Reviews (page 5 of 14)
Falls just short in a lot of ways for me. Not catchy enough to be good '70s folk pop, not poetic enough to be good Blues or standard Folk, not leaning into influences enough to match up to Graceland. Highlights: "Run That Body Down", "Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard"
This one surprised me, who know this guy had groove? Anyways this albums pretty cool, the ballads are really fun and the lyrics are straightforward as they can be, but can still engage you, even when its just him singing and the guitar. That dude knows how to play a guitar btw, the little euphemisms that he does with his guitar really adds a lot to whatever he's playing. 9/10
Prefer the double act material more but this is still really good.
I’ve always (at the risk of being thought a massive weirdo - as ever) thought that there’s a chance Paul Simon is UNDERrated as a songwriter. Maybe because he hasn’t made that many good albums - but this might honestly be my favorite. What’s not to like? Mother and Child Reunion? Good, Me and Julio? Good. Meat? Good. Hang on I thought I was Joey Tribbiani for a minute. Duncan? Good. Are thise pan pipes sort of cliched and annoying? Sure, but they’re only cliched because of the phase he went through of slapping them on all over. It’s kind of slight, but also kinda great.
Yea
album cover looks so cute 10/10 Apart from that, the songs are also cute. I like it. It feels like a quiet album, reminicising of Simon & Garfunkel obviously, but it has its own flair. song writing is great, hate demo versions i do not need to hear them leave them be.
Can't see the appeal.
Very pleasant listen
I found this balanced in many aspects
I LOVE this album, especially Mother and child reunion, Duncan, Me and Julio down by the schoolyard, and Peace by the river. Beautiful music, voice, and lyrics!
I already had a few favs on this album, but listening through the whole thing made me appreciate it more. It’s understated, well-produced, and very much in my lane
Hell yeah
un disco bello, creo que crece con cada escuchada. Ninguna canción me conmovió o me enloqueció de más, puntos para Run that body down que fue un gran tema. Seguramente con cada escucha se vuelva mejor! me trajo vibras a blonde on blonde pero sin la epica dylan, quizás le falto un cambio de emociones entre tema y tema
un album para escuchar en algun atardecer de verano. es el tipo de musica que aprecias cuando alguien mas la pone y crea un momento lindo. escucharla intencionalmente me hizo sentirla aburrida y bastante lenta. ninguna cancion en particular resono conmigo, ni la letra. la voz es muy bonita, pero nada mas
Quaint, whimsical album. Thank you Simon (not Garfunkel)
не знаю что там пол делал с гарфанкелом вместе, но он и один справляется
Hey, he was into other genres well before Graceland, how do you like that. I suspect this was a big one for Britt Daniel.
It was fine, nothing stuck out to me although I had heard the Julio down by the schoolyard song before! I wouldn't go back to it, but I could understand why it's on this list.
Surface level folk. Thought the tubes were good but nothing stood out to me. Will most likely forget about this.
Paar classics, maar ook wat fillers er tussen
A little less interesting and more poppy to me than graceland to me. Though still a solid experience
Last fall, I got really into Simon and Garfunkel’s discography, so I was happy to see this one come up. I thought I’d like it more, but it was still a delight of a listen. I can appreciate that Paul Simon was trying to differentiate himself as a solo artist from his earlier works in a duo. The songs are very distinct from each other and take on a lot of different styles.
Really good! Genuinely no super familiar with Paul Simon's stuff and I really liked it. Essentially his first widely released solo album and it's clearly consciously moving forwards from his Simon and Garfunkel stuff. Early bits of the world music stuff he would dive deeper into later. Strong lyrics and a great variety of moods in the songs.
I actually really liked this one. I kinda wish it was somewhat more lyrically deep, but it's good enough. I really liked his voice, which I wasn't expecting and I also loved the instrumentation. Excited to hear more of his stuff 4.25/5
Great album. Have loved it for years.
Woah I did not expect to like this so much! Paul Simon just has an inherent likeability to him. Everything here works, the storytelling, genre shifts, it's all so good! A classic.
Beautiful, also huge nostalgia trip, I used to listen to my dad's Paul Simon vinyl when I was a kid
Very enjoyable!
Great album. Songs like Duncan are excellent and memorable.
Not having been a fan of Graceland, I had low expectations going into this album, but I was actually very shocked at how fun and playful it was! Paul Simon definitely works better with the instrumentation stripped down, he eminates American Belle and Sebastian energy, in a great way. Me and Julio is a standout for a reason, would be very interested to explore the rest of his 70s catalogue after this.
Alright.
I adore this album!
3/5, but it is so close to a 4. It's a lovely album. Simon is a wonderful composer, and the album is arranged and produced well. He also has this honesty and down-to-earth quality about him that really endears me to his music, and those are both on display here. What pulls me back from a 4 is that only two songs stand out: "Me and Julio," and "Run That Body Down." The rest are a nice listen but on the whole forgettable.
This album was alright. By digging further into the Wikipedia I had more appreciation for Simon’s stylistic experimentation, but ultimately it felt too disjointed and the lyrics and music never really reeled me in. A fine but kind of boring listen for me.
Great artist. Love his sound, and music. One of many great albums.
I prefer Garfunkel.... (1/5) Just joking. I liked this peaceful, smooth album. This was the first album that I actually heard of before playing it in this 1001 album collection. Best songs were Mother & Child Reunion, Duncan, and Me and Julia Down by the School yard.
This is a good album. Really great songwriting and solid instrumentals. I liked this more than Graceland. Favorites were Duncan, Run that Body Down, Me And Julio Down By The Schoolyard, Papa Hobo, and Paranoia Blues.
This is a regular on our turntable, so, yeah.
BANGER AFTER BANGER HOLY SHIT i want to take a road trip to this album
Pleasantly surprised after assuming I wouldn’t be a fan. Particularly liked track 1 - mother and child reunion and track 10 - paranoia blues. Liked the eclectic genres used and every song felt very different.
Campfire Music
Aprendi a gostar do Simon através dessa lista, já é o terceiro álbum dele que gerei aqui, e cada um estou gostando mais do que o anterior. As composições são tão harmônicas e agradáveis, uma sonoridade reminiscente de manhãs desleixadas, acompanhado de um lirismo brincalhão e instrumentalização requintada e minimalista. A voz dele é um veludo nos ouvidos, sempre. Suas melodias são infectantes e memoráveis, infinitamente apreciáveis. Este disco fica melhor a cada rodada, muito valor de replay. Existe um pequeno ecletismo aqui, o que me agrada, mas alguns dos cortes mais Folksys não me pegam cem por cento. Assim como algumas das faixas da dupla com Garfunkel não me pegam. Mas são poucos momentos que o disco me perde, ao todo, é uma escuta bem cativante. 4.5/5
Awesome
a true classic
Très belle surprise qui commence par un reggae et qui continue sur de la folk très mélodieuse.
good ig
The easy listener.
One of the greatest songwriters of all time.
Never thought that i would listen to this kind of music, but it was absolutely fine. Not my favourite, but still, enjoyed discovering classics like Me and Julio. The mood that is radiating from these songs made my day, done my cooking much enjoyable :)
he's got some blues in him, mais un peu répétitif
This album was OK not the greatest. In my opinion. I do like some of his older stuff. He is a great writer and the lyrics are always good. I guess the instrumental sound is what I don’t really enjoy.
Really enjoyed this, great writing and music composition and production with lots of variety.
Such a solid record, love how he explored all these different regional sound palettes within the context of folk
this is peak 5/5
This sweet little boy can right some folk. You hear the roots of "Graceland" in this one and overall it's not so much of a departure from his duo work you'd think Art was weighing him down. "Me & Julio" is an all time bop.
esse é bom, 4 estrelas
De la diversité dans cet album. Tout n'est pas top mais ce Paul simon est une pointure
One of the more personal Paul Simon albums I've heard. Allows the guitar playing to shine a bit more too. Imaginative songwriting over some well-crafted tunes, as expected from Simon, this felt like a mix of folk with all sorts of other musical varieties sprinkled in. Somewhat indictive of what was to come for Simon's solo career.
So incredibly safe and lacking depth, but otherwise a pleasant listen.
very mid, there's some cool melodies but I just couldn't get into it
chill af. Perfect for summer.
Kjoet
Highlights: Paranoia Blues, Papa Hobo, Peace Like a River, Run That Body Down Kind of a weird start for this exploratory journey. Not really my style musically but I like the themes of the lyrics. I'm just not used to folk, that's all. It has to be one of those "gets better after a first listen" deals. Still, I have found a great deal of nice songs on here. Not an easy listen, it's more of a sit-down situation. At some points the album feels like just a collection of little stories backed by a bare-bones musical theme.
I’d honestly prefer to listen to this kinda folk over Bob Dylan. This album was a smooth ride with some really fun songs and experimentation in between. My favourite has gotta be Me and Julio Down By the Schoolyard. Such a fun song
one of my favourites
no me gustó para nada, de las cosas más aburridas que he escuchado en mi vida, un real tough listen
oiiii FAVS (top 3): mother and child reunion, me and julio down by the schoolyard, peace like a river mençoes honrosas: duncan, run that body down, papa hobo, paranoia blues, congratulations compraria o vinil: sipá gente pior q gostei é bem chills nota final: 4/5
everything put together falls apart me and julio 6.5-7/10 თან არაა ჩემი სტილი მარა მაინც რაღაც ჰქონდა საჩემო
bit of a slower album, but nice cohesive folksy sound. top track: run that body down
Luv
3/5 - More entertaining than expected, realizing that I really miss songs that tell stories. Country with a dash of something else. Don't see myself re-listening, but I have no regrets.
Excellent album. Some great guitar work too. Favorite track Armistice Day
Nice tunes, relaxing, thx
3.5 - love me and julio bc its so nostalgic but once again just not music id listen to over and over again but still appreciate it
what a delightful album :) beautiful sounds, catchy melodies & meaningful lyrics the talent on display here is unbelievable
Apart from mother and child reunion ( which I used to think was someone else) this album is utter drivel, are the songs rejects from S&G albums. Now I know why I find Graceland so offensive on the ears
Incredibly good album. So many good songs. Such good music. So easy to listen to. Stands the test of time.
meh
One of my favorite Paul Simon albums!
Paul Simon always brings a sense of calm. It was great listening on a winter day. I knew only two songs before hand and noon of the rest really grabbed me, but I definitely didn't regret this listen.
Also never heard of him before It feels like nothing bind blowing to me honestly, it’s not bad tho I like the instruments in armistice day the guitar ahh It’s still a vibe tho lol Also me and julio down by the schoolyard I like fun
This is a grab bag of styles and influences- blues, ska, jazz and folk but all formed into shape through great songwriting. Each song is a like a short story full of rich characters. Great lyrics and unerring sense of melody throughout
Solid album I hadn’t heard in years (but only listened to in entirety probably once). Bunch of popular tunes though….
The political discontent feels real today
It's fine. I like some of the more jazzy vibes to it.
i’ll have to listen again, but i enjoyed some
Simon has a good voice, and the songwriting is fine enough (although side 2 makes me question that statement). But why would ever listen to this over something like Nick Drake's Pink Moon or Neil Young's After the Gold Rush? Redundancy is what I'm getting from Paul Simon. Also, that album cover pisses me off. He looks way too goofy to also be looking that smug.
Enjoyable but not super memorable
You can hear him start to branch out from Simon & Garfunkel here, with a wider range of influences. I particularly liked 'Peace Like a River' which I had never heard before
I’d always thought of Paul Simon mainly as one half of Simon & Garfunkel, so this was my first time really listening to his solo work. I found myself unexpectedly drawn to “Peace Like a River” and “Paranoia Blues” — especially the bluesy slide guitar, which made me appreciate him as a guitarist more than I had before.
Graceland better but enjoyed nonetheless.
Well, I loved the composition and production of the album but due to my preference for other genres, I feel I cannot truly understand the depth of the album but it has wonderful and succulent highs and bewitching lows.
Beautiful flute sound Live the mixing of genres done very seamlessly Great sound
Never really clicked with Paul Simon. Maybe things he was doing at the time were breaking new ground but it’s always left me flat. Okay album but was kinda waiting for it to be over
gut ruhig schön manche lyrics zu weird eher so gedicht vortragen vibes
Loved a lot of songs on this one. Makes my brain zap in a good way.
very folky very fall vibes. not a favorite but enjoyed listening
Thoughtful and beautifully rendered
Never listened to this as a single album before. Though I know many of the big hitters of course.
Je m'attendais à une bouse d'un mec avec un ego surdimensionné et finalement c'était pas si mal
I love Simon's songwriting, sounds beautiful and effortless
It's OK but not something I would choose to listen. I did add Me and Julio... to my 1972 playlist, as it is a catchy tune. I'll likely rate this 2 stars.
It's everything you'd expect from a Paul Simon album. Unfortunately, nothing really hooked me, hence two stars.
It feels like an album that 40 year old me is gonna absolute love, I am 20. 7/10
nie moj klimat
Mother and child reunion - 8.1/10 Duncan - 8.6/10 Everything put together falls apart - 7.9 Run that body down - 8.9/10 Armistice day - 8.7/10 Me and Julio down by the schoolyard - 9.6/10 Peace like a river Papa hobo Hobos blues Paranoia blues Congratulations
My fuckin guy
favorite - everything put together fall apart 6/10
Very whimsical listen. Super chill to listen!
Not someone who has ever been on my radar, but I really enjoyed this. 3.5
Benign, pleasant, uncontroversial
Ugh, Paul Simon is just so... flaccid. Just another folk album, nothing to see here.
Favourite Songs: Duncan Peace Like A River Hobo's Blues Paranoia Blues
Muy bueno, nunca lo hubiese escuchado por voluntad propia, me sorprendió que aparezcan zampoñas y quenas en el segundo tema. Me gustó. Seguramente lo vuelva a escuchar.
Well. Me and Julio down by the school yard always reminds me of Wes Anderson films and just happy summer days. Great voice, easy to listen to on a New Year’s Day 1
I really enjoyed this and I think it'll be a good CD to throw in my car for a summer roadtrip :-)
It was fun!
Nothing gets the new years eve party going like Paul Simon!!!! This album is fine, but I have never really cared much for his solo work. Nothing was bad but a lot of it was bland. Mid 3.
A sweet voice, genius lyricism and the best acoustic guitar I've ever heard. How can it get better?
peak
Some good tracks on here and some forgettable ones, about half and half. Favorite tracks- “Mother and Child Reunion” “Me and Julio Down By The Schoolyard” “Paranoia Blues”
It's Paul Simon... not much more or less. pleasant but not extremly engaging album.
Boring and not my vibe
Superb lyrics, music that matches, and timeless hits. What more could you ask for
Meh
Pretty joce folk stuff on here, some catchy tunes but nothing special
Greta album. Can tell his writing was political and mentioning problems he wanted to address. Loved it!
"Me and Julio Down By the Schoolyard" is a classic, but I can't get into Paul Simon or Simon & Garfunkel in general. When you have two songs with the word "hobo" in the title, that's a sign this won't be my thing. Rounding up to 3 for "Me and Julio."
Pleasant folk album, nice acoustic guitar and vocals
Not my favorite genre, but still had a couple of songs that I enjoyed. Overall an average album, but definitely on the higher side of a 3.
Pretty cool. I liked Me and Julio, of course, and Stephane Grappelli is always cool. I liked some of the Blues inspired songs. Solid album. Favorite Track: Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard
Chill vibes Fave track: Me and Julio down by the Schoolyard
Pleasant enough. 3/5
Kind of songs I either want to listen to at a campfire or driving through woods on a late summers evening.
Not really a fan of country and this didn’t help at all. Mid
Really cool fusion of blues, funk, and rock. Standouts are Mother and Child Reunion, everything put together falls apart, armastice day, and peace like a river. Really good album 8.5/10
Every once in a while, I find myself disappearing down a Paul Simon rabbit hole. Much as I enjoy a bit of Simon & Garfunkel, it's Simon's solo work that really shines for me. With this record, he seemed to actively step away from that whimsical, folksy sound he'd honed with Garfunkel - a bold move when you consider how enormously successful that formula had been, but he absolutely nailed it. A beautiful, plush production that suits his voice fantastically, and some masterful songwriting - this is a great record.
I can put my hand on my heart and say I have NEVER heard this album and I only recognise one song, which seems to surprise me. That said I enjoyed it. It didn't blow me away but it was... nice... and a little interesting. I will listen to it again.
i’m sure this album was a banger when it was released, but it’s not my cup of tea i fear 💔💔
Nothing too impressive, I enjoy the instrumentals of the songs but I don’t think I’d listen to the album or songs again. I just listened to ‘paranoia blues’ and I really enjoyed that song and the production of it. Overall, this album didn’t wow me. I probably wouldn’t listen to it again but it was nice to experience something I’ve never heard before.
Synes det lyder virkelig velproduceret, en del sange jeg kan lide, men jeg savner Garfunkel på nogen af de mere simple numre og det hele er bare lige cutesy nok endnu. Man kan godt høre Graceland er på vej
De bedste numre var vildt gode, de dårligste numre var lidt fesne
Snoozefest
Mid, dec' 25, guitar mostly nothing special, could understand if this is someone's favorite though
Enjoyed this, would listen again for sure.
Listened 12/25/25
My Dad had a Paul Simon Best Of that he used to play when I was growing up so I was familiar with Mother and Child Reunion and Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard. There's something mercurial about the individual songs, I am enjoying them and something will happen lyrically or musically to throw me off or I'll be finding a song a little mundane and then a brilliant lyric or unexpected musical turn will grab my attention. As such, it's hard to rate this, because it's slippery and hard to fix an opinion on. I liked it more than Hearts and Bones but think Graceland probably has more magic so I'm going to award this a 3.
I enjoy the rhythm. However, unfortunately, I thought the lyrics were quite forgettable.
I love this classic record.
cant believe ive not heard this album before, wow peace like a river. yeah gorgeous love it
Top shelf Paul
8/10
i was not really moved by this. the sound is pleasant and deep but i'm not a big folk fan and the lyrics were nothing special. i don't see myself re-listening to any of these songs in the near future. still, i'm glad this was the first album to pop up in the generator. i would have not listened to it if it weren't for this proyect. i'm excited!!
Very interesting use of instruments, however, I will probably never listen to any of the songs ever again on my own.
Poslechla bych si znovu? Možná. Některé písničky fajn. Některé mají indiánský vibe. Asi bych stáhla půl hvězdy, kdyby to bylo možné.
Paul Simon's work has never resonated with me. I have no idea why. Clearly the man has talent being considered one of pop's greatest composers. But he does very little for me. That being said, this album is fucking great! Beautiful and personal, it deserves the praise.
Absolute joy of an album!
More hippy shit.
It was alright.. Duncan stood out Pretty mediocre though in my opinion but then again we all receive music differently and I can appreciate that somewhere out there this has changed someone's life.
Didn't know Paul Simon had a solo career after Simon and Garfunkel, was very good!
Eras el bueno, Paul?
Most enjoyable Paul Simon album I've heard! I might be converted
Too hippie/70s for me
Don’t care for it. Not my type of music.
6/10 good space filler album. Very suzie. Favorite song: peace like a river (duncan is also very good)
a bit too country for my liking.
Melodia cativante
One of the great songwriters and singers, displaying that he didn't need Art to make his art. This is the sound of my early childhood and is steeped in sepia tones in my memory. Not every song holds up solidly through the passage of time, but the ones that do shine brightly.
I definitely don't hate this album, but It doesn't stand out to me. There are a few songs I enjoyed and will listen to again, but not my favorite album.
Zuhause, Gerstetten, Deutschland. Ganz okay.
A solid album of songs. Simon can hit it out of the park sometimes but a few tracks seemed like filler to me.
A really soft album thats just a little too slow for my liking, particularly the last 5-ish songs. I’m okay with folk music but this one just didnt quite appeal to me. A few decent tracks but nothing too exciting in my opinion Standout songs: Duncan Run That Body Down Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard
It’s a 3.5
Paul Simon has very gentle voice. I really like his other album "Still crazy after all these years" but this one is also enjoyable. I would rate it 6,5/10
Although I am a big fan of Paul Simon, I had not heard this album through. Very relaxing and the two singles show a talent at adapting world music that would only improve throughout his solo career. I’m giving it a 4 but am sure it will grow to be a 5 with further listens.
I think I'm finally starting to get the Paul Simon hype, he's pretty amazing. I think I liked the stuff with Garfunkel more, but this was a really solid album. It is kinda a lot like the Simon & Garfunkel stuff, you can tell he wrote most of that stuff I just think his material was better there. Favorites: Run That Body Down, Peace Like a River, Paranoia Blues
This one surprised me and I don't know why. I put it off for a few hours until it hit me. Amazing singer songwriter stuff, I don't know why I wasn't expecting this to be good. 9/10
Tranquileras, para poner de fonfo
The real question is who will have more solo albums on the list between Simon and Garfunkel?… smart money is on Simon.
Run that bOdy down SLAYED
country folk old ppl music😭🙏
I enjoyed the creative melodies and chord progressions and instrumentation throughout. Incredible guitar work, and many genres encapsulated into this folk and story-telling album. I can see myself repeat listening to several of these tracks.
Dialed back but dialed in. Blue(s). Silver spoons. Plumes of steam. Blankets of snow.
Listened through twice, with reading the chronology (1972) makes this interesting if not great. I can understand the adulation, but he has better albums in his quiver. 1. Mother And Child Reunion 2. Me And Julio Down By The Schoolyard 3. Peace Like A River
mellow and emotional and silly and fun
Last two weeks all i'm getting is Paul Simon and Neil Young. I'm sick of both of them. I've heard Graceland and PSR&T and now this album. This album was done after separating from Garfunkel where Simon, I guess, had to prove that he's an actual musician and this proved that he was capable of writing songs and making music. Lyrically the songs are open and honest. Nothing overly creative, it's like conversational songwriting. Don't get me wrong, I think there's skill in being able to communicate your emotions effectively and directly, and that's what he does.....it just doesn't blow me away. It doesn't help that i'm just not interested in his music and this album is full of cartoony melodies. In terms of albums to listen to before you die, this one is replaceable and forgettable. I get that it established Paul Simon as a legitimate artist without Garfunkel but.........ok? Great. I think we can afford to drop this album since he's so represented on this list. As you can tell, I don't have a high impression of Paul Simon.
Lovely LP
Some nice folk rock. Probably need a few more listens, but doesn't stand out to me.
#31 I'm beyond done hearing folk from this list
3.5
Classic Paul Simon
Some highs, some lows. I feel like I listened to this as a teenager 20+ years ago so a handful of songs were familiar. Slow start, strong middle, weak end. Would give it a 3.5 if that were possible.
very fresh diversity of sounds, my dad called this one the weird album where he does a bunch of different sounds with random ppl from all over the place
This was a nice album. Good folk and some blues in there too. Nice listening.
I like 3 songs (Mother and Child, Me and Julio, Armistice Day...the rest were not necessarily horrid, just meh. Very easy listening, but that's about it...Congratulations sucked though. 3 stars MOR stars.
perfect for a snowy day like today. such a happy voice
Can’t believe I’ve never listened to this whole album. Not AS good as his other but still it’s Paul Simon.
141225 10:15 4 / highlights: me and julio down by the schoolyard, run that body down, mother and child reunion
Yeah
First listen
Okay.
Couple bangers, but overall pretty unremarkable to me. 6 for the couple of fun songs
Another one I liked more than expected. Simon is a great guitarist and a poignant lyricist, albeit prone to smugness. I was initially put off by the white boy reggae style of the first track, but there are definitely worse examples. A low 4
Favorite track(s): Mother and Child Reunion, Armistice Day, Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard
This is kind of like Bob Dylan made good music (I'm just kidding, I like Bob Dylan!!). But seriously, Paul Simon is probably one of my favorite artists ever. Me and Julio Down By the Schoolyard reminds me of my dad, in the best way possible.
Insane vocal ability and individual instrumental skill
One of the best songwriters ever. And he can sing.
love!
almost like "cowboy" music, not exactly my style but i can imagine these songs being played in brandy melville hahha
Wow very nice but when I went to find the album I got really scared because I saw his face and it was actually really scary I’m sorry
I’ve really been surprised by how hit-or-miss Simon & Garfunkel / Paul Simon albums have been for me. This one was a hit. I wasn’t fully on board with the first track, but Duncan came on and sounded familiar - I’d Shazammed it somewhere (a show or movie, maybe?), forgotten about it, but somehow I really love it. I’m a total sucker for that Andean panpipe thing it’s got going on (see also El Condor Pasa). From Duncan on, most everything was very good. I felt that the quality (or at least, my enjoyment) came close to Bridge Over Troubled Water, my favorite S&G album. I remember feeling pretty disappointed in “Graceland;” liking this made me wonder if I should revisit it. Favorites: Duncan, Run That Body Down, Armistice Day, Peace Like A River
Álbum bom da peste, com uns instrumentais sacanas de bom
This is my first review and I'm a little worried about review inflation so that may be coloring the number of stars I give this. Also I'm going to rank these against how well I think they belong on this list. A 3 star great album is still a soildly great album. 5 Stars would go to a work of genius with no flaws. One star would mean I question it's position as great but not necessarily that it's bad. That said, I recognize the importance of this album. It is laying the groundwork for a five star album 14 years in the future. It was one absolutely perfect song (Mother and Child Reunion) and one song I find annoying at best (Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard) and the rest are all range from pretty good to unoffensive. There are great bits to most songs but to me they are flawed breakthroughs pointing to the perfection to come.
My favourite from Paul Simon. Impressive first album following the breakup with Garfunkel. Nice warm sound and feeling with catchy tunes too.
This guys pretty good he should join a band or something
hobo’s blues was awesome !!! also “hobo” mention so that’s extra awesome
better than garfunkle???????????????????
Fine I’ll say it, I like Paul Simon
Initially, lots of energy. I liked the vibe from the very start. As I keep going though, I’m finding it a bit too bouncy and light. Not super my style. Almost annoying to me, and trying to keep myself from mindlessly changing the song.
Cozy vibes
Very good album. Strong songs, he’s a good songwriter worth listens.
Very good album. Definitely reminiscent of the Beatles as they were made in the same era. Very beautiful sonically. The album flowed extremely nicely while still having every song feel unique and exciting. My favorite song was paranoia blues because I loved the visuals. Definitely will have to check out more of his work
Mehhhhh not really for me. First song was all right
Self named lol
Really liked this album tbh
Generally pleasant but not all that interesting. A few tracks like Peace Like a River have nice instrumentation.
Fine folk album, but I see why only Me and Julio survived the test of time. Again, nothing wrong with this album, just no songs outside of the aforementioned were super smashing for me.
Whispy.
Paul Simon's 1972 self-titled album presents a confident and wonderfully diverse collection of songs. Though undeniably low-key and relaxed, the album is also fun. The record's enduring appeal rests on its standouts: "Mother and Child Reunion", an infectious track infused with reggae and recorded with Jimmy Cliff's band, and the truly sublime "Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard", a playful, samba-rhythm pop song that epitomizes light-hearted fun. What did the "Mama and Papa" see? But the album runs deeper than its hits. I especially appreciate the blues-drenched "Peace Like a River", anchored by truly wonderful acoustic guitar work. The track "Duncan", a beautifully crafted acoustic tale of a fisherman's son traveling Canada, and the album’s beautiful, sarcastically titled closing statement, "Congratulations", are equally brilliant deep cuts. Visually, the iconic portrait photograph by Edie Baskin is a perfect complement. The masterful framing and muted colours brilliantly capture the album's intimate and reflective contents. Packed with essential songs, "Paul Simon" remains a very good to great album. Four stars. Side one 1 "Mother and Child Reunion" (5/5) 2 "Duncan" (5/5) 3 "Everything Put Together Falls Apart" (3/5) 4 "Run That Body Down" (4/5) 5 "Armistice Day" (3/5) Side two 6 "Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard" (5/5) 7 "Peace Like a River" (5/5) 8 "Papa Hobo" (4/5) 9 "Hobo's Blues" (4/5) 10 "Paranoia Blues" (4/5) 11 "Congratulations" (5/5) Total - 47 Average - 4.27 178/1001 97/178 albums reviewed were new to me.
Mother and Child Reunion - 4/5 Duncan - 5/5 Everything Put Together Falls Apart - 2/5 Run That Body Down - 5/5 Armistice Day - 3/5 Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard - 5/5 Peace Like a River - 5/5 Papa Hobo - 3/5 Hobo's Blues - 2/5 Paranoia Blues - 3/5 Congratulations - 4/5 Average score: 3.6/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️ i guess i half-enjoyed this. there really are some gems in here, it's a shame i didn't care for half the tracks on here the album just seemed to lack cohesion in my opinion, like there were too many ideas being exploredon one album. i probably would've liked it if Paul stayed more in the folk lane
Pretty nice.
Tellement blues je m'attendais pas à ça! Dobro et slide en open tuning, formes blues etc. 2ieme album solo après le split après Garfunkel, (le premier a jamais été publié semble-t-il), il se cherche un peu, cet album a pas grand chose de spicy ou de unique, assez dull même si on tape un peu du pied sur certains blues J'ai de loin préféré Graceland meme si c'était longtemps après
Summer after college, in mournful limbo between everything that came before and a great unknown expanse, driving around with nowhere to be quite yet.
Unpopular opinion, but I liked this album way more than Graceland. Very emotional and heartfelt album that still manages to be fun the whole way through. Favorite Songs: Peace Like a River, Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard
American folk. Really not my think at all, like a weird form of storytelling but very much at the cost of the music being good.
A bright and shining way to start a solo career!
On erittäin hyvää laulamista ja kerrontaa. Kantaaottavuutta mutta maulla. Tämän ajan artisteja ei vaan ole enää.
I’ve never thought the two Pauls sounded alike before but some of this reminded me of Ram-era McCartney, That’s a compliment by the way (as is the fact that while I liked this, I prefer Graceland - how many 60s artists made their best album in the 80s? It might be just Paul Simon and Leonard Cohen.)
Overall Rating - 3.95/5 (7.91/10). Good introduction to Paul Simon's solo work.
5.5/10
Honestly great
Laid back yet energetic. Really into hobos seemingly. Great background music not in a negative way
This is extremelly dull. First song good and stand out song me and Julio down by the Schoolyard. The rest I never want to hear again
OK
Good folky album would listen to more paul
This was a good listen, lots of genres while not feeling like a jarring mix. Thanks Paul Only knew me and Julio before. Thought it was Julia. Clearly didn't know it very well Songs added to playlist: - Duncan - Run That Body Down - Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard - Paranoia Blues (unreleased version)
Not my thing but since watching the documentary must say I like this guy
Don't know this album off hand but love Paul Simon. Ok jumping right into a bopping reggae beat. Kinda sleepy after that, multiple songs about Hobos. But "Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard" instantly pushes this up a star. What a banger. Would listen again. 3.9/5
Duncan is my favorite Paul Simon song, but there are a number of so so songs
yes good
Paul Simon the man that you are. Short king legend and amazing songwriter. He may not have been dunkin’ on the court, but Duncan he did, and it’s so good! “Me and Julio Down By the Schoolyard” genuinely never grows old, that light guitar and cuica combo is unmatched. Might be close to a 5 for me if it didn’t have to compete with Bridge Over Troubled Water, Bookends, and Graceland. Favorite Tracks: Mother and Child Reunion, Duncan, Armistice Day, Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard, Congratulations
This was a great listen. I already had a couple of songs in playlists. For me, not quite a 5, but would happily listen again.
At their best, the songs on this album stand up with the best of Simon and Garfunkel's work, but at their worst they don't even approach Simon and Garfunkel's filler. Not sure what's the deal with that, since Garfunkel didn't even write the songs? I guess maybe Simon needed a quality control guy?
Classic. Not up for debate.
Paul Simon is always good, but this first solo album doesn't hold up against Simon & Garfunkel or his later solo work. Good but not great.
He’s no Bob Dylan (compliment)
Not his best work. After the album finished and Spotify moved on to related tracks it improved!
Faixa favorita: Paranoia Blues Letra favorita: “Everything Put Together Falls Apart” Como me senti: Country e hétero Resumo: Álbum solo que mistura folk, pop e narrativa íntima. Paul traz pequenas cenas do cotidiano em histórias cantadas, com leveza e humor. Reação pessoal: Escutei à noite de janelas abertas com o vento frio passando; foi como ouvir pequenas histórias de um jovem falido. Me fez pensar em estar perdida e juventude.
- O instrumental é leve e delicioso de se ouvir e um dos grandes pontos fortes do álbum na minha opinião. A flauta em Duncan é uma das coisas mais lindas que já ouvi. - A voz de Paul Simon é extremamente confortável de se ouvir. Tem um tipo de profundidade pela rouquidão que, atrelado a maciez da sua voz, faz com quê mesmo com o menor dos instrumentais, a música soe perfeita. Realmente, quem tem gogô sustenta. - Mesmo em um estilo como folk, Paul viajou pelos diferentes tipos de sonoridades. Enquanto antes sentia estar sentada a uma fogueira calmamente ouvindo ao violão, o impacto que tive ao estar ouvindo e do nada sentir que entrei em um saloon antigo quando Hobo's Blues começou foi um testamento a sua habilidade musical. Faixa Favorita: Duncan
Really liked the upbeat bluesy folk. Haven’t heard much of Paul Simon’s stuff outside Simon and Garfunkel.
This thing isn’t for me, but I did like it more than Dylan if we’re talking folk storyteller
It’s fine but knowing that Graceland is probably on this list it seems like a waste of time
This was nice! A more intimate entry with hints at Paul's fondness for world music that would manifest more strongly later. This feels like a "close" album.
Odeio quando os artistas não sabem quais são as músicas boas do álbum. Das 6 primeiras, só duas são boas, "Everything Put Together Falls Apart" e "Armistice Day". Ironicamente, são as duas com menos streams entre as 6 (talvez o errado seja eu). Da música 7 em diante o álbum melhora bastante. Com uma pegada bem mais raiz, melódica, e criativa. Apesar de "Peace Like a River" ter sido a minha favorita, é necessário fazer um menções honrosas à "Hobo's Blues" e "Paranoia Blues". A finalização não é das melhores, mas é honesto. Resumindo: um álbum que começa bem mal, com algumas ressalvas, e se redime no lado B. Faltou maturidade para explorar mais as ideias que eram de fato boas. Melhor do álbum: "Peace Like a River". Pior do álbum: "Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard".
Detesto Paul Simon. Álbum completamente esquecível. Não entendi a escolha do reagginho ser a primeira do álbum, mas é a melhor, mesmo sendo bem mediana
I love Paul Simon, there’s something about his music that grabs me and sticks like nothing else does. He has such gorgeous melodies, but also fantastic instrumentation. A beautiful album with a great variety of songs.
I really liked this. More than I expected to. Nice to go back to a 30- something minute album rather than 1 hour +.
love the similar flute sound to "El Condor Pasa" on Duncan. "Mother and Child Reunion" has this unique stop-start dub/reggae kinda feel. "Run That Body" down has the feel of most Paul Mccartney Beatles tunes.
Mixed bag but nothing that was awful.
2 - Ok. There is better Paul Simon music out there. The song Duncan is nice.
Such a delightful songwriter. Hard to have a bad time with him. 8/10
1. mother - 2 2. duncan - 1.5 3. together - 1 4. run - 1 5. day - 1.5 6. julio - 2.5 7. River -1.5 8. Papa - 1 9. Blues - 1 10. Paranoia - 1 11. Congratulations - 1.5
What do you do after being in one of the best duos ever? Record a brilliant album, and better to come. One of the greats.
I like some of Paul Simons stuff but this just didn't do it for me
There's part of me that thinks this album is at least as good as anything Simon and Garfunkel released. It certainly cements Paul Simon as the main songwriting force of the duo. There's also a ton of variety and some really stand out tracks here. "Me and Julio Down by the School Yard" may be my favorite thing he's ever done. There is a part of me though that feels like it's missing something. Maybe it's too eclectic without really gelling together, or maybe Art Garfunkel had a subtle quality that really helped to balance things out. For some reason, this album feels just shy of 5 stars to me, but I can't put my finger on it. But the thing is, I can't actually find any good reason *not* to give it 5 stars as it's really good album regardless. So I'm feeling generous in the hope that when the mood strikes me, this album will just fit perfectly because there's a lot to love here, even if I don't quite hear it as a whole today.
I quite enjoyed this. Quite a few different styles used with some quite catchy tunes and lyrics
Nice
I’ve always had a soft spot for Paul Simon, as he is one of my childhood heroes (the amount of time I sang scarborough fair in school plays, contests, concerts is absolutely insane), but this record is an absolute gem. I love the production and the use of the guitar, and Simon’s voice is velvety and light, absolutely delightful. Loved loved loved this record
Good interesting songs
Good album. Not as good as I was expecting, but good nonetheless.
Some classics.
This is a bit of a variety piece that just about works. The Calypso-esque sounds on first track didn’t get it off to a great start. It felt a bit forced where somehow the pan pipes on Duncan didn’t. Then you get some decent tracks dotted around. Some enjoyable funky guitar on Armistice Day and a few others that while not profound are generally decent. Papa Hobo sounded like a S&G song but very much poorer for only being half the equation. All in all quite a mixed bag and I’d probably rather just listen to S&G but there’s enough to pique the interest (just).
Interesting album which I found myself phasing in and out of with regard to my enjoyment. The plus for me was the often stripped back arrangement which allowed the unique elements to shine, and they captured the tones and depth of the featured as a result. It made some of the guitar elements in particular very engaging. Ultimately well put together. I think the key downside and probably which dated some of the songs was the incessant need to throw the kitchen sink at it with regard to the depth and variety of musical instruments on offer. From maraca to flutes. They have experimented themselves out of a 4 in my opinion here.
Overall this is a lovely sounding album. The well composed songs are perfectly recorded and the mix is artfully done. There is some really good stuff in there, particularly the guitar, but sometimes it just tries to do a bit too much. For example, I was really enjoying the stripped back guitar performance of 'Armistice Day', despite the bongos, then the maracas started and it lost me. The songs are all just a bit too saccharine for me and it lacks any bite or edge. From the moment it opened with a reggae track, the album had a tinge of self indulgence about it and the gratuitous use of flutes and tambourines made me think of over-exuberant secondary school music teachers.
well he's Paul Simon
Melancólico
Yes waiter I would like some Simon and Garfunkel, hold the Garfunkel
Liked it more than similar sounding albums but still don’t love it
First song sounded like Bob Marley. Nice peaceful music
No stand out songs for me, probably one of his weaker albums but will still happily listen to it over and over. He's a genius.
Who knew Paul Simon's music would improve by cutting off the dead weight of a lesser partner? I guess Paul Simon knew.
This album has a lot of classics on it even without Garfunkel
Excellent as Paul Simon may be, I’m not convinced he’s 100% for me. That being said, I think if you wanted to give a foreigner an album that explained America in the 70’s/80’s, this album may be a strong contender. Like a slightly folksier version of Springsteen
A great album by one of the best song writers ever. This was fun to listen to and who doesn't enjoy Julio down by the school yard!
Fine
Добротный, приятный альбом со спокойной, доброй музыкой. 7 из 10.
Álbum muito agradável. Arranjos e vocais no ponto! QoA Adonis New.
Etter å ha hørt S&G og Graceland, må jeg si dette var litt skuffende. Ikke dårlig, men heller ikke essensielt...?
Tror jeg har hørt mer på dette albumet enn noen S&G-plater, og ja, mer enn Graceland også. Selv om hans største låter kom ut sammen med Garfunkel, så mener jeg at dette albumet har flere verdige arvtagere. "Duncan" og "El Condor Pasa" kan man fint spille back to back for eksempel. De åpenbare hitsene "Mother and Child Reunion" og "Me and Julio" er certified bangers. "Hobo's Blues" får meg til å skjønne at Lillebjørn Nilsen har hatt plata også. Men når jeg hører albumet igjen nå så tror jeg soundet er det som treffer meg best. Simon er en mesterlig gitarist og det farger mye av lydbildet, og litt ekstra krydder med alle de snodige instrumentene han trekker fram her og der. Jeg klarer ikke peke på hvilken årstid plata passer best til, kanskje det er en helårsplate. Den føles egentlig bare som en logisk videreutvikling av Bridge Over Troubled Water, og viser at det er null tvil om at det var Paul Simon som dro lasset.
Man kan aldri slå helt feil med Paul Simon, det gjør man ikke her heller! Et knallgodt album med veldig kul produksjon. Han har skrevet bedre låter andre steder så derfor når den ikke helt opp til femmeren.