Reviews (page 10 of 12)
Not really a jazz dude, but as a musician I can appreciate the God-tier musicianship of those involved in making this record. This showcases Ellington's prowess as a band leader moreso than a pianist, which is fine, but overall, it was much more difficult to appreciate than a studio album given the sound quality. The horns were blaring and the drums front and center, but the piano was all but lost most of the time (assuming there was piano at all?). Overall not bad, but not something I'd actively seek out to listen to again.
Fun album to listen to. So much going on that everyone you listen pick up something new.
I really enjoyed this more than I thought I would. It reminded me of music my grandpa would listen to in the car and, at the time, I didn’t appreciate it but now I think about what it must have been like to listen to it in a cool club when he was younger. There were moments I was cleaning and it gave me a little upbeat soundtrack without being my typical pop/hip hop/R&B or rock. Other times it was slow and created a cool vibe to chill to and I could imagine slow dancing to it with my husband at the same time. Glad this was early in the rotation!
Great stuff. My only complaint, and this sounds silly, but I find that jazz with trumpet as the lead can be a little too shrill sometimes. Otherwise, this is a fantastic listen.
I liked the piano and brushed drums, but a lot of the trumpet just wasn't for me. Perhaps if I hung out jazz bars in the 50s....
Trad Jazz just ain't my bag baby
I see a live jazz album from the 50s, I rate 5 stars.
‘Skin deep’ is F I R E.
👍 I can listen to this while working
Intellectually, I understand it jazz and it's complexities. I just don't like to listen to it that often.
Remarkable how many people feel the urge to detail their relationship with Jazz in the reviews. So... Me? I'm not a stranger to it, but (or therefore?) I can't say that I'm a great connoisseur of jazz', say, pre 60ies years. Unless it's ~smooth~ but then it becomes music for dinner parties. This here is cool, however, but solely because of the energy that's conveyed through the live recording, which also cuts it into slices that makes it unwieldy and too long. It's wild and again: cool, but - in 2024 - this album doesn't hold my attention or interest enough to grant these 2 hours more than a 3.
The band sounds so crisp, sharp and sexy. So full of life, big band music at it's best
Enigmatic, and fun
Going back in time with the Duke! A very good live album.
A fun one to listen to. I like all the introductions and reactions from the crowd. Feels like a big party
Nothing for me here. I don't mind some plinky piano nonsense, or even twangy guitar nonsense. But I didn't sign up for any squealing trumpet nonsense.
Brilliant.
Wow! Awesome.
The music's good but not to my taste. But it's not really a live album if Wikipedia's comment that only about 40% is actually live recording is true (how do they measure that?).
the quickest way to harlem
A big jazz band like this seemed anachronistic among the birth pangs of rock n roll, but Duke Ellington and his ensemble ably prove why they’re one of the best. Even if some of these performances technically aren’t live, they’re impressive nonetheless.
It’s fine, not my cup of tea, the musicianship is very impressive, but the live atmosphere kills it for me
Great
S really good and relaxing album. Was great listening to it on the way to and home from both work and the gym. My favourite song on the album was Pt. 1 Festival Junction.
I enjoyed listening to this, but I don't think it's something I would ever return to. Glad to have listened to it. Makes me feel like I earned my fandom of Whiplash that much more.
A deep, long listen. Lots of interrupting vocal announcers, and I didn't find I could lose myself in it as much as I could with cello or piano or irish music.
4.4
neat music and i respect the talent but its not something that i would find myself listening to
LOVE IT!!
Amazingly cool live jazz
wow niche. a good listen though
I'm not big on jazz but this is the best one I've come across on this list.
Love that it's actually a few different concerts pieced together with a lot of surrounding lore and circumstance career wise for Duke. One of the best sax solos I've ever heard and the sounds from Duke and those on and off the stage help add to the live feeling of the album. Really stellar Jazz and a riot to boot. Wonder what it was like to live back then
I'm. ot a huge fan of patriotic songs, so that first one doesn't do much for me. The remainder of this album was clearly innovative and felt like the kind of thing I might have listened to with my grandfather on the porch sipping sweet tea on a summer afternoon. Really enjoyable.
Duke Ellington’s “Ellington at Newport” is one of the oldest albums on a list that for the most part begins with the dawn of rock and roll. It is both a time capsule of the pre-rock era of music, and also apparently a revitalization of Ellington’s career, which began long before anything on the list. The list has to have its limits, but it's right that some of that big band and jazz music must be listened to before you die, and Ellington’s band seems as good a representation as any. Ellington is great as a pianist and band leader, but it’s the horns that really stand out from the performance. Great stuff. Great musicians. Great band. Great band leader.
Absolutely electrifying!!
The guys are outstanding musicians, but I need more structure and less meandering.
I have tried multiple times to get through this. After about 30 minutes it all blends together. You know when you are reading a book but not paying attention and realize three pages later you have no idea what's going on? Audio version of that. Lovely music, great musicians, too damn long.
Ok
Да, круто! Мне так нравятся записанные живые выступления! Как будто ты и сам находишься там, где музыканты вытсупают. И звучание крутое. Но, опять-таки, я ничего не запомню из этого альбома.
Riktigt bra musikaliskt och många riktigt sköna låtar. Nu är kanske inte denna typen av jazz riktigt exakt vad jag älskar just nu men kommer förmodligen komma tillbaka till några av dessa låtar.
Gillar inte den här typen av jazz. Dessutom som tråkig liveplatta.
Mastering and mix is pretty terrible, unfortunately.
Well I didn't hate it and for anything in this genre, that's a really big compliment for me to pay. I guess I'd be happy for it to play as background music at some gathering. I could hear it at a coffee shop and not put on headphones to drown it out. Yay Duke.
I like jazz. Sometimes more than others. This is classic, like the jazz my mother listened to in the 1950's at smoky Chicago clubs while smoking cigarettes and drinking gin. Ellington is a master of brass and the entire band grooves like cool cats of days gone by. It is simultaneously awesome for this world and not for me.
The Duke is great. An all time classic. But not really one I’m gonna go back to for more than just background music.
Para muchos críticos y aficionados al jazz la aparición de Duke Ellington y su orquesta en Newport en 1956 es una de las mejores interpretaciones de la historia y supuso el regreso de Ellington a la cima de la fama. Destacó sobre manera el solo de tenor al saxofón de Paul Gonsalves en "Diminuendo in Blue". No obstante, la grabación que nos ha llegado no es la grabación en directo sino una mezcla en la que se incluyen fragmentos de la reconstrucción en estudio que realizó la banda al día siguiente. El famoso "Diminuendo" se había grabado en un micrófono equivocado y la única forma de arreglar aquel desaguisado era reinterpretando toda la "Suite del Festival", introduciendo falsos aplausos, introducciones y ruidos del público. Aún así, sigue siendo una grabación extraordinaria.
I can handle jazz, but this was a lot of jazz. Still, good album, good listening.
Pretty decent jazz, with some fun announcing and crowd-noise bits. Love hearing a jazz festival riot, just sounds so silly to me. 6/10
Look…I don’t mind jazz, but I also don’t love it. I also don’t typically like live albums. So what do I do with this? 2.5
A great album, but I’m going to be picky and give it a 4 because even though this is definitely my favourite era of jazz, I do prefer it with lyrics, it just wasn’t quite Louis Armstrong enough
I wouldn’t consider myself a jazz fanatic, and this album didn't seem too different from any of the other stuff i'd heard before. At first I thought "okay just your regular jazz-elevator music"- but by track five "tea for two" I was starting to get the hype. An album to make anything you do feel aesthetic- in my case lying in bed at 3pm on a wednesday- but I felt like I was transported into a scene of Pink Panther or Tom and Jerry. Personally, I will never opt for a live version over a studio recording but in this case, the atmosphere of the audience made the experience all the more electric- I really envied the audience. Overall, despite its length I really enjoyed this piece, although I think more intended to be listened to while doing something other than fantasising about being in whiplash- which I defs did NOT do. favourites: "Tea for Two", Jeeps Blues" skips: The introductions and announcements
Not hater of jazz, but definitely not my thing. And also, live record ...
I’m a big fan of Duke Ellington!
Ik pak even het origineel van 44 minuten ipv de complete versie van 130 minuten. Deze laatste zou ik niet trekken en dan werd het gegarandeerd een 1. Iedereen die hier aan meewerkt is een virtuoos, dat staat buiten kijf. Als live-optreden was het waarschijnlijk een indrukwekkende ervaring. Dat de opname een liveregistratie is maakt het voor mij alleen niet per se beter nu. Het op dit album vaak toch wat drukke, schelle gekwetter van alles wat van koper is, wordt door de live opname nog net wat snerpender en daardoor minder prettig om te luisteren. Het joelende en fluitende publiek voegt voor mij niks toe behalve ergernis. Het is zo druk aan je hoofd allemaal. Vooral bij "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue Pt. 2" gaat het voor mij helemaal mis, als een eigenlijk heerlijke solo wordt bedolven onder de herrie van een hondsdol publiek. Ik moet ook deze weer op luisterplezier beoordelen en dan kom ik wéér niet hoger dan 2 sterren. Wel knap, niet leuk.
2 plus hours of jazz is far too much. Especially in audio only formats. Seeing this live would be something else and probably far more enjoyable. I don't really know what to say here... The live aspect is fine.. But the drawn out introduction to songs makes this album feel even longer than they are. Top musicianship going on. Unfortunately, it's just boring listening to it. First few songs, I was engaged... But 2 hours of this was very tedious. Took me 2 sit throughs to get through this as I was bored 20 minutes into each listen, and had to force my attention.
I usually don't like live albums, but this is an exception because of its age and because the commentaries between songs provide useful information and context. I usually don't like jazz albums because they tend to be long and meandering. This is certainly long, but it manages to avoid feeling meandering.
Fabulous!!
This is some good big band jazz. There are some particularly strong tunes on here, including Festival Junction and Jeep's Blues. I would have preferred to listen to the original release's track list, as the version I am listening to seems to be an expanded version so it's a bit long for me at over 2 hours and includes some repeats, but I can't hold that against the original album. This is a solid listen, but maybe not one that I would come back to very often.
A great performance by a great band.
Duke Ellington beat Apoleon at the Attle of Aterloo.
squee! squeeze! I SAID SQUEEEE
Too much “jazz”
Wow. So that’s what pandemonium at the jazz-house sounds like. Iconic and timeless (though I loved the MC mentioning that a very young producer named ‘Quincy Jones’ had lectured earlier in the day of this concert).
An Amazing Jazz album in the Big Band era , personally I prefer Quartet jazz musicians, hard bop and modal jazz...
This is a historical Jazz album. I listened to the (complete) 2-hour and 7-minute version on Spotify, and it definitely does not fill that long. I loved that Duke is introduced by the Jazz Priest, Father Norman O'Connor, on track 2. The Jazz Priest comes back later because there are some conversations and introductions recorded. It helps imagine (a little) how it would be to be there.
Some of the most talented musicians. This album works for me as background music, but sometimes too lively to concentrate.
Very nice.
Listened up to where the original show ended (Mood Indigo, so longer than the first release but not the full 2 hour 1999 release either) and have to say it was incredible. For others unversed in jazz i can fully recommend this as an undeniably perfect intro
I enjoyed this album. I am a fan of jazz so probably ginna be a bit biased in my review. Tbh there were only a few moments that really caught my attention. This was probably very imaginative for it's time. I'll probably have to listen again to get an actual opinion on it.
A little long, but great!
A 2 hour live album??? Come on guys we're all busy people
Classic sound. A lot of talking on this recording. 1956, and live, so I suppose it's authentic. But great music.
Diverse, superb playing.
💜
Strong. Classic Ellington
Best song - I Got It Bad (And That Ain't Good
Pretty good live.
I thought I would enjoy it. I did not. I couldn’t even listen to all of it because 2 hours of that is way too much
Sounds great live and some really good players in the band. I listened to the complete version so it did run a bit long and started to blend together. The announcements were a bit obnoxious too (3.5/5)
This is a very long album . The musicians are extremely skilled and I can appreciate this but how much jazz can one person take ? And is that a kazoo?
Been wanting to listen to this one. Good old school jazz.
Yup. It's jazz. This is game show music. My head hurts.
I've been putting off listening to this because it's so long. I had to come back to it a few times but it is impressive, just not for me.
That's Sir Duke to you!
Holy hell was this a long ass album. lol First time listening to a Jazz album and i’m thoroughly impressed. would’ve been so cool to see this live. great stuff.
Pass, will listen on CD at some point
Great jazz band, no lyrics & easy listening
Classic big band. Probably one of the best in this genre. Great music.
classic jazz orchestra big band
some great things happened in Newport
Schöner Jazz. Einzigartig arrangiert. Eben Duke.
Spectacular live jazz album. Ellington and his band at their best. Makes me miss playing in my high school jazz band. I thought it was an odd choice to include the ramblings of the emcee. It really didn’t add much of anything to the show past his introductions at the beginning. But none of that could really hamper the fact that this is a lively, inspired performance of some absolute classic jazz songs. I didn’t listen past the actual live album, as the studio concert wasn’t part of the original live show and feels like cheating on the part of Duke and the band. Excellent stuff. 5 stars, with the caveat that it’s a little confusing unless you read the Wiki article and know what the deal was with this one. Standout tracks: Black and Tan Fantasy, Tea for Two, Take the A Train, Pt. III-Newport Up, Sophisticated Lady, Diminuendo in Blue, Jeep’s Blues, Skin Deep
Good background music
Great jazz album
I love Duke and this was a solid listen… but I don’t know the necessary to listen to if you listen to other Duke?
Reminds me of my Grandpa
Not bad, enjoyed more than i thought i would
Wow what a treat someone gave us when successfully recording and mastering this recording from 1956! A chance to hear Duke and his band live from the early days of the Newport jazz festival is priceless. Enjoyed tremendously.
Pretty good jazz album, the horns are espescially delicious, and the drumming is insane. The full concert version is a fun if long listen, but the original LP is almost the perfect length and captures the concert pretty well when forced to condense into 40 minutes
Good to go somewhere different
I'm not a fan of live albums, but this one is still solid. It sounds like it would have been a blast to have been there. Duke and the orchestra are absolute monsters! Favorite tracks: - Black and Tan Fantasy - Tea for Two - Take the "A" Train - Festival Suite (Festival Junction, Blues to Be There, Newport Up) - Sophisticated Lady - Day In, Day Out - Diminuendo In Blue - I Got It Bad (And That Ain't Good) - Jeep's Blues - Tulip or Turnip - Skin Deep - Mood Indigo So, all of them. All killer, no filler!
Superb!
Sir Duke
So good. Love the love intros and sense of the feel of the show. Killer freestyles.
Awesome album!
A trio of pain. Jazz, live albums and it being stupidly long. 2 hours of suffering. At first I hated the host listing names and informing late audience members of what they had missed. Surely you would cut that shit out? Then the screeching never ending noises started and I would have much rather listened to him list the name of every audience member present. Maybe the worst album I have ever listened to. No redeeming qualities.
Jazz album. I don’t really know enough to tell the amazing from non It’s live but I’m not a fan of the speeches in the middle In terms of music like I’d be happy to have this play at some cafe I was in, but I wouldn’t Shazam it. I guess that should make it 2/3***. I’ll give it 2 because I’m not scared of being told I’m uncultured by the pointy heads
There's some really enjoyable songs in here, but it's a lot of Jazz in one go and I found myself drifting in and out of it. "Blues to be there" I really liked.
Gave it 1 track, then ran the fuck away
Cool jazz album. Didn’t move me but enjoyed listening to it.
I've been on a roll recently, this is the third very good (4/5) album I've had in a row, after a period of mediocrity. I headed out on a chilly early-spring walk in Montreal with earphones in and a 2 hour Ellington record queued up to spin. And was I in for a treat! Such class, such elegance, such musicianship. What a time it would have been in 1956 to be part of this audience. Something struck me in particular about Diminuendo In Blue; this was the clincher for me not long after my first coffee of the walk that guaranteed a quality review. I really want there to be more Ellington records along the road to 1001.
# Playlist track - Take the "A" train # Notes - I'm into jazz, and also into jazz performances, but I couldn't get to the end of this one, despite trying twice. - There are so many introductions, and announcements, and clapping and talking. - Albums stretches for over 2 hours, but you can never get in the zone, because you're going to be interrupted by people taking.
Gorgeous, impeccable, I will never listen to the full album again because it is too damn long
This is how you do a live album! A bit too long, though.
I might like this album, if it wasn't 2 hours long and had less screeching trumpet in it.
Appreciate the skill and musicianship, but doesn't move me much.
Performed wonderfully but I probably won't go back, too big band for me, and too many introductions. Really rips sometimes though.
tea for two, pt III
to answer Barry b Bensons question. No.
a good time
One of the better jazz albums on this lost, in my opinion. I think this is the entrance level jazz music, that a novice in the genre (me) should have listened to first, before jumping at Thelonius Monk and Miles Davis. Every song on this record is really amazing, everything works together really well, every instrument has its place and time to shine, but it's not overly complicated, or it's not trying to invent something new. Great album, this is where my jazz journey will start (if it will take off at all).
Live jazz album dans un festival en 1956. C'est vraiment loin d'être mauvais, mais je suis aussi vraiment loin de connaître assez ma musique pour savoir que c'est le meilleur album jazz de tous les temps. S'écoute super bien quand même, mais dur d'avoir des chansons prefs quand tu dois choisir sur 38 pistes de 2heures de long.
I’m not a fan of live albums, but this one was good until the last song. Drum solos are better in person.
I had a hard time listening to this. Not because of the music but because I kept getting interrupted and had to keep pausing it to deal with life. The musicianship on display was amazing, but I wasn't a fan of all the introductions sprinkled throughout.
Enjoyable once I started skipping thru the intros.
Disco de jazz gravado ao vivo
It's great. Ellington is a beast of a player and, on this recording, he's surrounded with an entire menagerie of jazz beasts. It's a master class in this era of jazz. It's just not my jam. It's dated and comes off, more often than I'd like, as kinda cheesy. And, while that's admittedly a "me" problem, not a "him" problem, I still can' bring myself to give it full marks.
Decent, just super long
Even though I’m not that into jazz, I know enough to know Duke Ellington is a, if not the, premier name in the genre. This was a relaxing listen for a Friday work afternoon, I committed to the full 2 hour experience. I could picture cool cats like Cab Calloway wearing black suits and dark shades just jamming away. I can tell this is a selection of top notch players, and the pace is very measured and the set is arranged well. I like the commentary, adding context for the listener that may not be as familiar with the genre. 3.5/5 rounded down
I love what Sir Duke represents in music but I don't think this is what we here are calling an album.
Þetta fellur undir liðinn "læv albúm sem ég fíla ekki".
Its tough for me to rate a jazz album as I don't listen to a lot of it. This was enjoyable, but not to the point where I felt it was vastly different from other albums I've listened to.
Just a solid big band jazz set. I’ve got no complaints, but I wasn’t wowed either.
hot damn these cats are cookin! love the sax in diminuendo in blue
Jazz is the only genre I truly enjoy live most of the time. Sadly this was not the case with this album as a whole. The music for the most part was fantastic, but the amount of talking at times, especially not from Duke was annoying AF. It's the only reason this gets a 4.
Classic big band music. The intro voice introduction was a nice touch to bring the listener into a mindset of a live performance.
I listened to the original, not the remake that's quadruple the length. It's talent and big band.
Over 2 hours? Really? Could have cut half of this including the pointless tracks introducing the songs and telling the crowd that a white Ford Transit van is blocking the exit.
Enjoyable but I feel like the crowd interactions could've been cut and I just don't have this much love for jazz in me.
4.3 - Really enjoyed this, feel like I could listen to it for ages
Not really for me, I don't love jazz but could see why jazz heads would enjoy it. He should defs ditch the first track though.
So far live albums have been a major source of disappointment for me on this list. This is better - jazz gets a lot more from a live performance than rock imo. Still my favourite track here is probably Take the A Train - always a bop. Fave Tracks: Take the A Train 3.2/5
I want my jazz albums live I think
It took a bit to gather momentum but I loved the last few tracks. Saxes and clarinets aren't my *thing* so that's saying a lot.
This made me feel like my atoms were out of position
This was pretty nice music to study to. It was interesting and not what I’d normally listen to at all. It definitely stands up to the test of time.
not today, no
First two songs felt really interminable but the rest was better Update: except the squealing at the end
Ohh
I guess that the jazz albums in this list are those from the '100 best albums of jazz' lists. It is a great album, and the vaunted solos on Dimuendo and Crescendo are superb. But the jazz albums here are a bit random - why not for example have Jacqueline Du Pre's recording of Elgar's Cello Concerto? Anyway, four stars.
Long album, and not one I'd revisit
Sorry, but I'm never going to like Jazz.
Full of energy and the band kills it, but goddamn 2 hours of it is a lot
Much babbity. Not my favourite jazz at all but 2 seems a bit harsh
Brought me back to sitting at my grandparents, and my grandpa listening to his albums in the living room.
Perfect for a relaxing, lazy Sunday vibe.
Did not like it.
I mean some of it was alright but so many decent tracks were ruined by horrible screeching squeals during the last 30-45 seconds wtf is that
Listening to this album is like going in a time capsule back to the year 1956. This is an incredible live album with amazing sounds which has transcended time. The talking points, solos, audience participation, the two recording sessions and painstakingly meticulous craftmanship in this album are just phenomenal. You don't have to be enamored with jazz to recognize how great this album is.
Duke Ellington is simply one of the greatest musicians to ever live
There's great playing on this album, it sounds like an incredible show! The sound quality lets it down a bit though. Still a pretty great introduction to Duke Ellington for me though. I'll definitely be checking out more of his recordings.
Beautiful and elegant.
some of the best musicians in the world at the time all in one band. Big good listening experience 11/10
Didn't get to listen to every track, but I loved hearing this live performance. it's not just good music—it's a piece of history that we get to experience some 60 years later. So cool, and such a joy to listen to.
Wel Chill, die hele hoge trompet geen fan
Wel nice, beetje piep jan knor jazz dus je mot er wel zin in hebben
It's good that they switched up the upbeat tracks with the slower ones. I really enjoyed the upbeat ones.
Trad jazz album
Not really into the big band sound, despite the high perceived quality of this record
talented for sure but i don't think i need a 2 hour long listen
Classic big band jazz
Enjoyed. The live element was interesting but made for bad distracting focus music
litt langt album men var chill å høre på
Great players. I would've preferred the original version. Duke is an all timer for a reason.
Großartiges Jazz-Album
It's kind of surprising that after over 130 albums, this is only the second 50s album I've gotten. I guess it really shouldn't be that surprising since the album era didn't really kick in until the 60s, but that's still kind of crazy. Anyways, this one's really good. I'd go so far as to easily call it the best live album I've listened to for this project so far, even if the original version, the one I listened to, isn't entirely live. This is an instrumental album, and a great one at that. One thing I really like about this album that I didn't expect from older music like this is that the tone in each song is pretty different. Sure, it's all the same instruments and such, but each song on this album has a different feel than the one that came before it, which is super respectable. The sound is quite good. There's some nice solos in there, with the one from "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue" obviously being the highlight. Perhaps the full version is an even better experience, aside from the sheer length. I don't know if I feel like doing that, but it wouldn't be worst idea for music to listen to. Overall, this is a very impressive album for 1956 and a solid collection of instrumental jazz. Light 4/5.
It's fine. It's not really my thing. The recording is good. Washes over me a bit.
Banger
PHENOMENAL! DUKE AND HIS ORCHESTRA AT THEIR BEST!
I’m not the biggest fan of live albums, but this was cool. The performances are amazing here and carry this thing on its shoulders. The calm and vintage feel to this is amazing too. Perfect for what I need in the morning. Cool album!
Great jazz album good energy
From the concert that revived the career of Duke Ellington. There are a couple different variations of this album. The classic version is actually live mixed with studio, but you can find the "all-live" release also. "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue" is the clear standout, but the entire album is a great example of "live" swing.
Good easy listening album, wish it did not have all the speaking sections. I do like live performances though. Perfect for a small bar and enjoying a cocktail. Favorite track is Jeep's Blues.
its long, its jazz but its nothing too entrancing, the liveness of it all is fun but i think it leans too far into it really. I can appreciate the art, but its not for me.
Fun listen, just dated
Loved the whole thing. Listening to the drum solo in “Skin Deep” I thought I was going crazy hearing a double bass drum which I didn’t think had been popularized yet. Turns out this drummer, Louie Bellson, is one of the double bass pioneers from the late 50s. He was metal before metal was a thing.
Meh. Its the Duke but still meh.
No pude escucharlo
Good jazz album, some yapping
Smooth :)
It’s a long album didn’t get through it in its entirety but I love the inclusion of the MC and all the intros. Pulled me into the specific time/place/performance. Not my usual fare but i listened driving through the city and it just put me in a really nice headspace.
Jazz is not my cuppa.
I don’t listen to much jazz, and I found this to be pretty good. Still not my favorite genre but it definitely has its place.
Even if big band isn’t your first language, this record shows all the strengths of Ellington’s band: the mix of hot and sweet, the grand-scale compositions, threaded thru with intimate moments, the integrated soloing by players set up to succeed, the sheer swinging romance of the entire endeavor. Take the yearning of Hodges’ solo on “I Got it Bad” (not on original). And of course there’s the Gonsalves solo heard ‘round the world, one of the great all-time moments in jazz, and one of the best solos ever recorded, in any genre, at any time.
It isn't my taste in music. This doesn't mean it's bad.
Jazz at its best. I had almost forgotten how much I liked jazz. Thanks for reminding!
4-5
Rather torn on this one. On the one hand, the music itself is phenomenal. The playing is top-tier and can't be faulted. But, there are two major issues: 1 - Live albums are so rarely good. This isn't an exception. 2 - It's very long. Maintaining active focus on an album for over two hours is one hell of a challenge when it's not the main task of your day.
There is a bit of irony to the random album selections at times on this list, and for me the irony today is that yesterday I dumped on the Hüsker Dü album for being too long and then today I’m given an album where the billed “complete” version is over two hours. I considered going for the original release but opted for the complete version instead. Figured I’d give it a go and if it was dragging I would flip over to the shorter version. Holy shit that wasn’t an issue at all. I was fully sucked in immediately. I bought like 2 pounds of shrimp for dinner and realized they weren’t deveined, so me and my novice knife skills had plenty of time to kill to let it all play out. At first I was just kind of vibing, it was a good performance by the backing band and I enjoyed the vamping of the emcee as the band was constantly shuffling around to prep between songs, but by the time Festival Junction starts hitting its peak I was barely paying attention to my work at hand. Chills down my spine. Incredible. They were locked in on this particular evening, and once the band hits that peak they just rip the rest of the way through. By the time Diminuendo In Blue is hitting those loud trumpet stings at the end overloading mics into the red, I was convinced this isn’t just a new favorite of mine from a genre I barely know, it may be among the finest live albums I’ve ever heard. I should also mention the crowd on this album. I have a vision in my head of a Jazz crowd being on the more silent and contemplative side, and I feel the beginning of this record had their reactions pretty in line with what I would expect. What I loved is they started getting more and more rowdy, I would assume in part due to the historical excellence occurring on stage in front of them. Reading up about it I see what I couldn’t on the album: The crowd was worked into a full blown frenzy due to dancing in the aisles escalating to what I imagine would be the closest thing to a mosh pit the 50’s had to offer. That energy fed the band who kept ramping it up harder and harder. Eventually, they tried to call it a night, and the crowd goes BALLISTIC, threatening to turn violent if they don’t hear more Jazz. So they get it. The show goes a bit longer than intended and ends with an incredible performance of Mood Indigo. I normally pick my top tracks, and I suppose I’ve stated them above, but truthfully this is a performance best experienced as a whole. The build to chaos is amazing to behold and the energy is unrivaled. What a pleasure to listen to. Once the original performance ended I was delighted to hear additional performances and some studio renditions were also on the album. What a shift, from yesterday feeling like I couldn’t pay attention for over an hour to today wishing there were more than 2 hours of music to enjoy.
Transcendent, truly great
Really enjoyed it. I've been trying to get into more jazz over the past couple of years, and I've learned there's a whole lot out there, even when you just consider some of the classic artists. Everything from compilations to live albums...stuff that was a once-in-a-lifetime event. I got the impression that this recording really captured something special in Ellington's career.
Nice "easy" listening. It is some what frenetic music, but I think that is the appeal. This is jazz during the 1950s after all ...
Tolle Musiker, nicht meins.
Ellington's revival at Newport launched his career forward. His performance, particularly on "Diminuendo in Blue", excited the crowd to stand up and dance as Paul Gonsalves kept going forever on his sax, followed by a crazy improvisational piano solo by Ellington. It's the highlight of this album, and showcases the impact jazz can have on audiences. Much of the album is filler. There are plenty of showcases of the orchestra's capabilities and improvisations, which makes it better than most live jazz albums, especially for its time. There is a sense of liveliness and space, and various members get their time to shine. But I wasn't able to find a track that blew me away as much as "Diminuendo in Blue". It was a mix of "pretty great" and "forgettable". And I'm not even including the outtakes after the closer "Mood Indigo."
2 hour live jazz, that is not even that good, why would anyone want to listen to that
I rather enjoyed this as a historical document. However, no particular tracks stood out, though I did appreciate the arrangements and musicianship. Perhaps not my favourite jazz form, predating the 'Kind of Blue' era, but still an interesting listen which reminded me of my late grandfather's record collection.
It’s a long way to the top if you wanna…play jazz. But this album is a great example of what many artists can’t do: perform live! The commentary in between was interesting and made you feel like you were there. And the players were top notch. Like cool, daddio!
I navigated to the original LP which was a much more manageable 40 min compared to the 2+ hour version Spotify linked to. This album cooks, no doubt about it. Makes me wish I was in the audience, taking down martinis and talking about the Eisenhower administration. Truly remarkable display of musical talent on this. Player after player just letting it rip.
This album has two things working against it that would typically doom it for me: 1) Jazz 2) Live recording But to my surprise, the live aspect really elevated the album. Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue Is a perfect example where the band is feeding off the audience and the audience is loving it. Doesn’t take it to 4* category, but ended up enjoying more than I expected. 3.25/5
needs to be remastered, sound is not good
Legend. Very long. 4.
Jazz double albums are very long. I'm not generally a fan of live recordings, but this was a great example of one. Sax solos were epic.
Album 308 of 1001 Duke Ellington - Ellington at Newport Rating : 5 / 5 Back to the basics. I love the horns and Duke does it as well as any. What awesome sounds this album gives us. Paul Gonsalves's tenor saxophone solo on 'Diminuendo In Blue', alone, is well worth the ticket price. Put this one on, sit back, chill out in whatever manner you see fit. You can't miss with this one.
What a crazy crowd! Pretty sure this was in my dad's CD collection on heavy rotation.
Technically extremely impressive, but overall this style of jazz doesn't really do it for me.
Jazz gonna jazz.
As a person who has never listened or been exposed to any jazz, this was a pleasant surprise for me. Although not the most entertaining album to listen to, it is incredible in terms of musicality, with countless impressive solos and strange synchronization with the instruments to keep you on your toes. it was fun to admire the skill of these musicians, and I now have a newfound appreciation for jazz.
The level of the musicianship is mind blowing. The music puts me into a sort of trance I enjoyed this album
Too Big Band for me.
In terms of pacing, Ellington at Newport captures the ferocity of a live show in it's purest essence. A well laid out LP shows masters at work and highlights the thunderous moments that eventually revitalized Ellington's career. The suite of new songs on the A Side is fun a playful, meant to elicit reaction and awe from the Newport crowd. Even if historically the performances slightly underwhelmed the crowd, they're still wonder numbers and serve as the palette for which the rest of the performance would be judged by. Side B is a different sort of animal altogether, bringing two stomping 1930's pieces back into the (when it was recorded) current scope. "Jeep's Blues" is a perfectly suitable number that will be overshadowed by the next track. And what a shadow that is. The live recording of "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue" showcases a raucous saxophone solo that sends the audience into an uproar. Being a live recording, we can really feel the energy of this performance from the audience gasps to the encouraging shouts of Duke and other band members encouraging Paul Gonsalves through the solo.
Totally fine. I'm not a live album person and the recording sounded awful, which really hurts my experience, maybe unfairly.
I know this is a CLASSIC recording. An IMPORTANT recording. Usually I'm all over jazz. This was good for me. I think I'll have to give it another listen - or 3!
After looking at the Wikipedia article for some context, I was able to appreciate this a little better. I listened only to the "restored" live set (digitally combining the original live recording along with a radio broadcast recording) through to Mood Indigo with all the introductory banter between the songs. Listening to it as a whole I liked how it might take me back to the location it was recorded in, and the stereo imaging with the combination of the 2 recordings was remarkable, but certain times I could hear some weird phasing effect occasionally in trying to create a stereo image from the recordings. Having The Atomic Mr. Basie as a comparison (mono recording only) I think I like Duke's arrangements better - they have a grander sound and slickness to them, compared to a more jumpy, raw energy with the Count Basie album. Diminuendo in Blue is clearly the standout of the album with the Gonsalves solo, but I enjoyed Newport Up as well.
Mastery on display. These are top notch musicians doing a live show for a very lucky audience. The quality of the recordings aren’t the best, but in this case it creates more of a longing; not a longing to better recordings, but a longing to be in the same exact setting as the band goes through these numbers. I almost enjoyed listening to how hype the crowd was getting as the show went on as much I enjoyed the masterclass of musicians just enjoying the crap out of some jazz. I am not sure I would listen to this album a lot though, as it is one of those experiences that are great the first time, but maybe not as much with consecutive listens. 3/5
Okay. Not my thing.
Groovy. Not sure qhat else to say for instrumentals. Really loved the live recording with the announcer and audience, very charming.
Big-variety jazz. Super long album, didn't have time to finish it
Excellent - a portal to another time
1956 -working on my electric train in the basement in winter. Dad comes home around noon on a Saturday and works on something in another part of the basement. He turns on the radio and the tubes warm up...we listen to the Mal Bellairs show on WBBM in Chicago with this kind of music. Mmmm, memories of a wonderful time and feeling the love.
Firstly, a shout out to the algorithm for setting all the long albums for the weekend. Secondly, this is fantastic. I was nearly up doing the jitterbug halfway through, and I have no idea what the jitterbug even is.
Love it. Love hearing the classic jazz that I’ve heard in jazz and marching band my whole life from the legend himself and his amazing band
Classic! Love the Duke!
A captured portion of Jazz from and incredible musician. Historically significant and a good time to listen through.
Probably the hardest album to get through so far. I enjoy jazz live but struggle listening to it at home. Impressive horns, though not super pleasant to listen to at the points of showing off breath work. Parts I liked, and otherwise my attention span was put to the test. Important to listen music like this though, especially since I'm not a musician
Cannot deny the talent, skill, musicianship, etc.....just kinda old and boring. I'd like to respect them with a better rating, but if I am being honest....
Jazz is a genre of music which peaked at a time when large swathes of its audience, and in all likelihood the musicians themselves, were regularly getting hammered on liquor distilled in bathtubs, and it really shows. Having said that, I quite enjoyed this, but mainly as background noise. The more I focused on it, the less I liked it. This is music meant to be heard while doing the Charleston in a speak-easy with some flapper girls, not listened to while sat working at a computer.
Quite a pleasant listen actually, preferred it to the John Coltrane. Simpsons reference: Yes
Surprised that I actually enjoyed this, could see myself listening to more. Giving it an extra star, for being not only a bearable jazz album, but an enjoyable one.
I have been to a couple of different newports, and can honestly say this the worse one. And I have been to the Welsh one!! Tracks are too long! Didn't like it. However on a positive not it was better than coltrane
I liked it more than I thought I would to be fair. Not usually a fan of big band but most of this worked. Really enjoyed the opening piece, the rest interested me less.
Good tunes, but live recording in 1956 was kinda distant.
surprised that i enjoyed this so much
Is it just me
I just don't really like this kind of jazz.
A very pleasant listen although I'm not sure it stands up to active listening
Making some brass instrument sound like a voice is impressive but ultinatly limited in appeal. Music from another age hard to connect with but you know good.
Very cool, easy background listening. Great musicians, not sure the live element adds that much.
Whilst it's enjoyable jazz, I wasn't particularly grief at any point. Deserves its pace on this list, though.
Spotify had the remastered album, running at about 2 hours. Far too long! I opted to pick out the 5 tracks from the original 1956 LP (accordingly to Wikipedia). Much better.
[rating is of the 1956 version]
It’s a live instrumental that for 1956
biiiig album, but has some cool music
I don't appreciate jazz as i don't understand it, great but not for me
A great live recording of an all time jazz great. Subtle and nuanced, smooth and cool, this is (unsurprisingly) top notch. Rating: 4/5 Playlist track: Diminuendo in Blue Date listened: 22/01/24
You like jazz, you like the Duke.
Haven’t really listen to that much jazz but certainly knew how popular Duke Ellington became. Rating album higher as I can appreciate his accomplishments and the musicians that helped him achieve his well deserved status.
2.7 per track. Ignored the talking tracks. This is fine, perfect for background music but I don’t think I’d be listening with intent.
Highlight here is Diminuendo in Blue, with the middle section by Paul Gonsalves. Outstanding!
Siempre he tenido gran curiosidad por el jazz y he escuchado cosas aquí y allá pero creo que este es el primer álbum entro que me siento es disfruto. Una gran elección, no solo por disfrutar este gran genero en directo y con una calidad increíble si no ver la gran calidad de diferentes artistas juntos con su arte individualmente colectivo. Uno que sin duda repetiré muchas veces y me ha dado pie a conocer a muchos más.
Dope work vibes.
Einer der großen Meister, was soll man da sagen. Als Live-Aufnahme für diese Zeit gar nicht so schlecht. Witzig sind die Ansagen, z.B. wird Quincy Jones als vielversprechender Arrangeur angekündigt ;-)
Well this was perfectly pleasant. Nice to have a live album for this kind of music. As far as jazz goes I thought this was easy going and not aggravating...
Blah, I guess it was kind of pleasant but I'm just not interested.
Some good tunes, and great musicians playing them. But Jazz just isn’t my bag.
I don’t know much about Duke Ellington, other than that he was a ghost on Big Mouth, and I’ve always assumed Sir Duke by Stevie Wonder is about him. I think he’s one of the bigwigs of jazz, from an era where jazz seemed to be considerably more listenable. Songs I already knew: none Favourites: Jeep’s Blues One of my favourite songs as a child was In The Mood by the Glenn Miller Orchestra (I was a weird child). This felt very similar to that and made me quite nostalgic, despite the songs still being objectively unfamiliar to me. It was nice background music while working and was an album where I was bit gutted to have it end. I’m not sure I’d seek this out again, but I’d enjoy it if it came on.
Pretty much every actual song on this got added to my dinner party playlist immediately. It was cool to hear the "skits" in between songs since it was basically just a recording of the entire set which made me feel like I got the whole experience of being at Newport 70 years ago.
Definitely old timey (40s and 50s) jazz. Not my music at all.
Dideldidudeldei
Ahh. Finally! One the albums I needed to listen to. Frequently mentioned as one of the good ones. Big band isn’t my thing, but this album was recorded just as post-bop was becoming a thing. Well done for what it is. 4 stars
Not a fan of jazz music
Good kitchen music
Good listen. Jazz really isn’t my favorite, but this was an enjoyable listen. 3 stars for me, but probably a 4-5 for a jazz album.
I enjoyed this. I liked the introduction at the beginning because it helped set the scene of this being recorded in front of an audience. It gives you the feeling you’re there in the audience, too. This was a lively album and I would listen to it again if I was in the mood for 50s jazz.
För långt. 50-talsjazz är inte jättespännande.
Love albums always feel like sneaky best of albums.
I don't care for live albums, but I do like jazz.
I didn't hear as much of this style of music on my childhood as I did of Stan Getz and that style, but this is the music my mom grew up listening to so I have heard it before and a lot of other big band music. Mom's favorite tho was Sinatra. Anyway, this album is historic and foundational, so I approve!
du jazz qui s'écoute super bien. je ne saurais juger la qualité des musiciens, mais c'était très sharp pour une prestation live 7/10
Absolutely electric~!
Jazz. Trompetita.Orquestita.
Great album, but be forewarned that it is 2 hours long and benefits listening through in one go!
Hard to listen to, partially down to the recording equipment available at the time and partly because it's Jazz. Sounds like it was recorded with a potato.
It was nice. Sounds good nothing I recognized
It’s ok I prefer more upbeat jazz tho
1/11/24
Very talented unfortunately I am uncultured swine and I like newer things
Great sound
Great mix of jazz. Slow Blues. Jive. Horn players going mad for it.
Not a fan of Duke or live albums, too much introduction talk to keep me listening to the whole thing. Also Jazz is not my favorite.
Jazz. Trompetita.Orquestita.
I like the live sessions and hearing the extra chatter.
Absolutely swingin. Some of the solos are jaw dropping. I still hate a live album, but this performance fed off of that crowd.
What I assume is an iconic jazz album. I liked it but just am not a huge jazz guy
A very good jazz ensemble album by duke ellington. This is classic jazz that has a little bit of everything and is very easy to listen to. Back when jazz was one of the top genres and the most talented artists performed it. Now put that energy into a live album and you get this solid piece of work. 6.7/10
I never sat down and truly listened to this legend before this opportunity. Love the old big band and jazz sounds. Makes you truly appreciate just how good, progressive, and inventive music once was in this country.
Nice!
Not for me
Ziemlich langweilige Fahrstuhlmusik, leicht nervend gegen Ende
Not a huge fan of old jazz but this stuff ripped.