Reviews (page 7 of 13)
Yes, this is a jazz album. So very jazzy, thanks.
I'll take Monk over (more than?) half of this list.
Its jazz. Its old jazz. But the lyrics were good.
Delightful listen to it on the bike ride to work at work and from work
Incredible
Ei ihan mun juttu
I think I'm a bigger fan of the slower tracks; it's really good but I feel as if I don't understand jazz very well. Would like this on vinyl to continue listening though. Pannonica is my jam.
Brilliant. Always love some Monk time!
Would have voted 0 stars if it was possible
I like some 50's Monk. This has Sonny Rollins of Rollins Band, I believe... I'm a liar, don't listen to me. Monk is the embodiment of jazz on the piano. He's all over the place, but it works. These guys play well together. I like some of his later stuff better, like Monk's Dream and Monk., but this is a good one. A nice loungy jam session. I like this music, so it gets a 4.
I've never been super into this kind of jazz, but the longer I listen to it the more I could tap into it and enjoy it. No doubt about the talent and skill it requires to pull off. 3.5
I liked this a LOT. Nothing I didn't like about it honestly. Perfect jazz album.
May need to circle back to this one!
Jazz, not my thing, men lite chill. Kan förstå att det är bra.
Not my favorite Thelonious Monk album, but still a solid jazz classic.
Very cool. Monk had such a unique sense of melody. I love the smoky dark room vibes of “Pannonica.” Must-listen #162.
I know. He’s a legend. I think. And I’m grateful to this project for presenting this album for me to listen to because I absolutely would never have done so otherwise. But. But. It. Is. Jazz.
4/5
What an absolute delight of an album. Not so wild that it seems grating but never so calm that you lose interest. Put me in a wonderful mood to the point that I might listen to this (or something similar) every morning. Fantastic from start to finish. Wish I could give it a million stars!
A little too unstructured for my taste.
You like jazz? Meh, I prefer my jazz with some lyrics
Very very good jazz record. I enjoyed this alot. Normally I am somewhat hesitant with sax jazz, but this was great. This may make it to my regular jazz rotation
Jazz really isn’t my thing
I realized while listening to this that jazz is the original stoner music! Half joking, Jazz has a transformative quality that takes the listener to places and guides them through a journey of the band leader’s design. Thelonious Monk was frequently talked about in high school jazz band for his syncopation, which I am not sure Mr. Stevens did a great job explaining. As such, I can only judge this album on feeling, which Thelonious had plenty of. Key song for me was Ba-Lue-Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are, especially the bass solo and the drum solo, which you can hear the influence in the later recordings like Ginger Baker’s Toad. And of course, no jazz album is complete without a kick in’ Xylophone solo, provided by Pannonica. There is talent in this album I will never understand, but definitely respect and appreciate.
Random thoughts: * pleasant listen on my commute home. Definitely chilled me out despite the Denver traffic. * I’d heard of Thelonious Monk before but never listened knowingly before. This was some good classic jazz. * I’d definitely throw this on again some night for a chill night. * I’m not sure this is up there with Brubek or Miles Davis but it is good. Might take some time to grow on me.
I just don’t get jazz. I’m sure there’s some great musicianship on show here, but I can’t really tell. I also can’t get Garfield or any other 70s/80s cartoon out of my minds eye when listening to this genre. I now fancy some lasagne!
Very solid album, but not my favorite type of jazz. It all sounds good, just gets a little repetitive in an album format. High 3.
No expertise on Jazz, no understanding of what is innovative or musically why it is what it is, have a small jazz collection of jazz very much based on what simply sounds good to me, think have Monks genius of modern music vol 1, not heard this before but yeah sounds good. 3 Star
Very jazzy. We aren't usually the greatest fans of jazz, but we really enjoyed this one. Makes you want to move.
4.6
3/5 generic jazz
Perfecto
good jazz type music
really smooth and upbeat jazz music. i didn't know what hard bop was until tonight... it's a subgenre of bebop jazz that takes influence from rhythm and blues that's noted for its faster pacing and animated solos. i like jazz! i really really do. this album is great. however, this album, like many other albums doesn't stick out to me. it's very nice to listen to, i like the sort of swingin' jazz sound that sounds like everyone's bouncing along to the hits of the tom-toms, and the long tracks really showcase just how creative these solos can go. but alas... it's missing the spark that makes me obsessed. it's a shame, because again. i found this album pleasant to listen to. one song is vocal and there's a few piano focus tracks... really there's just a few other jazz albums that blend into this one i think.
This is one that I'm gonna have to spend more time with. I can listen to this and very plainly see that Brilliant Corners is full of extremely intricate, emotive jazz compositions, and I can understand that Monk is considered among the greatest jazz composers/musicians ever for a damn good reason. Just listen to the title track for everything great about this in a nutshell: it's really a staggering song. However, I regret to say that I have yet to really digest and connect to these songs, but I can definitely appreciate what I'm hearing on some level. I'm gonna give this a healthy 4, because I really can't imagine giving it anything lower.
not into jazz enough to know how to correct rate it. but i did enjoy this quite a bit. will be revisiting alot
Not my style but a decent listen.
Been getting more into jazz as of late, so this was a fun, perfectly timed treat. I loved it.
6/10
I'm sure it's brilliant music, but it is not for me.
++: Brilliant Corners, Pannonica, I Surrender, Dear, Bemsha Swing +: Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are 9,4/10
jazz place holder
Não é um estilo de música que me agrada. Ótimo pra deixar como música de fundo.
Listened while driving, probably better for lying about in the sun or relaxing in the evening
Great music to code to. Love this vibe/instrument combination.
Good.
Very pleasant and set a good vibe, but I'm not a big enough jazz fan to find it particularly notable. Favorite song: Brilliant Corners
I know I'm not a jazz aficionado, but this just made me think of Will Ferrell scatting as Robert Goulet ("BOP BOP doo doo doo doo...GOULET!"). Really hard to get into this one. 1.8
Überfordert mich komplett - obwohl bestimmt technisch meistervoll
Brilliant stuff really, I still feel like I have to learn more abour jazz compsitions and what they do to really get into this one more, but in the two times I have listened to it its been a great time I think. Monk never disappoints imo
Light and refreshing! Awesome musicians all!
Yeah idk I like Jazz but this wasn't it. It did some interesting things but honestly the parts I liked most were the most basic parts and that was disappointing. Hoping we get some more redeeming Jazz albums as the list goes on. Hoping we get some Doolittle by the Pixes soon bc im in dire need of a 5/5. Favourites - Pannonica, I Surrender, Dear
I’m sure in some dingy, smokey club in the 50s in America with 2 fingers of whisky, this shit would slot in perfectly. Impressive performances, as is standard from the genre, but this album is exactly the kind of aimless, meandering wankery that puts the vast majority of people off Jazz in general, myself unfortunately included. It is, at best, background music, and just in no way the kind of thing I’d ever actually want to sit and actively listen to. Brilliant Corners (3/10) Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lure-Are (3/10) Pannonica (4/10) I Surrender, Dear (2/10) Bemsha Swing (3/10) 3/10
Another decent jazz album - I'm actually starting to look forward to anything in this genre. Ouch, my knees!
This seemed like a simpler jazz record to enjoy. Was bluesy, catchy just straight up enjoyable. Outstanding musicianship. I liked this a lot. Fun to listen to.
I do indeed fear the jazz!
Норм джаз, хотя иногда слишком мудрёный
Not a fan 3/5
Good background/chill
That’s good listening. Sometimes I think jazz songs can lose the plot. Not the case here
Thelonious Monk has to be the most distinctive musician we've had since they started recording music. The notes sound incorrect but it just works. He's just as impressive for what he doesn't play as for what he does. Solo Monk on I Surrender Dear has to be one of the loneliest sounds out there. It's not a warm, comforting solitude like Bill Evans or Marty Robbins yodeling his cowboy songs, this is the solitude of the guy you ignore asking for money at the exit on the highway.
Simple, complex, the music seems to flow rather than have composition, but there's not a single honk, hat tap, or key strike out of place
not sure to completely get this kind of music but i can recognize it's good
Gjennomgående lavt tempo og til tider tungrock-tungt. Veldig spennende album fra en veldig spennende tid i jazz-historien.
It kind of sounds like they are hitting wrong piano notes but it somehow still sounds ok
Not for me but I understand it’s jazz pedigree
Ich weiß, dass ich Jazz nicht verstehe, aber das war einfach langweilig und ich fand es nervig.
Not my fave either, every piece is played beautifully but it didn’t give me the same feelings of nostalgia.
Not for me. Doesn't make me feel anything and is very slow. Not sure jazz is my cup of tea.
This was super relaxing to listen to, with a few parts that excite everything. Great jazz album
Peaceful but disquieting. Monk plays with a stuttering skittish rhythm, pausing unexpectedly, tripping and catching up, emphasizing beats you weren't ready for and holding a rest a beat longer than usual. This is all most evident on the solo piece 'I Surrender, Dear' where it's him and the piano and he's free to riff without a bass/drum waiting on him trying to keep time. The blues and swing pieces are classic hard bop, warm and lively with hints of dissonance from the piano shading the tone and pushing new harmonic interpretations of the melodies.
10/10. One of the coolest albums of all time.
Brilliant corners. Sadly, what lies within them is unlistenable shit. I set out with an open mind, but this project is really starting to turn me against jazz... One of the keys on that piano is definitely a bit out as well!
Awful. Close to an hour of mindless, rambling instruments playing over each other. Not for me.
It's good but didn't feel like it
2nd album from generator. It was a good listen while riding my mountain bike. Jazz is all over the place for me, but it's interesting sometimes. Maybe it's growing on me?
I think I can appreciate that this is "good", but I can't say I had a good time listening to it. I need my jazz with boundaries, dang it!
So... Ya like Jazz? Thelonius Monk's Brilliant Corners is the first Jazz album I have been served. I liked it! The whole thing felt like tumbling down a flight of stairs, bumping and running into things along the way. I probably wouldn't go out of my way to listen to this again, but I appreciate it for what it is.
Laid back relaxing effortless cool from one of the masters of jazz. As with most Jazz it would benefit from hearing it in the confines of a club but soothing nonetheless.
This was better than the last jazz offering thrown my way by this generator… but only just.
I keep wondering if one day I'll wake up and have suddenly gained an appreciation of jazz. It's not happened yet. At one point during Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are, the drums reminded me of roadworks. I did not hate this like I hated Bill Evans, but I can't say I particularly enjoyed it either. Once again, I'm bemoaning the lack of half stars. 2/5
# 493 : Brilliant Corners : 02/06/2025 MORE BORING JAZZ! I honestly can't say anything bad about it, except it seemed more like they are constantly warming up and I spent the whole album waiting for them to start playing something. Whatever I was doing while I was listening to this album was more enjoyable than this.
I mean, of course you have to have Thelonious Monk on this list. Jazz isn’t really my thing, but this was enjoyable and made great background music while I read. I’d give this 3.5 stars if I could because a 3 feels too low for this album, but I won’t listen to it enough to justify a 4. I’m rounding down, but it’s a high 3 for me and an album that definitely deserves to be on the list.
I don’t think jazz is for me.
Interessante, magari non è il mio genere preferito, ma mi piace molto.
Leuk om jazz te leren kennen.
i love this kind of jazz. It's entrancing. it's relaxing. it's telling a story and it's beautiful. Could listen to this all day
Not my kind of music, but of course interesting.
This is cool jazz - not smooth and never simple, not easy listening. I was in the mood for a challenge with this one and it delivered. Never going to be the biggest jazz fan but got my foot tapping and jazz hands flapping for this.
I just don't get jazz.
Meh
Just good vibes the whole time. 4 stars
crazy name
Listening notes: - Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are is giving Cruella de Vil (edit: Mel Leven paid homage to Monk with the Cruella song for the Disney film) - Sonny Rollins is IN FORM - Pannonica is where the swing really comes and gets ya. - I'd say that hard bop is better with Monk on the keys.
Really enjoyed it! Some jazz can feel too disjointed for me and this was great. Cohesive but still jazzy. Made me feel like I was more cultured for having listened to it
Did not like. Liked one of the pop songs. Violently happy.
It’s not background music
a lovely listen - album as a collective whole when you’re in the mood for jazz
# Album Name: Thelonious Monk # Artist: Brilliant Corners # Rating: 2/5 # Comments: The only corner this reminds me of is one of those sharp edges you manage to catch your balls on when you walk on by. I gave it a chance but i didnt enjoy this one. # Top Tunes: Not a single sausage # Would I listen to it again? No
Monk on form, I expect I'll only really appreciate this after coming back to it a few times. I read something recently that mentioned that one of the difficulties with appreciating Jazz is that people don't come to it chronologically, and so its hard to recognise the influence this has had on music you've already heard.
Amazing
It's not bad, but it's not good either. The first few songs are great, with some really nice solos to listen to. But as you progress through the songs, they start to sound like elevator music. Despite the few songs, listening to the end was a huge challenge.
Yesterday I lamented how 5 tracks at 45 minutes was too long, but today I’m going to contradict myself and say I enjoyed this one. I guess I like this jazz album a bit more than the funk/soul album of Isaac Hayes, either that or 42 minutes is fine, but 45 is too much? What can I saw I’m inconsistent. 3.5 rounded up to 4 stars.
Brilliant album, really enjoyed hearing it again.
I am not a huge fan of jazz, but liked this
i never listen to jazz but this is serious so 5 fuckin’ stars it is
I really want to appreciate this because I want to be the kind of person who appreciates the jazz greats. Besides, “hard bop” sounds like it should be bops that go hard, and “Thelonious Monk” has to be the coolest name that’s ever been. Alas, these meanderings just didn’t do much for me. They were pleasant. And I recognize and like the riff off the last track, “Bemsha Swing,” even adding it to my 1001 playlist. But the rest of the record, to use a technical term, felt too doodly to me. Sorry, Theo.
jazzz
Really solid jazz. Glad I listened!
Muy escuchable, no se hace insoportable de escuchar
As technically good as this clearly is, it made me want to punch something.
It takes a lot to make me like jazz. I like Kind of Blue and there were bits here that I could relax to. Other bits sounded like stereotypical American TV tunes gone wrong.
I like how this one sounded, but I couldn't get into it. I couldn't really pick out any motifs or parts to recognise. It just meandered along. The overall sound reminded me of time out by Dave Brubeck only that album has recognisable songs. So I prefer it. My star ratings are all over the place. Maybe this is a 2.5.
beginner to jazz
jazz 👍
I've heard some Thelonious Monk and I just find it falls on the wrong side of the track for me. This album, despite the awesome album cover, delivers experimentation and creativity that doesn't pay off for me. Not enough to be any better than middle of the road, I found.
Hey baby that's jazz, deal with it!
I don't have an ear for jazz. I can't find the groove, each 8-minute song is a slog. Maybe it's good. I'll never know.
Some more 50's jazz! Can't say I know too much about Mr. Monk, despite knowing the name. Pretty interesting playing style he has, which is evident in the first two compositions especially. I don't claim to be a music scholar, but the title track in particular sounded different than other jazz at the time purely due to its unconventional structure and almost "off key" piano playing. Yet I now understand that was Monk's flair and style. Things slow down after side one, becoming more "conventional" in a sense I guess. The first two tracks are definitely the highlights here. Also, the second track, "Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are" definitely inspired the Cruella De Vil song that Roger sings in 101 Dalmatians, yeah? Couldn't help but immediately think of that as soon as the first few notes hit.
## In-Depth Review of *Brilliant Corners* by Thelonious Monk *Brilliant Corners*, released in 1957, stands as a pivotal work in both Thelonious Monk’s career and the evolution of modern jazz. This review will explore the album’s music, lyrics (where applicable), production, themes, and influence, and conclude with a balanced assessment of its strengths and weaknesses. --- ## Music **Compositional Innovation** *Brilliant Corners* is renowned for its compositional complexity and innovation. The title track, “Brilliant Corners,” is particularly notable for its unconventional structure-an eight-bar A section, a seven-bar B section, and a modified A section-making it one of the most challenging pieces Monk ever wrote. The rhythmic accents, abrupt tempo changes, and jagged phrasing required the musicians to attempt over 20 takes in the studio, with the final version being a splice of several attempts[6][7]. This complexity is not just technical showmanship; it reflects Monk’s unique vision of jazz as a space for both structure and surprise. **Instrumentation and Performance** The album features a stellar lineup: Thelonious Monk (piano, celeste), Sonny Rollins (tenor saxophone), Ernie Henry (alto saxophone), Oscar Pettiford and Paul Chambers (bass), Max Roach (drums, timpani), and Clark Terry (trumpet on “Bemsha Swing”). Monk’s piano playing is central-his use of dissonant clusters, angular melodies, and percussive touch is unmistakable. Rollins’ saxophone work is a highlight, especially in his interplay with Monk, providing both contrast and cohesion[2][6][8]. Other tracks, such as “Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are,” showcase extended improvisation over a modified blues form, with the musicians stretching out and exploring the harmonic landscape. “Pannonica” introduces the celeste, giving the ballad a dreamy, surreal quality, while “I Surrender, Dear” is a solo piano piece where Monk’s stride influences and harmonic daring are on full display[5][7]. **Rhythm and Harmony** Monk’s rhythmic approach is idiosyncratic. He subdivides rhythms in unexpected ways while maintaining a swinging pulse. His harmonies, often built from dense clusters and unusual intervals, were initially seen as eccentric but have since become a hallmark of modern jazz composition[7][8]. The tension between Monk’s avant-garde tendencies and the more traditional approaches of his collaborators adds a palpable energy to the performances. --- ## Lyrics *Brilliant Corners* is an instrumental album, so there are no lyrics to analyze. The album’s expressive power comes entirely from the music-the interplay of melody, harmony, and rhythm-rather than from words. Any “narrative” or emotional content is conveyed through Monk’s compositional voice and the improvisational dialogue among the musicians[2][6]. --- ## Production **Recording Challenges** The production of *Brilliant Corners* was famously difficult. The complexity of the title track required producer Orrin Keepnews to splice together multiple takes, a rare practice in jazz at the time. This was not due to lack of skill among the musicians, but rather the unprecedented demands of Monk’s writing[6][7]. The rest of the album was recorded more conventionally, but the sessions were still marked by a sense of experimentation and risk. **Sound Quality and Engineering** For its era, the album’s sound is warm and clear, capturing the nuances of Monk’s piano, the bite of the horns, and the dynamic range of Roach’s drumming. The mix allows each instrument to be heard distinctly, which is crucial given the density of the arrangements. The occasional use of celeste and timpani adds unexpected timbral colors[8]. --- ## Themes **Innovation and Individuality** The overarching theme of *Brilliant Corners* is innovation. Monk’s compositions break away from standard song forms, embracing odd phrase lengths, abrupt modulations, and dissonant harmonies. The album is a statement of artistic individuality-Monk’s refusal to conform to prevailing jazz norms[6][7]. **Joy and Playfulness** Despite its complexity, the album is suffused with a sense of joy and playfulness. The music is full of “jaded edges and sharp, pointy exteriors,” but also “jovial excitement” and moments of unexpected beauty[5]. Tracks like “Bemsha Swing” and “Pannonica” balance cerebral invention with emotional warmth. **Struggle and Perseverance** The recording process itself, especially for the title track, becomes a metaphor for perseverance and creative struggle. The musicians’ efforts to master Monk’s demanding material are audible, giving the album an undercurrent of tension and release[6]. --- ## Influence *Brilliant Corners* is widely regarded as a landmark in jazz history. It was Monk’s first album for Riverside to feature primarily original compositions, and it marked a turning point in his recognition as a composer and bandleader[4][6]. The album’s influence can be traced in several directions: - **Jazz Composition**: Monk’s willingness to experiment with form, harmony, and rhythm paved the way for later innovators like John Coltrane and Ornette Coleman[1][6]. - **Performance Practice**: The album demonstrated that jazz could be both highly structured and deeply expressive, influencing generations of musicians in how they approach ensemble playing[7]. - **Cultural Impact**: *Brilliant Corners* is regularly cited in “must-hear” album lists and is considered essential listening for any serious jazz fan[2][8]. --- ## Pros and Cons | Pros | Cons | |---------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------| | Groundbreaking compositions and structures | Some tracks are so complex they required splicing, losing spontaneity[6][7] | | Stellar performances, especially from Monk and Rollins | Not all musicians are equally comfortable with Monk’s demands[7] | | Rich, innovative harmonic and rhythmic language | The album can sound “dated” or “cliché” to some modern listeners[2]| | Emotional depth and playfulness amid technical brilliance | Accessibility: challenging for jazz newcomers in places | | High production quality for its era | Lack of lyrics may limit appeal for some | | Enduring influence on jazz and beyond | Occasional unevenness in ensemble cohesion | --- ## Conclusion *Brilliant Corners* is a masterwork of 20th-century music-an album that captures Thelonious Monk at the peak of his creative powers. Its combination of compositional daring, virtuosic performance, and emotional resonance makes it both a challenging and rewarding listen. The album’s production history, marked by struggle and perseverance, only adds to its mystique. While the album’s complexity and idiosyncrasy may present barriers for some listeners, its innovations have become foundational to modern jazz. The interplay between Monk’s singular vision and the contributions of his bandmates results in music that is at once cerebral and deeply human. For those willing to engage with its “brilliant corners,” the album offers endless rewards-a testament to the enduring genius of Thelonious Monk.
It was ok, a bit boring, didn’t really change me on my whole jazz adventure in any way. I can see why this is on the list, but maybe it just wasn’t for me
I quite enjoyed listening to this album. It was great music to have on while I was working on tasks that needed my "full attention" and thought processes. I don't know if I can see myself just sitting down and listening to this without having something else I'm doing.
it's jazz
Not a bad album, but it's just not for me.
The Good: Brilliant corners are better than sharp corners! The Bad: If corners are too brilliant… The Ugly: Realizing that cutting corners would’ve been better… We’ve got Thelonious Monk, one of the larger names in the Jazz game… if you are into jazz. If you are just into listening to music, then you probably would not have listened to this, as it takes a compass and several maps, and one of those army knives, in order for you to be prepared for the unknown. This album was not my thing, as it is the kind of Jazz that I am not such a big fan off… Give me swing, give me easy… just don’t give me this. However, glad I did get to listen to it, and will dish out a lovely 3*
Джаз это классно, но на постоянной основе бы не слушала.
Kept getting better and better.
Listened twice although not super closely either time. I'd go back to Kind Of Blue before this.
Yeah... I'm not a fan of these old experimental jazz albums, it was just kind of boring to me, it's okay, it's clearly well made & competent, just not for me, I can see why it's so highly regarded though, still, I thought it was boring.
This album turned out to be a pleasant surprise, especially considering it leans into the more avant-garde side of jazz. It’s a good example of how experimental jazz can still feel accessible and grounded. The instrumentation is strong throughout, but what really stood out to me was how Monk uses the piano as much for rhythm as he does for melody. Also, an interesting bit of backstory is that the title track was so complex it had to be pieced together from several takes. That really shows how intricate and demanding the composition is. Even though the album feels slightly off-center, it’s very intentional and well crafted. This is definitely the type of jazz I’d like to explore more deeply moving forward.
Jazz is just not for me.
Again, really nice. I understand the structure but it doesn't move me. Enjoyable in the background. I can't see sitting down and listening all the way through.
It’s jazz. Interesting but still jazz
Not bad
I Surrender, Dear
Type of jazz I really enjoy. Drums and piano are always wonderful, it was really relaxing to listen to to. Overall I’d say 9/10 great tracks, not too many, they’re a bit long and completely instrumental, so I’m sure not everybody would like it as much as I.
good stuff, but not for me
Jazz sounds all the same to me… I guess I’m just not cultured
I need to be further educated on jazz at some point. Of course I know of the greats like Mingus, Davies, Coltrane and Sanders, but I've never really dove into their discographies, having only heard single records from them. Thelonious Monk is one of these great Jazz men I've completely ignored, sticking to my safe and accessible fusion records instead. And while that's all and good, it turns out that when you're reviewing a jazz record it's pretty handy to know a thing or two about the thing you're reviewing. With the disclaimer that I'm completely uneducated when it comes to the genre I'm still hoping to provide something of value with my first time reaction to this. Going into this with no expectations what so ever, and hoping it provides me with some memorable moments that make me want to explore this genre further. Brilliant Corners It sounds complicated as all hell. The bass and piano feel very in line with each other, while the sax is almost standing in opposition to them. The piano feels very deliberate and melodic. I enjoyed that, sounds spacey. The composition respects each individual musician giving them plenty of spotlight both solo and as a unit. Good. 4/5 Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are I can see why people say the "Cruella de Vil" song is similar to this. The opening melody bears a lot of resemblance to it. Has a sophisticated aura about it, I think it has a lot to do with how the piano notes are parsed out throughout the sax part. Love how the opening motif subtly comes through occasionally with the piano part. Feels like I'd have a better time with this if I understood the technical and theoretical aspects of this better. I can tell a lot is going on that I'm not equipped to understand. The bass solo is pretty cool. Difficult to comment on, on one hand I really liked the main motif, and I found the sections where the musicians worked in unison to be pretty entertaining. On the other hand the solos were a big question mark for me, because I don't understand the intricasies of what was going on I sadly ended up being pretty bored by them. It is in no means actually boring I'm sure, I simply don't get it. Fine. 3/5 Pannonica Sounds like a messed up music box to start. Sleepy tempo. Love the little musical "cuts" for a lack of better term. Love how cute and pleasant the celesta sounds. TIL that is an instrument that exists. That felt pretty accesible and sweet. I really like the main tenor sax melody here, feels really classic. Decent. 3.5/5 I Surrender Dear Has a sadness to it, feels moody and deep. Really enjoy the sparseness of the track. Feels quite dense, despite only featuring Monk and his piano. Decent. 3.5/5 Bemsha Swing I like the shift in tempo and energy from the previous two tracks. The percussion here is really fun. Kinda melds into the background after a bit. I fail to find anything to notable about it. Fine. 3/5 A worthwile listen for sure, but I don't feel like I got as much out of it as I hoped I would. In all fairness I think the musicianship on this thing is absolutely stellar, even an untrained ear can hear the complexity of the compositions and the insane technicality of the performances. However I know next to nothing about jazz, so while I can appreciate the talent I have no idea what is going on. While the stereotype says you must "feel the jazz" that only works on a surface level. A singular groove or a motif might stay in your head for a while, the intricacies however can easily be lost. Sadly I felt lost a lot, and when I'm lost the music sort of melds into the background, becoming mere noise. I'm however extremely happy this was the album I rolled to day, as it's challenging nature made me feel stimulated trying to pierce it together. I'd love to revisit this someday with more educated ears to see wether my tastes have changed. Based completely on a surface level first reaction I'm giving this 3.5 stars out of 5, though for the site's limited rating system's sake it's closer to a 3 than it is to a 4. Fave track. Brilliant Corners
Good jazz, I liked the sax. But a bit too sleepy for my state of mind
I like how you can mentally fall in and out of this kind of jazz. I don’t know if it’s me or what the artist intended, but I partially engage with it until a chord or melody draws me back in. It’s a more rhythmic way to listen to music than how I frequently do.
My problem with jazz is that I feel like I need both a music and history degree to understand it.
As far as Jazz goes, it goes without saying that unless it is along the lines of "In A Sentimental Mood" or "Blue In Green" then it will likely not be my preferred style of music. There was definitely a sense of direction to the chaos which lacked on Coltrane's album and thus made this slightly more palletable and thus earning a hard 3.
Good improv on the album. Solid overall, a lot of Thelonious Monk music is more original and intricate/complex. The album felt fine but I didn't fall in love with it and wouldn't have it on repeat if I was in the mood to listen to a jazz playlist.
Feels like I need a PhD in Musicology to appreciate this. I enjoyed it but wouldn't seek it out again. 3/5.
Cover song is most played, classic Monk in these tunes.
Interesting listen. Enjoyed this one. Lot less dated than other jazz listens so far. Highlights: None
At times it swings too far into a few unsatisfying and unorthodox places but overall I enjoyed the quirkiness. It’s easier to get into the swing of things when you listen to it as purely a performance rather than looking for a traditional song format or structure. It’s play.
Definitely a lot more experimental than some of the other jazz on this list. It was fun to see the inspiration for the song "Cruella de Vil" from 101 Dalmatians in "Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are". I wasn't as impressed with the instrumentation with this album. Decent album and I appreciate it as a piece of art, but it's not something I see myself listening to again.
Not that interesting, and at times the band didn't even sound locked in. Also, god forbid saxophonists make pleasing sounds come out of their instruments every once in a while.
Classic jazz album. Didn't really listen listen to it, but it was aight.
hmm no likey
Good background music for a rainy Saturday night.
Pretty nice Jazz - could do with a bit more groove for my tastes but perfectly listenable.
Pretty good, not a Jazz enthusiast, but I can appreciate how much effort went into this album and the songs have their own themes and composition.
V pohode jazzicek na pozadi.
Yeah I dunno it's a jazz album - this shit all sounds the same to me.
Reminds me of the talented Carl Fletcher!
Good, not ground breaking. Enjoyed it enough to not turn it off.
It was great at one time. Sounds dated.
A really enjoyable Hard Bop record that stands out in a field of standouts.
It’s Thelonious Monk, but it’s also Rollins, Henry, Terry and Roach that bring the vision to life. If you like jazz, you will love this. If you hate jazz, buckle up for the jazziest jazz record out there. This is a treasure of an album, songs played by the absolute best at what they do.
likey likey
Helt ok jazz, men inget som fångade mig
Album very Jazz. Contains much sound. It is rated. I respect how the other members play well with this pianist.
Even when it's good, instrumental jazz just bores me to death.
Couldn’t quite get there, but the melody that reprises is interesting. Feels winsome and then just a bit off with the final harmony so close. There’s a cinematic/storytelling shorthand that uses jazz or the jazz fan identity to signal that the (usually white, male) character is serious, consumed by dark thoughts, has seen the truth of the world and is shaken by it, usually cursed to have an occupation fighting for justice. Their solace is in vinyl, their intelligence demonstrated by knowing which sideman filled in for the session that one day, their taste by preferring that unknown and forgotten player to the bigger name. Meanwhile, like most, Monk was grinding away at making difficult (to play) music, but not for sombre audiences to stare into their drinks while their forgetting to ash a cigarette.
I took a jazz history class in college and remember how much the music benefited from having someone versed in the genre explain to you what was going where and why. That was a great class, it made me feel really smart. But I don't think I'm smart really, because basically my taste in and opinions on jazz range from "my type" to "not my type." This is sort of my type, but I found it kind of washed over me? I listened 6 times and kept waiting for something about it to hold my attention. There are jazz records that can, but this one just didn't. Kind of a pleasant wallpaper? I don't know. I liked I Surrender Dear best, maybe because it had the easiest melody and was less fussy than the rest, since it's just Monk and not all the other players. I don't know. I should go back to college.
idk what the deal is here this feels like nothing
This is, without question, a masterpiece. But for me? I feel like Emperor Joseph II watching Mozart in the 1984 classic, Amadeus: "Too many notes!" I respect it, I do—it’s genius at work. But I’m over here clapping on the wrong beat, nodding like I get it, and secretly wondering if Monk’s piano is mad at me.
Very comfy. Feels timeless, and I can easily relax to this.
Brilliant! I will definitely listen to this one again.
I'm sure this is top notch to all enthusiasts
Honestly really nice I loved the instrumentals and beat
A bit anonymous
Classic Thelonius Monk
His third album..A jazz jam session of sorts. Five tracks for 43mins. If jazz is your thing this is a seminal album. It's still a good listen anyway. Great musicianship. Enjoyable.
I Surrender, Dear. This album and its Brilliant Corners have me in awe.
Another solid album where nothing's really standing out to me... though not exactly my flavor of jazz either.
Challenging, gripping, I listened to this while making loaded potatoes and spent the entire time bopping. I can immediately understand why this isn't everyone's cup of tea but I loved it
Great album, love this kind of sound, it's just not the absolute best I've heard in this style. I like some of Thelonious' later work more. EDITGreat album, love this kind of sound, it's just not the absolute best I've heard in this style. I like some of Thelonious' later work more. EDIT: Its health is... improving.
This would probably be cool at a nighttime jazz club or bar. I probably shouldn’t have listened at 1am when I was half asleep. Edit nearly a year later: Can confirm, shouldn't have listened while half asleep. Bumping up to a 3
👋 Jazz 👋 This whole album feels heavy in experimentation - no minute goes by without a total switchup in the song structure. Maybe this is the zoomer in me, or maybe it's just a style of jazz I'm not used to, but as an album experience it felt absolutely disorienting. With so many different ideas every second, though, you do end up with a lot of very cool individual moments. Standout track was Bemsha Swing Edit: Nearly a year later, I have found myself smoking the shit that made the Monk Lonious. It's a very rewarding listen if one can get through the chaos! Bumped from 2 stars to 4 stars.
I honestly do not have much to say about this one. It was fine. It didn't really leave an impression on me in any way.
Terrific album cover. Favorite track: Pannonica 3.5/5
3- Stars (7/15)
Cooooool daddy-oh.
Not into jazz
Not on Amazon
Mmm... Excellent. 4/5.
This was good fun.
Such a unique style of playing. So "ugly" in a sense... Still, there's something about it that captivates you, even if it may be "simple" or even silly at times. Glad I finally got around to hearing some Monk
Nice to hear some jazz. I enjoyed it but it didn't blow me away, not the biggest fan of thelonius, a little too much dissonance sometimes
Classic album.
Things are happening in my brain.
Stars to recognise the quality of his musicianship but this style of music doesn't do it for me.
an interesting jazz album. very classic sound for sure. Would I listen again: Probably Deserves to be on this list: Yes 8.0/10
Too-too-tooo-tooom / 10
Holy smokes, no wonder it took so many takes to get that first track. There's so much going on, and those rhythm changes are wild. You've got some incredible personnel on this besides monk. Rollins is a monster on the sax. And I love Maximum Roach's drumming. He's right up there with Blakey and Rich for me. I've never heard this album before, but it's definitely going to enter my rotation. It's easy listening but also has some progressive elements found in later 60s post bop than what was typical of 50s jazz. I could play this at home without and get my jazz fix without getting too many raised eyebrows.
I don't have the right knowledge to appreciate this kind of music. It sounds like music to me. It's fine.
Really bored mostly goes on too long and doesn’t change much, it’s really cool from a technical standpoint but not something I’d ever want to like “listen” to. It would be really good background music but for actually listening I found it very boring. I did somewhat enjoy “Pannonica” and “I Surrender, Dear” so it wasn’t a total wash but definitely not something I will probably ever return to. Unless at some point in the future I get into jazz which at this moment I find unlikely.
Jeh - mal öppis anders. Schön, harmonisch, ziitlos. Nüd für 24/7, gfallt mer aber.
monk isch amel so extra sloppy huuere geil. finds en uhuere geils stuck s erste. es entscheidt sich nie würkli wo ane aber blibt irgendwie ide gliche stimmig immer. balue bolivar? balues are?? hä. sehr sehr cool. es isch easy frei irgendwie für 57? ok es isch schono hard boppig. i surrender dear huuere schö nur klavier er groovt wie sau. bis chli passiv am gnüsse.
brilliant corners of olimpico fame?? das isch HARD BOP??? mega fun ja also ich han wenig dezue z sege. finds bis jz sehrsehr schöni musig und ich meine es 68 jahr alt, das isch schono crazy ehmm jaa smooth und schön aber halt für mich nüt uuunglaublichs. drei
Pefect jazzy background to work to. Helps that I also love jazz.
On 4/14/46 Mel Ott hit home run number 511, the final one of his career.
Smoove
Hard to rate jazz albums, always good but don’t know enough to really differentiate them. Good listen though.
I started this project because I was in a bit of a musical rut (my Spotify Wrapped felt like an intervention) and wanted to expand my horizons. And so far it's working, because I'm enjoying the jazz albums a lot more than I thought I would. I really liked this.
I don’t hate jazz but I can’t say I enjoyed this. Maybe technically marvelous to those who are interested but to a casual listener, I didn’t perceive much range in tone or emotion. It felt samey throughout.
I enjoyed it as a very very amateur listener of jazz
I have heard of Thelonious Monk before, but I could not have told you who or what that was before. Good to know now. It is average (to my ears) jazz music, OK for my morning commute to work.
Kjedelig dessverre (for noen som ikke er spess glad i jazz..)
A cornerstone record in any jazz collection.
Vibey
Wijs album. Ideale timing, want ik ben wat in m'n jazz-periode for some reason. 3.8
It was an easy listen, I was vibing throughout
This album turned out to be a pleasant surprise, especially considering it leans into the more avant-garde side of jazz. It’s a good example of how experimental jazz can still feel accessible and grounded. The instrumentation is strong throughout, but what really stood out to me was how Monk uses the piano as much for rhythm as he does for melody. Also, an interesting bit of backstory is that the title track was so complex it had to be pieced together from several takes. That really shows how intricate and demanding the composition is. Even though the album feels slightly off-center, it’s very intentional and well-crafted. This is definitely the type of jazz I’d like to explore more deeply moving forward.
It's jazz.
A spectacular album, by a stellar line-up of musicians.
So I don't really "get" jazz, in the sense that I find it harder to connect to than say rock or pop music. I guess that makes me unsophisticated, which I'm at peace with. Having said that, this was quite nice to have on in the background while working. It was different enough from what I would usually listen to to be interesting, but not so much that it was cacophonous or jarring. Some bits were foot-tap inducing, which is always a good thing in my opinion. I feel like extended drum solos are pretty cool and should catch on more outside jazz Final thought: This guy's actual birth name is Thelonius Sphere Monk? Come on! How cool is that. Destined for greatness
a hard bop composition whose title track was so complicated that the first quintet to record it had 25 takes, devolved into anger, and ultimately was created by the editor pulling together multiple takes. a super fun jazz album with heavy havana influence.
It’s Thelonious Monk and Sonny Rollins bouncing off eachother, what’s not to love? Some superb dark jazz throughout this album and a beautiful solo piece by Monk towards the end. It wasn’t one I had heard before but it’ll definitely be going into my rotation now.
Definitely a cool jazz record but Theolonious has not hit me the same as his other contemporaries of equal legend/myth. One day one of his songs/records will get me and I'll feel the vibe and understand the brilliance (no pun) but otherwise it's definitely just a nice jazz record.
pyöreyttä, ei brilliantteja kulmia.
Honestly a lovely jazzy time. Good vibes
Classic Monk off-kilter jazz with some pleasantly spicy instrumentation. at times I'd feel like the album is poking fun at me.
Excellent Perfect Beautiful
Jazz at its best.
Sorry but I just cant stand this. 2 stars because I am sure these are excellent musicians and this is exceedingly difficult and maybe groundbreaking. But I find it unlistenable noise
Brillant!
i like that I Surrender, Dear is more piano based and has very little background instruments. pretty good music for a jazz club. maybe not my jam but i can appreciated it!
An absolute horror to listen to; had a completely inhuman experience listening to this on Spotify. By the third track I had a hard time catching my breath
I was not expecting fully instrumental so soon, but this was nice to listen to. Not much more than that, for me. Sounds like a soundtrack to a coffeeshop though, which was enjoyable to have on in the background while doing other things.
Very Jazzy, but also not really my thing. Am I uncultured? Should I feel ashamed of myself? Maybe I should give this another go at an older age when i can appreciate the sophisticated things in life. I need to be in my own private reading room by the fireplace, wearing only my bathrob, and a glass of whiskey in my hand, as I immerse myself in the music while going through my weekly existential crisis. 2/5
Yeah I probably won't listen to it again. But, jazz
Very good- It almost made spreading mulch in 47 degree temps enjoyable
The title track was so difficult it had to be stitched together from multiple takes like jazz Frankenstein. Pleasant, intricate, and elusive — I enjoyed it twice, but nothing ever tapped me on the shoulder.
So damn good
Creative Bops
Challenging to the listener
This album ruined my morning. Really boring and made me want to go back to my warm bed.
Sounds like a billiards expert to me.
It's standard jazz. Good background music.
No one plays the piano like Thelonious Monk, and this band is stacked. A classic album, and Bemsha Swing is a tune for the ages.
I've said this before about jazz albums, but I find it difficult to review them. The ones on here are largely by jazz masters, so you know they're going to be good. You could probably swap out a lot of these albums with others from the same artists and not miss a beat. That's how good they were. Sure, some might be technically better than others (from a skills standpoint, I mean), and some might be more exciting or more expressive than others, or be in a sub genre of jazz you like more than others. But on the whole, they're all going to be good. Monk didn't produce bad stuff. Neither did Davis, Ellington, Coltrane, Basie, Rollins, Armstrong, etc. At least in my opinion. So this is an easy five stars. It's Monk, what do you want? Standout Tracks: Brilliant Corners, I Surrender, Dear
This one was a little weird. Not my fave when it comes to jazz. Sounded nothing like Monsters Inc.
Not a jazz guy but I didn’t mind this. Not something I’d listen to all the time but might be good for background music.
i enjoy jazz music :)
It was ok. I think I prefer jazz from a little bit later
Too jazzy
That opening track starts a little too jazz for me. But the rest of this was super fun. I may buy this on vinyl if I come across it.
musically interesting, at least it has an amount of complexity but ultimately fails to appeal in any other way then remaining novel.
Good jazz. Stand-out: Bemsha Swing
Not a fan of this subgenre of jazz. It’s like listening to a hangover.
Jazz! Not much for me to add here Best Song: Brilliant Corners Rating: 6/10 Adequate Stars: 3/10
High quality noodling
I could cry this is perfect
I'm glad jazz is for someone, but it's not for me. This album just made me anxious.
Brilliant Corners 3.8 Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are 3.7 Pannonica 3.4 I Surrender, Dear 3.3 Bemsha Swing 3.5 Score: 3.54
A delight.
It's good, but at times it sounds like they're trying to be different for the sake of being different. Favorite song: Ba-lue Bolivar Ba-lues-are
I can’t say I can distinguish great jazz from ok jazz, but I do feel classy listening to it.
Getting hit with some jazz records early in this challenge. Enjoyable background music, but I struggle to stay focused on record, and feels more like the type of thing that would be so much more powerful and engaging live. This is just me, struggling to connect with jazz as a genre. Great name though!
Adventures in listening.
I really enjoyed this album
It’s undeniably good. But you need to be in the mood.
Before I got this album I thought Thelonious Monk was the name of a 70s prog band. I was pleasantly surprised to be wrong, because this was much better than more 70s prog.
Too jazzy? A little too jazzy. Couldn’t get into this one.
Love this guy.
Miellyttävää. Mutta vain jazzia.
Kuulin viimeisessä kappaleessa toistoa ja kiinnostuin hetkeksi. Eikö toisto olekin puhtaan eron välttämätön ehto?
Thelonious Monk is held in such high regard amongst jazz players, that its feels wrong to say anything less than praising him for his contributions. Sadly, I just wasn't impressed. Not that I disliked it, but there's nothing about it that truly stands out.
I liked it. I really wanted to love it though Too much of it faded on me
Very much enjoyed.
Cool but the songs are kind of long
Super smooth jazzy grooves.
Nice - blends into the background if you want, but if you pay attention there's all sorts of weird stuff going on! Fave tracks - hmmm, sections of "Ba-Lue Bolivar Ba-Lues-Are" were great. "I Surrender, Dear" was very chill, too. This is more of a whole album deal, though...
Love thelonious, there a lot of quotes in here or maybe a lot of melodies quote this album idk. overall awesome
Nice jazzy record
Damn cool, this one.
It was nice, for jazz
Tough to review someone so far beyond anything I can fully understand in terms of talent. Clearly a masterful performance. Great listen and makes total sense to be on the list. Reading about all the other players getting frustrated playing the title track due to the complexity is funny.
I've heard the name forever, but not the music. What can you say for something like this? It just puts me in a trance. Occupies my mind. Yeah.
Great bop album by Monk. Like all of his records this has this slightly weird, hard-hitting piano playing. Good stuff!
Quirky "little" jazz album with quite a lot of good sounds. Not my favorite from the Monk, but still an essential in his discography.
Enjoyable hard bop record for sure, but I can't say it's a standout of the genre to me. It sounds like a bridge between easy listening jazz and more hard hitting stuff.
Monk’s style can be a bit polarizing, compared to more fluid or melodic jazz pianists like Bill Evans or Dave Brubeck. The rhythmic unpredictability gives it a uniqueness for sure.
Amazing
Good background music
Pleasant
Nice vibes for a fall morning
Go off, Max Roach. Loved “Pannonia,” also “I Surrender Dear” with just Monk on piano…lovely
I don’t know jazz well enough to be able to tell if this is any good or not. Therefore I can only really judge it in whether I liked it or lot. And I didn’t.
Jazz, or endless, self-indulgent, boring, obnoxious, noodling as I like to call it.
So, it turns out that Arsenal (23/24), West Brom (16/17) and Oldham (92/93) all scored 16 goals from brilliant corners in a season. A joint Premier League record. Which is just slightly more interesting to hear than this album.
Better jazz than most, it's fatal flaw is that it's jazz
While Monk has never been my favorite jazz pianist, this was a solid album with some fantastic horn work from Rollins
Get jazz album. Listen to it multiple times
Are we going to get a decent jazz album at any point