Randy even though I can see how he is formulaic and can get under your skin.
Plutôt entraînant, mais assez quelconque. On dirait que toutes ses tounes sonnent pareil.
Pas capable de ne pas penser à Toy Story quand je l'entend chanter malheureusement. Sinon, sa voix me fait penser un peu à Craig Finn que j'adore. Ça le sauve un peu parce que sinon je trouvais ça oubliable.
It's not bad but there is something about randy Newman I always interpret as novelty song even if the content isn't 3*
It's a bit shocking to hear the N word in the opening track, but I understand the satirical intention of the song and am aware that this album is 50 years old. I'm offended by the use of that word in any music, whether it's satire or the supposedly 'reclaimed' excuse that hiphop uses. Sad, though, that Randy Newman's legacy is likely to be as the 'ToyStory' guy rather than his great singer/songwriting.
Standard Randy Newman. Interesting that modern day reviewers have no understanding of the times this was made and the statement Randy was making.
Randy Newman doing Randy Newman, and doing it well
Craig: funny when you can understand him Courtney: Randy Newman is the Bob Saget of music
I admire Randy Newman as a songwriter a great deal more than I enjoy him. He's smart, and funny, and good with a melody. And for his era, he was a bold and brave lyricist. I'm old enough to get what he's doing but young enough to still cringe at it. He couldn't, and shouldn't, do it in 2026, and it makes it tough to enjoy some of these tunes. That's a me thing, I wholeheartedly acknowledge. As good as he is, I just don't enjoy Randy Newman records all that much
Wait... Is this offensive? Or genius? Or both? Not an easy listen.
Who gave the Toy Story guy the N word pass???
#33/1001 🇬🇧 I knew nothing of the background before listening to this record and had to read up more after hearing the first track with its use of Jew and N*****. It sounded obvious to me as satirical but will every listener at the time seen this. Musically, its an easy listen fusing blues and country with Newman's laid back vocal style. This sits in contrast to the biting lyrics. Best tracks: Guilty, Louisiana 1927, Rednecks. * Check out John Belushi's version of Guilty with The Blues Brothers Band.
Fun, pleasant and enjoyable. 3.5/5
Quite good. 3/5
This man went on to do some legendary soundtracks and as a film lover always appreciate that. This was only ok though. Him and nepenthez the only 2 who have escaped uncancelled for their symbolic use of a certain derogatory word.
Listening to Randy Newman feels like it should be accompanied by a montage of Buzz and Woody, which makes it feel very innocent and comforting. Even though at the heart of it this is an album about racism and the Deep South, which isn’t very innocent at all
I'm not a huge Randy Newman fan. His stuff all sounds quite samey but this was an ok listen
Randy is a mad man, I have to give him my respect. He may sound like he's had a stroke but it's oddly poignant in a way.
I didn't realize that this guy existed outside of Pixar. Overall the songs were fine.
Not the album but Randy is sharp and clever.
Pretty cozy.
really nice album, good vocals and songs overall
Is it just me, or would all of these songs sound better sung by Ray Charles?
Quite nice. I find his voice ok and unique but his music is nice.
The n word must’ve been said like 50 times
I was hoping for some nice wholesome Toy Story adjacent songs, so track one was a bit of a shock. I think it's well intentioned but Jesus it sails close to the wind. The rest of this was pretty uneventful compared to that one.
It's like a bunch of variations on the Toy Story song! Distinctive style but a bit redundant. Still enjoyable 3.3
Nice and short, pretty enjoyable. Feels like the soundtrack to a comedy movie.
Before listening to this album I was thinking I’m not super keen to hear songs from Toy Story today, then I listened to the way he dismantles and takes the piss out of rednecks, wealthy people, the government and the French, and was surprised and impressed. Sorry Randy, I was not familiar with your game
2.5 I've already forgotten it
A sound that is uniquely and distinctively Randy Newman, paired with some engaging songwriting, all pretty good but nothing quite memorable enough to bring it to the higher step
Guter Start, auf Dauer (und das obwohl das Album ziemlich kurz ist) allerdings recht eintönig und driftet in Hintergrundmusik ab. Reicht gerade so noch für 3 Sterne.
Die Platte hat bestimmt gute Texte, aber musikalisch ist mir das hier oft zu seicht und easy listening. Ein paar gute Songs waren aber doch dabei.
Fand ich eigentlich super. Auf die Länge ist es aber zu viel zu gleich gewesen.
GOING IN: Not fussed really LISTENED WHILE: walking the dog FAMILIARITY: New to me SKIP RATE: Played it straight through REPLAY VALUE: Once was plenty DISCOVERY CURVE: Slow burner this one ALBUM ARC: Pretty even, consistent VERDICT: Better than expected BODY'S VERDICT: Toe tapping situation My Rating: 3 First thoughts: Yikes... wait, what... explicit... dark... fearless... witty... musical... funny... shame... clever... The music is sharp, funny, and broadly American sounding rather than just Southern rootsy, which helps make his point that these failings reflect all of America, not just the South. But there's a risk here. Not everyone will catch that Newman is performing these characters, not endorsing them. I've given this a 3 rather than a 4 as I don't think I'll ever listen to it again, but I'm glad to know it's out there in the world.
What the fuck is this? I can't tell if it's satire or just glazing Southern life (good and bad). The composition is nice and Randy's the perfect voice for this. But my god
Basically everyone who gave this a negative review cannot detect irony or sarcasm. Compare Rednecks to his more famous I Love LA - both satirical, if not outright sarcastic. This is almost a comedy album. I kind of like it, but it's presented as easy-listening music, which I don't like even when it's ironic easy-listening music, so all I can do is nod in appreciation and leave this one in the Listened pile. I liked it but I'm probably never coming back.
good I think.
Good song writing and some catchy tunes
I like Randy Newman at times. This album's narrative caught me off guard as I didn't do any research before jumping in. The Toy Story man slingin' a hard-r took me for a second. Then the album title made sense.... Some of these are cool but overall they left me wanting the writing and variety from the prior album we did "Sail Away" On a "meta level" its interesting watching the reviews for this tank as its subject becomes more and more topical.
Woah, this feels weird: the randomiser has thrown up back-to-back Randy Newman records. This one provides an interesting thematic contrast as it marks a shift from personal to much more political material. Some of this, although delivered in characteristic laid-back, low-key style, is really lyrically hard-hitting. Equal parts tragic, scary, and maddening that the targeted invective is still so completely on point over 50 years later. Disgustingly racist country really - but wait, this is also much more universal than it's comfortable to admit. Given current events, maybe this a small protest move by admin? If so, nice one✊.
1/8/26. Aesthetically pleasing. 6.5/10
Solid singer-songwriter entry.
Randy Newman. 1974 Randy Newman, but definitely Randy Newman!
Any one who knows Randy for the Toy Story soundtrack would be surprised by this. Satire, righteous anger and genuinely touching love songs. The power of a voice and well crafted songs
What’s the deal with dudes playing characters as an excuse to drop slurs?
Toy Story was better
All I hear is You've Got a Friend in Me.
honestly i like it... i know its misguided white guy music so nick and luke aren't allowed to like it but it just works for me LOL.
How is it this guys early work has the sound of Toy Story soundtrack, but with fucked up lyrics? This is weird... But is actually not bad.
Asså helt okej? Inte så märkvärdigt, men rätt bra texter och särskilt Marie hade jättesnyggt arr!
I heard the first song and almost immediately gave up because of the context. Then I looked up that Newman tries to “hold a mirror to society” and it helped me understand the point of the music. While unique, still not my vibe but rating neutral for uniqueness.
If you think the slur is bad, you should see how he treats short people! What a fiend!
mid pra caralho, indo pra baixo
mano. o cara do you've got a friend in me falando a n-word. bom eh isso. não foi ruim e eh meio bizarro como as letras são atuais. mas eh isso só, nada demais não
Problematic in parts but a great songwriter. I honestly think that Randy's heart is roughly in the right place, but this century we would at least call him an edgelord. Constantly flirting with poor taste at the very least. It actually makes me feel awkward to listen to in parts when he's writing in character in such a difficult way. There is something about his songwriting style that I really love though. Marie is such a beautiful ballad - one of my absolute favourite of it's style
Solid album. Hadn't thought much about Randy Newman but he's so familiar to anyone who has to watch disney films regularly. His voice and songwriting style are so distinctive. I did have some reservations about the opening track, Rednecks. You can't help but feel that this mocking of the US South has contributed to the US being as divided as it is today. I also find it so weird that tracks with so many n-words in them don't get flagged as explicit by Spotify.
Very biting humor on this album. Satire at its finest... But the music was just ok.
Sonically it wasn't bad. I get that it's satire buuuuuut...big oof on the lyrics.
Nice country music that's surprisingly actually enjoyable? He's funny, first track and he's roasting those rednecks. Love the album already. Half of the album is also quite sarcastic, which I really like. Musically it's not outstanding, but still enjoyable enough, plus the lyrics really do add extra flavors to it. Overall I would give it a 3-3.5/5.
I was caught off guard on the first track. I wasn't expecting much, but I was greeted with "Jungle Book"-like vocals and easy-going instrumentals. This was pretty good. Favourite Track(s): Every Man a King, A Wedding in Cherokee County Least Favourite Track(s): Guilty
It was fine. Some of the language was pretty awful by modern standards, but I think, with it clearly being used to critise racism, it's pretty unfair to judge it by modern standards.
Challenging album. Hard to justify a white artist making the N-word a focus of their art. He’s using unacceptable language to describe characters who would drop the N-word or antisemetic slur without thinking twice — the satire is heavy. How can you describe racists in the first person without sounding racist? In the end, the critique of southern racists on “rednecks” is unsparing and almost as dehumanizing as those the characters are oppressing… almost. But of course, it’s a choice to platform racists in the 1st person to begin with. If art’s job is to make listeners’ uncomfortable, Newman has done his job. The music is excellent and Newman can sing well enough. If I didn’t listen to the subject matter, this might be a 4. But, as I said, the content is problematic and makes me struggle with the purpose of this art. It doesn’t make me feel good, but it makes me think. A 3.
I liked this one more than the last Newman album on the list I listened to (Sail Away). Some pretty poignant commentary on this one.
It is a bit disheartening to hear the guy who did that song from Toy Story say the Hard R. I do however know that he is using the Hard R in a way that is a critique of actual people who think that backwards way and can't help but say nasty words, so I do quite like the message of the song "Rednecks." Most of the other songs aren't as interesting I'm afraid, with all that disney-like orchestration, with an exception for "Every Man a King" which sounds like a military song. Highlight Song/s: Rednecks, Mr President and Every Man a King
🎶Beware, beware, beware of the naked man🎶
Good album - nice listen, not my usual thing but really enjoyed
Some lovely tunes from the other piano man.
Randy Newman sounds the same as he always has. Tough themes but good that he's tackling them.
Context is very, very important. Still shouldn't be singing that. 3.
Strange choice - but as is often the case I did actually recognise some of the tracks. Not too bad but not really my sort of thing.
It’s funny (not really) how American political satire doesn’t seem to age. You can say, “People are racist, and the government doesn’t respond to the needs of the working class,” and it might just remain true forever. It’s crazy how such a stagnant society is still (at least nominally) rapidly developing. As for the musical aspects of this album, it’s fine. Not really much to talk about. Chill, somewhat enjoyable, but literally nothing special.
Ein klassisches Album mit souligen Elementen. Ein bisschen Frank Sinatra, ein bisschen… lahm …
Greatest City in Alabam'
Fine
I enjoyed this. Lyrics are deep as well as funny. Making fun of rednecks is automatic 3 stars. 7/10.
Fine I guess
Pretty good satire, but you really need to wear headphones for this album - especially the first song, sheesh.
later
Talk about dad rock..
splitting the difference of scores from the household
This guy again. Respect to the songwriting; don't absolutely love this, though.
I love Randy Newman's voice. I enjoyed the music. DIdn't enjoy the lyrics of a few songs.
7/10. Instrumental legal e vocal tmb, talvez merecesse mais, mas faltou algo
Pretty solid, felt like I was listening to a Pixar album for a minute Didn't appreciate the first song too much...why need to say slurs to get your point across 3/5 7.83/10
Decent.
3/5
Good stuff for the genre, not my think but I appreciate it
It's a fine album but I don't think I can really get into Randy Newman's music. He's a good songwriter and musician, but I find his voice too goofy to take seriously and his style of music doesn't totally work for me.
enjoyable album and it was nice to dig deeper into deep Southern music!
Easy listening