Reviews (page 6 of 8)
Bien pero ritmos muy repetitivos
All songs sound the same. Rock that I can forget easily.
Kinda like it, old school but catchy...
Good ol' Australian punk. Iconic for its time, alright now
I liked this one. Maybe a little simple at some times holding it from a 5 for me. Still good punk that I haven ever heard before. Will I listen to again: 75%
Great, straight forward Punk Rock with very nice sounding production
Imagine the Smiths where the bass remains the same, the drums and guitar are dialled back in the mix, and the singer, rather than Morrissey, is some drunk Aussie off the streets of Canberra. That's pretty much what we're working with here. The standouts on this album were the bass and horns. The bass guitar was very energetic and motile, arpeggiating up and down chords at just the right time and gluing the rest of the band tightly together. The horns/trumpets, in the few tracks in which they featured, were tight, punchy, and just a little low-quality (a la Got To Get You Into My Life, Beatles version). I'm a fan of that sound. There were some catchy (albeit extremely generic in the punk genre) guitar riffs, but I wish they would've gone all-out and played it with more gusto. The electric guitar sound is often very washed out here; same with percussion. Again, the bass definitely keeps the band afloat, establishing a solid energy and defining the chord progression when the guitar fails to do so. The singing is very typical of the punk genre – namely, unrefined and technically not great – but it works. Kind of. Great energy throughout the album. Some fun moments too – International Robots, (I'm) Misunderstood, Orstralia, to name a few. Trust a punk band to not take themselves too seriously. I just wish the music was backed up with better recording choices and a stronger vocalist. 3/5 Key tracks: Know Your Product, Orstralia, (I'm) Misunderstood, International Robots
I don't really have much to say about this one, except that of all of the Australian albums my group has gotten so far this is the one I've liked the best. Turns out all they hadda do to win my affection was play some damn solid punk with horns on a few tracks. Who woulda knew?
Did not know what I was expecting when I started this album, but that second track just fucking blew me away. These Australians can make some banger punk tunes.
I’m at a 3.5 and… fine, alright, I’ll bump it up. Shockingly, for a 36 minute album, I think this kinda goes a bit long; 13 tracks is a little much, and some of them circle around the same soundscape a few times in a way that makes listening to the full album sort of a chore by the end. It comes out of the gates pretty hot though, but I only really dug one or two of the final 5 tracks. Sometimes less is more, you know? Instrumentation is super fun, lots of energy, and the horn section that comes up a few times is really fun. Vocals are a bit jarring at times, but I don’t think they’re ever outright bad, just unbefitting a few times. There are some seriously good lyrics on Private Affair that don’t fully get their credit because he goes all spoken word on them instead of belting them out with the energy they deserve. This happens a few times on the album, and while I don’t think it ever ruins the vibe of the song, it just makes me wish for a little more. Ultimately, though, I don’t think there’s a bad track on the album, and that’s the key difference between bumping it down to a 3 and bumping it up to a 4 – I had a lot of fun listening to this album, and I think with a little more time and a little more polish, a lot of my little nitpicks could’ve been cleaned up. This was a good album, and I’ll be nice to it because of that hot start to go with a 4. It’s like a 7/10, though.
Fun, energetic punk. I enjoyed it. 3.5 rounded up
When I read that this album mixed punk with R/B and a horn section, I was very intrigued. The first song on the album is great because of the innovative sound, but each subsequent song loses that uniqueness. By the 5th song the album just sounds like any late 70s punk record, which is a shame because the album never fully recaptures it's early intrigue. Overall disappointing. Top tracks: Know Your Product, Lost And Found
Old school school punk sound in the new age. Also, they bring out the horns!
This sounds great. Not sure I managed to give it the concentration it deserves today, so I'll be back for another listen
Kinda fun, kinda annoying. 4/10
If I liked Punk music more, this would be great album! Unfortunately I don't, but I recognize that it's a great entry in the genre! Some fantastic jams here.
Is this a loop of the same song? Cuz it feels like it
strong 4
Pretty decent old school punk. Would have been four stars from me if it wasn't 75 MINUTES LONG. 40 minutes should be the absolute maximum for any self-respecting punk record.
fun punk album with good riffs, but gets a little repetitive
I enjoyed this album
A little more polished than a traditional punk album but still pretty good. I liked it a lot
dfsadf
This reminded me more of early rock & roll than punk rock. As always, the highest compliment you can pay to punk rock music is that it sounds like something else. This punk rock sounds like something else, so it’s not too bad.
Punk indeed
I liked it but coulda skipped a few tracks
### In-Depth Review of "Eternally Yours" by The Saints "Eternally Yours," released in 1978, is the second studio album by Australian punk rock band The Saints. The album showcases a significant evolution in their sound, characterized by a broader musical palette and deeper lyrical content. Here's an in-depth review focusing on lyrics, music, production, themes, and influence, along with a balanced assessment of its strengths and weaknesses. #### Lyrics The lyrics on "Eternally Yours" reflect a more mature and introspective approach compared to their debut album, "(I'm) Stranded." Chris Bailey, the band's frontman and primary lyricist, explores themes of disillusionment, personal struggle, and societal critique. Songs like "Know Your Product" critique consumer culture and the superficiality of modern life with lines such as: > "You've got a big big mouth and nothing to say." This sharp, biting commentary is a hallmark of Bailey's lyrical style throughout the album. "A Minor Aversion" and "Private Affair" continue this trend, delving into personal and social conflicts with a raw, unfiltered lens. The lyrics are often imbued with a sense of urgency and frustration, reflective of the punk ethos. #### Music Musically, "Eternally Yours" represents a significant departure from the raw, stripped-down punk of their debut. The incorporation of brass instruments, particularly evident in tracks like "Know Your Product," adds a rich, dynamic layer to their sound. This brass-driven approach gives the album a distinctive flavor that sets it apart from typical punk records of the era. The album's opening track, "Know Your Product," features a prominent horn section that drives the song with an infectious energy. The addition of saxophone, trumpet, and trombone lends a soulful, almost Motown-like quality to the music. Tracks like "Lost and Found" and "Memories Are Made of This" also highlight the band's expanded musical range, incorporating elements of rock, soul, and R&B. Guitarist Ed Kuepper's work on this album is notable for its versatility. He seamlessly shifts between aggressive punk riffs and more melodic, textured playing. The interplay between Kuepper's guitar and the brass section creates a rich, layered sound that is both complex and accessible. #### Production Produced by Chris Bailey and Ed Kuepper, along with sound engineer Mark Moffatt, the production on "Eternally Yours" is a significant step up from their debut. The album's sound is polished without losing the raw energy and edge characteristic of The Saints. The production quality allows for a clear separation of instruments, which is particularly important given the diverse range of sounds and the inclusion of brass instruments. The production captures the intensity of the band's performance while enhancing the clarity and punch of each track. The brass sections are well-integrated into the mix, providing a full-bodied sound that complements the core punk elements. The balance between the vocals, guitars, and brass is expertly managed, ensuring that no single element overwhelms the others. #### Themes "Eternally Yours" explores a wide array of themes, reflecting both personal and societal concerns. The overarching theme of disillusionment runs through many of the tracks. "Know Your Product" critiques the commodification of culture and the emptiness of consumerism. "Run Down" and "Orstralia" delve into feelings of alienation and frustration with the socio-political landscape. Another recurring theme is the struggle for authenticity and meaning in a superficial world. "Private Affair" addresses the invasion of privacy and the public's obsession with celebrity culture, while "No, Your Product" and "This Perfect Day" critique the artificiality of societal norms and expectations. The album also touches on themes of nostalgia and memory, as seen in "Memories Are Made of This," which juxtaposes past experiences with present realities. The reflective nature of these lyrics adds depth to the album, offering a more contemplative side to The Saints' punk ethos. #### Influence "Eternally Yours" has had a lasting influence on both punk and alternative rock music. Its fusion of punk energy with soul and R&B elements was ahead of its time, paving the way for other bands to experiment with genre-blending. The incorporation of brass instruments into a punk framework was particularly innovative, influencing later acts that sought to expand the sonic boundaries of punk rock. The album's thematic content, addressing issues of consumerism, authenticity, and social alienation, resonated with listeners and provided a template for other bands to tackle similar subjects. The Saints' willingness to evolve and experiment with their sound has inspired countless musicians to push beyond the confines of traditional punk. #### Pros and Cons **Pros:** 1. **Musical Innovation:** The integration of brass instruments and exploration of diverse musical styles set "Eternally Yours" apart from other punk albums of its time. 2. **Lyricism:** Chris Bailey's introspective and socially conscious lyrics add depth and resonance to the album, making it more than just a collection of songs but a commentary on contemporary issues. 3. **Production Quality:** The polished production enhances the clarity and impact of the music, allowing the complexity of the arrangements to shine through. 4. **Thematic Depth:** The album tackles a wide range of themes, from personal struggles to societal critiques, offering listeners a rich, multifaceted experience. **Cons:** 1. **Departure from Pure Punk:** Some purists might argue that the incorporation of brass and the move towards a more polished sound dilutes the raw energy that characterized their debut album. 2. **Cohesiveness:** While the diversity of sounds is a strength, it can also make the album feel somewhat disjointed at times, as it shifts between different musical styles and themes. 3. **Accessibility:** The thematic complexity and genre-blending might make the album less immediately accessible to listeners who prefer straightforward punk rock. ### Conclusion "Eternally Yours" by The Saints is a landmark album that showcases the band's growth and willingness to push the boundaries of punk rock. With its innovative use of brass instruments, polished production, and thought-provoking lyrics, the album stands as a testament to The Saints' artistic vision and influence. While it may challenge some listeners' expectations of what punk music should be, its bold experimentation and thematic depth ensure its place as a significant and enduring work in the punk rock canon.
Saai en vind zn stem meh
Another band in the late 70ies on the way (?to punk?) not so bad, not so outstanding. nobody gets alarmed.
A fun punk sound, with Standouts hard to choose.
I just couldn’t finish listen to this, hurt my ears. Clearly it’s difficult to get good singers, even if the rest of the band sounds good. But what the heck do I know about music and singing.
Some good songs, some bad songs. It all cancels out to create the most mediocre album of all time.
Australian punk from 1978, but nothing I could enjoy. I usually like punk too. Maybe I was not in the right headspace for this album.
cool punk tunes, good vibe. bit samey though
They are a great punk rock band but why are the horns gone after the first track? With them all of the later songs could have a more interesting structure.
I liked the horns that featured on I think two of the songs.
the best!
It’s okay
Enjoyable.
I was surprised by this one. A really good punk album, with some blues mixed in and a horn section.
This is a lot more interesting than the Ramones, but I am still not a huge fan of this style of punk music. I appreciate how the songs sound different from each other.
This album is exactly what that first wave of punk was. It's fun, energetic and not boring at all. The songs are in a great order and it's perfectly produced. If this is what you're into it should be up your alley. I'd say they are sadly under appreciated (or even heard of)
01) Know Your Product - 7,5 02) Lost and Found - 6,0 03) Memories Are Made of This - 7,5 04) Private Affair - 6,5 05) A Minor Aversion - 7,0 06) No, Your Product - 7,0 07) This Perfect Day - 7,0 08) Run Down - 6,5 09) Orstralia - 7,0 10) New Centre of the Universe - 6,0 11) Untitled - 7,0 12) (I'm) Misunderstood - 6,5 13) International Robots - 7,5 TOTAL: 6,85 (69/100) Current ranking: 130/173 Second punk album in a row. I'm not really a fan of punk so this is gonna be interesting. But this one IS kind of interesting. We have horns, we have harmonica, we have some slower songs here and there... It's still not my cup of tea, but it's not as shouty and repetitive as some other punk albums.
Yllättävän vauhdikas! Biisit ehkä vähän toistavat toisiaan ja itseään. Mutta onnistuttu tässä on: pitää mielenkiinnon, ei ole räminää muttei siloteltua (eli hyvä tuotanto?), pojilla on ideaa tässä.
Toimii parhaiten riffittelynä - muutoin melodian tai rytmisten koukkujen puute käy valitettavan raskaaksi. Elävä todiste siitä, että "rokkaaminen" ei riitä, jos haluaa soittaa rokkia.
Surprisingly catchy punk rock!
The Saints bring along a few “new” ideas, but they never have the courage to fully rely on them.
Great Album, really enjoyed it.
Real punk rock. The first song was a little much and I didn't want to listen to the rest of the album. But it got better with every song. It had a very clear punk sound but also included the quirkiness that comes from Australian musicians. Favorite is Memories are Made of This. Will definitely listen to again!
A couple of unique tracks. Run down throwing in the harmonica randomly. Feels like a soundtrack to Tony hawk video game.
the fuck is this. It's bland skapunk
i didn't get much from the saints' eternally yours album. it's very punk, right in the era of the clash and the ramones, but i couldn't find an aspect that allowed it to stand out, or at least offer something different from punk i've already heard. not bad by any means, but why was this included?
What stood out about this album is the addition of the horns; in addition to its punk roots, the horns give this album a very proto-ska sound, as well. That said, the sound was most obvious and standout on the first track, "Know Your Product", and then faded more into the background as the album progressed. So while the horns was a notable occurrence, it wasn't a prevailing one. Otherwise, this was pretty standard punk for this particular era. It was fine, but it didn't really offer anything that stood out to me.
Преступно мало духовых.... Потому что эта хуйня меня удивила
Surprised I never heard of this band or album at the time. In it's day I think I'd have liked it & they'd probably be great livebut from this distance it was a bit 'meh' I'm afraid.
A punchy album.
I would have loved this when I was 16.
Middling. I like the horns and appreciate a punk act with chops but nothing jumped out at me. I expect I'll eventually forget this band. I get why they had their moment but don't think it's timeless by any means.
I feel like they could grow on me
Cool stuff
Surprisingly good!
Not something I would hear. But it's nice Fav songs: Know your product Untitled =E
Meh, all sounds the same. I wonder what it takes to hear the difference between this and, for example, Ramones.
I hate 98% of this websites user base and their tastes this is so bad
Never heard of these guys before. Really good old school punk. 3.5 stars.
A brilliant fusion of many of the early British and US punk bands, with a clear influence on a bunch of Australian bands since - the likes of You am I, The Living End, Jet, & The Vines owe The Saints a huge debt. I loved it, especially because of its clear sense of both time and place. A brilliant record (which probably doesn't need the b-sides, rarities and live takes on the linked version)
boring but never bad
Tja, wer denkt Big-Band können nicht mit Punk- oder Hardrock gemischt werden, den belehrt dieses Album from Down Under eines besseren. Die Mischung ist interessant und kurzweilig aber nicht genial. Dieses Album ist grundsolide Musik. „Memories Are Made Of This“, „This Perfect Days“ & „A Minor Of Aversion“ wissen zu gefallen.
Eternally Yours is the second album by Australian punk rock band the Saints. The band pursued more of an R&B sound on this album with an added horn section to their normally stripped down sound. Critics mostly loved this album and hailed it as a classic from the early punk rock movement. I felt this was a fine punk rock album, but it was also nothing special. If you're a fan of punk rock, then I recommend this album.
Enjoyed this more than I expected.
Straya.
An early classic punk record heavily featuring horns and following in the footsteps of earlier glam rock and the pop punk of the Ramones. Songs evoke New Wave (the surf riffs, jangles, horns, pop singing style, chorus effects) and garage (60s grooves, sporadic drumming, bluesy forward vocal style). "This Perfect Day" is gothic, "Untitled" is power pop, and "I'm Misunderstood" is rockabilly. A few duds on here that don't work, but a lot of the deep cuts have appealing pop hooks. It's a unique sound which plenty of creative ideas. Very accessible with several standout tracks. Nothing too outstanding but it's fun and I will revisit this. Favorites: Memories are Made of This, No Your Product
This album has non stop energy from start to finish
Australian punk.
Ja. Immerhin eine schöne Klangvielfalt mit nettem Rock.
Punk rock lyrics, look, and snarl with a horns section? Haha, hmmm, ok that's different... If I hadn't grown up on real punk I might have been fooled... It's a fair effort, 2 stars.
It's your typical punk album
It’s ok
New enjoyable discovery!
Decent and at time I thought it neared on good but suffer from many of the same punk rock problems of terrible singing and unremarkable instumentation.
# 191 : Solid album that totally rocks, Punks not my thing but this was good. Some awesome tunes on here. I'd spin it again if it came up. Favourite Track : Run Down
This is an album made for me; unfortunately, it is too long to pay attention to all the songs.
Its was quite good, just not perfect.
Cool album from a brand new band to me. Really enjoyed, did blend together a bit.
Pretty good. I wish the horns from the first track were a bit more prevalent throughout to give it a more unique sound, but it's still a great time. Solid, simple, catchy punk, totally unknown band and songs, so the project is doing just what I wanted. Love the Aussie sneer in the vocals too. 19/03/24
Rock punk, un poco rollo.
I love this! And I've never heard it before! Wow, this is such a treat for a Friday. I love 70's punk rock, so I'm slipping into this one like a warm, welcoming bubble bath after a long and exhausting day spent dismantling the patriarchy from within. We don't get a lot of Australian music shipped up to Canada and these guys were probably completely overshadowed by the NY and British punk scenes at the time, which is likely why I've never heard of them until now. But so much of this lyricism resonates with me, especially today. The only thing I dislike is the horribly off putting album cover. Not punky enough, and too shitty, it’s not helping the band look appealing.
It's just punk rock template. It's fine, I guess, and if you're into punk you'll probably like it, but it's just so boring. Nothing unique or interesting about it.
After seeing the year this came out, I was shocked at what was coming through my headphones. I think this music was a little ahead of its time. I don't think of this type of garage-y punk rock gaining traction until the 1990s/2000s, but I thoroughly dug it. I found myself headbanging along to most of the songs. Makes me want to thrash about in a pit at a concert. I enjoyed this album a lot.
Decent punk rock. Not sure what makes it more special than other alternative groups like The Strokes. The vocals bothered me at first but grew on me by the end.
did not like it at all
skating music???
nothing memorable to write about, punk rock with no energy
Great to see an Aussie band on the list. The Saints are a solid hard rocking punk band with their own sound and a bit more depth to their music than the average punk band
Sometimes it's just nice to have a straightforward punk album. This album was punchy and driving. Though it has less sneer than the Sex Pistols and isn't as experimental as the Clash, this album embodies its time and didn't have a dull moment.
I had never heard of these Australian punks but there are some bops here.
I enjoyed this new to me album. Some good tunes, but not sure if I would revisit.
This was groovy and surfy, i digged it
The Saints - Eternally Yours Australian punk band. I really enjoyed this album. 4/5
This is a solid album. I'm loving the driving force throughout the length of it. The walk of music hits every song. You can tell this would have gone down well in a sweaty, smoky pub in the 70s and 80s.
Can’t find the quote but I’m pretty sure one time George Carlin said something along the lines of “if you work in advertising, kill yourself.” and that basically sums up the ethos of this album!
Classic sounding punk album. Pretty decent over all. 3/5
Not a band I know. Love the first song, love the horns. The next few songs are more standard-issue punk, but still enjoyable. Favorites: Know Your Product, A Minor Aversion, Orstralia. I ended up listening to an extended album and it included a great cover of River Deep, Mountain High.
Not up to much lyrically, but really sharp musically and reminds that punk is more than just anarchy.
Kick ass punk rock. Sorry I didn’t hear it back in the day
This was good! Surprisingly so, really. I was expecting some horrible thrashing, but it's musically pretty interesting and has a bit of depth. The singer is obviously a bit of an irritant, but that's probably to be expected. But overall, a great discovery.
Stable rock but nothing that stands out to much for me
Crap
It’s kind of ok for me but not much more than that
This is ok
Fine I guess, but why make it 27 songs?
Great album.
Not a great album.
Not bad as punk rock goes ... until you get to track 4 or 5 or 6... Same anti-establishment theme in every song and nearly the same tune. BORING as crap!! 2/5
Wow. Starts with a bang. Just a lot of energy. Lost and found seems like Green Day took some liberties from this song. Really enjoyed the passion and energy.
Totally serviceable punk rock. The delivery doesn't seem as angry or angsty as would benefit the music... it seems a bit plain or disaffected. I like both Memories are Made of This and A Minor Aversion, apparently a time where they were allowed to use the "R" work. ;)
One song ok, too punk to listen to continuously
вроде не бесячий панк, но на все выходные меня не хватило конечно)
Ástralskt pönk. Já já, alveg hægt að hlusta á þetta.
3 stars
27 songs wow it didn't feel like that many. This album is pretty mid. Easy listening for a classic rock style album but at the end of the day, pretty forgettable.
Felt repetitive most of the time and also it felt really long, even tho is not completely bad.
Very good album and I did very much enjoy the songs on there.
Rips. Can still remember the thrill of first hearing Know Your Product about 20 or so years ago. Not a perfect album but when it's good, it's pure energy
Well, I can certainly say that the production on this album sounds like absolute shit. That's not particularly unusual on early punk music albums, particularly ones that were produced by the band themselves. However, under the hood of this album is a lot of neat stuff. I love that they included horns in a lot of these tracks. That was a really innovative idea for early punk music. The vocals sound good, given the overall quality of the album. Really cool early punk album 4/5
Inget kul.
Not sure why’d you’d sling this on over any other UK Punk from the time
This is fun, and the skills demonstrated are impressive. There are varied instruments being used, more complex arrangements. Sometimes I feel like I can't listen to a lot of punk rock back to back because it blends together, but I did enjoy a lot of these songs. Untitled, (I'm) Misunderstood, International Robots, The Ballad!
Banda de punk australiana, no es mala la verdad, pero tampoco la gran cosa.
It's good punk. But it's not great punk. And it's certainly not world-class punk. But it IS good punk and I happen to like punk.
This was a great album. The singing wasn’t great, but punk often had that problem. I didn’t pay as much attention to the lyrics as I’d like but I really enjoyed listening to the album. The horn pieces, which threw off some people, I felt added to the soundscape
Great Early Punk Record
Звучит ровно так, как можно было бы ожидать от панк-альбома второй половины семидесятых. Во это конкретное звучание, формула, мне кажется, и стали смертью жанра (ну, смерть здесь, наверное, очень громкое слово, но мысль понятна). Хорошие песни есть, но в контексте всего того ПОСТ-панка, который условно возникает в этот самый 78-ой год, это всё звучит совсем не впечатляюще. Лучшая песня - Know Your Product.
Lol this band sucks. Sounds like lazy rancid kareoke.
1977-78 is my favorite period of music. Mostly because of the incredible diversity of really interesting and unique artists recording at the time - funk, soul, country, L.A.'s country-rock, pop, hard rock (classic and Van Halen's new take), soft rock (yacht and the decedents of Pet Sounds), prog rock, german synth-rock, punk, jazz was still kicking, and I'm sure I've missed a bunch. There was so much amazing and interesting music coming out that some real gems are all but lost to history. Never Mind the Sex Pistols. Here's the Saints!
Not really for me
Is "Know Your Product" and "Orstralia" the origins of modern ska? Sounds like a band you'd hear playing Tony Hawk. Like the bass and electric playing off each other on A Minor Aversion. Not exactly my style, but an enjoyable listen.
It was pretty good. Didn’t have to hear the album twice though. The singer could be better but the music was fun.
Early punk/pop...enjoyed this.
I liked it I’ve never heard it or them really. Would listen again.
Another artist I've never heard of! It's not quite punk to me, but it certainly has that aesthetic right down to the production quality from this period. I also can't help but compare to Bob Dylan. Maybe it's just the singer's voice, but it has an electric Dylan vibe to me. As if Bob Dylan got into punk rock.
no pensé alguna vez escuchar punk australiano, no estuvo mal
good one
Nice bawdy punk with tunes and a good sound. Just a bit short of stand out songs but pleasant notheless.
Get up and go punk rock from the late 70s, when experimental sounds, discord, and anarchy were musical. I’m beginning to see the birth of so much diversity of later years came from the sounds of the late 70s. Probably won’t listen again, except for the last song. That was fucking funny.
Good basic Aussie punk/garage. The only real reason this seems notable is that they were very early on the scene as a punk band.
Dope Australian punk! Loved it
Aufgeregt schrammeiliger Punk Rock.
I'm not familiar with this 'Aussie punk rock' band. This is a really interesting album, I'm liking a lot of what I'm hearing. 'Memories are Made of This' is a great song. Really cool/trippy vocal effects on 'International Robots', the closing track. I want to to listen to more of their stuff. Definitely a good one. 3/5
Fine punk 3/5
This is an album full of great punk rock instrumental performances undermined by mediocre vocals and melodies. I loved what the guitars and bass were doing throughout. But the vocals lacked energy or something. I mean, this came out in 1978, just a year before “London Calling” and “Singles Going Steady,” and two years after “Ramones.” And while the band arrangements could hold up against those albums, the vocals simply cannot. A shame, because it almost was great.
Good fun punk record - right up my street.
first track was great. Then I remembered why I'm not a huge fan of punk.
Solid punk performance from Australia. Solid and edgy but listenable.
Liked this, early Punk, very listenable, will check out more by the artist
Not bad background music, nothing stood out as amazing but kept me in a good zone
Paint by numbers punk music but I quite enjoyed it.
Decent album, not a lot of stand outs but a good listen. Was going to give it 2 star but then realised it's late 70's which needs kudos
Some decent moments on here. Rattles along nicely
One of australias most important rock bands. Also boring to me.
Meh.
Confused by all the reviews calling this raw punk when it's surprisingly polished and the better for it. Was prepared to give a 3 but enjoyed listening all the way through so rounding up to 4, bit long I think
Early punk hits to shake your rump to. You can clearly see where they are inspired by and have inspired other punk, alt rock, and post punk groups. Its interesting for a few minutes but gets a bit repetitive in the end. Still an easy listen if your just jamming along on some work or looking for a mid-afternoon pick me up on a commute home.
An interesting mix of instruments not normally heard on a punk album.
Standard fare
Pretty good album. Not a big punk guy but I enjoyed this one. I'd say I wish I could make out what the singer was singing a little more easily, but that wouldn't be very punk would it?!?
Not great. Did not finish.
3/5 Best Track: Untitled
duplicate
Song: Know Your Product I'm going to admit, going into this, I was relatively apprehensive. I typically try to keep an open mind, but three of the last four days have all been strikeouts for me, and two of those songs were rock-adjacent (hated Rush, really hated Dinosaur Jr.). So, when I saw a punk album come up, I was sure I'd hate it. However, I was pleasantly surprised. Is the singer especially musically gifted? No. Is his voice a little monotone and grating? No. But does he sound like he's whining and complaining? Absolutely not, he sounds like he's having the time of his life, and that's a stark contrast from the other rock songs I've listened to through this project. Some of the lyrics are objectively hilarious (let's shoot the professor!) but the subject of the song also seems pretty topical, considering today's age of constant advertising. Also, I really loved the brass section in the mix there, that's not a sound I usually hear in rock or punk and it was a really great addition. Generally, this was a really solid track, and probably my favorite rock or rock-adjacent song of the project so far.
Punk isn’t my thing
Another one where it sounds good for the era.
This rules why the hell didn't I know about it before?
Besides being the hated rival of my Atlanta Falcons - I have no experience with "The Saints". Didn't have time for the entire album, but the tracks I listened to, I enjoyed. Punk with horns - I love the idea. This is not an album I would return to, but I enjoyed my time with it. I would choose this over the Ramones or anything Green Day has churned out.
Really good early punk. Fast, hard, raspy vocals. Checks all the boxes.
I colleague gave me this record when he got rid of his vinyl collection. Pleasant surprise. It's very similar to OG UK punk like the Damned, but more energetic. I think it's good, but not essential. Favorite song: Run Down.
A couple of fun songs, but, overall, just more reinforcement of the reason I do not like punk.
Why do I like this so much? Solid classic Punk sound... never heard them. Love the bass. We open with some brass hooks. Then we get some catchy early punk. The on Run Down week got a harmonica going ham! This is awesome!
Täähän koittaa ammentaa samasta osastosta ku johnny thunders ja hanoi ja new york dolls. Mun korvaan jää vähän vajaaks silti. 2/5
Hyvä meno ja alussa kovia biisejä. Lopussa vähän hiipui.
Todella menevää kamaa, sopii hyvin vähän kevyemmän musan kaipuuseen! 4/5
This is the best type of punk, the kind that isn’t afraid to take risks, doesn’t adhere to some kind of notion of what punk is “supposed to be”. As a result, it doesn’t sound tied to its era. In fact, on songs like “Memories are Made of This” or “A Minor Aversion”, it sounds ahead of its time, prescient…a blueprint for what would become indie rock in the 80’s and 90’s.
Not a bad record, good straight ahead riffs, bass lines were good. 3/5 but may kick it to 4/5 at a later time
Ok
8/10
It's ok.
Just sounded like generic punk music to me.
early punk, rock, petite touche ska. bien agréable tout ca 7/10
Another shitty punk album like this couldn’t have come at a worse time. Having to go from an actually fun 70s rock album to a shitty one really sucks because I was just desperate to go back to T. rex after every single one of these ass songs that all sounded the same. The fact that it sounded a bit closer to 80s post punk and used a couple of unique instruments are the only silver linings to this album.
Is this the grandfather to ska? The horns are going wild. This is some solid punk. Good all around.
Solid early Punk album. Not sure what to say. Nothing popped for me but I might revisit in the future.
Zo'n half dronken stem en middelmatige nummers. Wat doet deze plaat in onze lijst?
Wel oké.
Feitelijk gezien is hier dus eigenlijk maar heel weinig reet aan. Of misschien wel geen reet.
Discovering a lot of new music
Neat little punk band that seems to be not so well known. Fun stuff.
3.5
Punk is not for me
Skv. Wikipediu sagði Robert Christgau að brassið á þessari plötu væri misheppnaður brandari. Ég spyr, hefur Christgau einhvern tímann ekki talað út úr rassgatinu á sér? Hresst pönk, merkilega fjölbreytt og brassið á mjög vel við. Fyrirfram gisk 3 stjörnur, lokaniðurstaða 4.
I liked it!
It was fine, very punk. Not really something interesting or new though if I wanted this type of music I’d go a couple albums back. It was fine though.
some sektch language, okay punk rock otherwise
New to me. Loved it. Was a great album.
Holy shit! These Aussie punks are obviously something Rancid and Tim Armstrong have heard before. High energy and mixing punk with 70s rock. The exact type of album that’d have me pogo dancing in downtown Melbourne!
Every song seems to be the same.
It has always been too hard and depressing for me.
More like bunk rock
Fine, but not my cup of tea
Started off pretty decent and then kinda fell off for me personally. Full of energy, though, so points for that.
Punk Rock, with horns and harmonicas 1978 Standouts: Know Your Product, This Perfect Day Others: Lost and Found, Private Affair, No Your Product, Untitled,
Cool punk music from Australia
Not on Apple Music
Completely new to me. Never even heard of these fellas. Infectious beats. Punk and rock vibes with extra treats such as the occasional horn and harmonica. Great album overall. Added "This Perfect Day", "Lost and Found", and "Run Down" to my current playlist.
One of the old ones that was actually okay, although still pretty forgettable...
70s punk sound. Kinda gets boring while listening to the entire album.
I liked it, but it can be a bit one-toned at times.
Just noise
Awesome. Reminds me of the Stooges from time to time, which is a good thing. I can also hear bits that likely influenced the likes of Ty Segall.
Fav song: memories are made of this
Sehr zugängliches Punkalbum, Know Your Product macht absolut Laune, private Affair auch absolut solide.
Hey, a punk album getting over a 2 is pretty rare from me. Some of the riffs were good and I liked the vocalists' voices. Definitely one of the better punk albums I've gotten, but, sadly, only good enough for a 3. My favourite songs were Memories Are Made of This and No, Your Product.
Som tri, punkzao clássico
Ça sonne comme une parodie de Clash, ce qui n’est pas toujours une mauvaise chose
2.0 - 2.5
They sound like a punkier Velvet Underground. Not quite defining their own style, so it’s not entirely original, but they’re all enjoyable, fun songs if you don’t think about it too much. 3/5
Pretty good for a punk album but that’s not saying much. 2.375.
The horns and arrangement lift it above others of its genre even if I found it a bit samey
Some songs had mid 2000s rock feel. Not bad
I guess I felt that, although it was a bit of a punk-ish band, there wasn't anything overly distinctive here. What made the Clash the Clash was they were wasn't just a punk band. There was something more there. I just didn't feel it. It wasn't bad, but I just... felt it could be more.
From the opening few seconds of Know Your Product (what a beauty) I was thinking ska punk like Goldfinger, Rancid, or the Johnstones (maybe Fishbone too? - I don't quite see them as punk though). It's the horns. I was surprised in my quick read not to see these guys tossed into that genre, they're just seen as early punk. Anyway, this album brings a lot of energy and the horns fused with the strings and drums give it a nice melody. Even when the horns aren't there they've got nice melody to go with their tempo. It's smoother than other punk and the album hummed along for the first half, though it did feel a bit repetitive by the middle onward. My other favorites besides the opening track were Lost and Found, Private Affair, Orstralia, Misunderstood. Great start to the album but it couldn't keep that pace. Torn between a 3 and a 4.
Fun album, but has the same problem all punk albums have - after a while it's clear you're hearing the exact same song. But it's a fun song. Favorite tracks: Know Your Product, Memories are Made of This, Private Affair, A Minor Aversion.
Didn’t know the band or record. It was enjoyable. A second listen may benefit.
if radiohead wrote this it would be a 5
It's a really solid early punk record with with overt nods to glam and pop. This one was a pleasant discovery for me.
Brand new to me, I was very non pleasantly surprised. Sounded very modern for 1978. 3.6 rounded up.
2.7. Gotta admit. I've never heard of the saints. From 1.5 listens of the album without any context I thought it was pretty straightforward. Know your product was the one that stood out for me. I'm sure if I was australian and/or dig deeper in the discography I'd appreciate it more
What a quick listen. Aussie Punk doesn't waste any time. Some good, if not forgettable, tracks on here.
yikes no. Wow do I hate the vocals. The beat's great, love the guitar, but oh the whine grunge. And I /like/ wangst. Do I love the guitar though <3. Just every time the lyrics kick in its like slimy sandpaper. Run Down is the first one with barely tolerable melodic vocals. but it might be that it is just mixed to minimize it under the harmonica. ooh, the intro to Untitled. The vocals are so much better. Seriously, this song alone is adding a whole star.
Excellent first 3 songs but loses momentum in the 2nd half. Fun listen but not in the top tiers of the genre.
An Australian rock and roll album with loose punk ties and rowdy production. Love the horns.
One of my favorite punk albums so far. Loving it!
This is how it feels to drown in sewer sludge.
Orstraliaaa! Become eternally theirs, sanctified! Punk at its coolest, its most vulnerable, misunderstood kid just hoping he’s liked as he scoffs at society. May make you want to kiss anything that moves and murder!
It was a decent rock album. No apparent classics but all the songs seem like they could be.
Perfectly splendid. Nothing earth shattering or life altering, or, for that matter, memorable. But quite splendid.
Favourite songs: Know Your Product, Lost and Found, "No, Your Product", Run Down, New Centre of the Universe, Ostralia, (I'm) Misunderstood, The Ballad, Untitled Least favourite songs: Private Affair, Champagne Misery 4/5
Never heard of the saints, but this is a soild punk album, deserves to be on the list. Love the raw energy while still keeping it together musically. Added to my frequent rotation.
Meh
1.5. Not very novel
Classic first generation punk.
Cool
When I saw this, I worried that it was going to be another dime-a-dozen punk band. I was instantly proven wrong. Trumpets in early 70s punk? It worked perfectly. Digging in a bit more, I found that The Saints were well ahead of the game. Contemporaries of The Ramones who brought punk to Australia before the Sex Pistols formed. Why are they not better known?
Another great band I'd never heard of.
Nice mix of punk and pub rock. A bit of adverts and a bit of Dr feelgood
p418. 1978. 2.5 stars Well done Aussie punk, with some decent tunes and added horns. Probably fantastic at the time, but sounds dated now. Not on the replay list.
Oh when the saints
Best Song: No, Your Product. A slightly more likeable Ramones. Worst Song: Private Affair. I mean he's literally just talking in this one. Overall: Who is out there campaigning for this forgettable album's inclusion in this list? Is anyone truly excited by this fairly paint-by-numbers punk band? It's just so extraordinarily okay.
Punk, now with horns!
14th September 2023 Listened during the day. Can’t remember what we did! Baby innit. Punk rock with a brass section - should be all over this but felt incoherent. 2.5 if I could.
Good punk music. I like the saxophone. This is one without much to say.
For 1978 punk music this is quite good musically, good urgency and not so dumb. Vocals are snarly and reminiscent of Psychedelic Furs and musically a bit like Stiff Little Fingers. I’m not totally won over by the vocal style, but I prefer this Australian punk to much of the English punk of the same period.
I've never heard of The Saints before, so I was really curious to see what this album would be like. Things started off strong with "Know Your Product." I really liked the guitar parts, and the brass arrangements punched things up and added some depth to the sound. I would have loved to hear more of the brass sound in the later tracks, but alas, I guess it wasn't to be. I thought the lyrics were really great throughout the album, minus a choice word that got repeated on "Memories Are Made of This," and the overall musical sound of the album was good too. This album managed to have the punk feel, while still feeling really well played and thought out from a musical standpoint. The biggest detractor for me is that the album started off really great, but never managed to hit that same level of greatness anywhere else on the album.
Rocking eternally. 4 stars.
Half listened
Very good one. Here's an 80s brit band worthy of the list.
Alright, got tired after a while
Like them Antipodians
Cool, but unremarkable.
I gave this one casual listen and enjoyed it quite a bit. I'm generally a fan of punk particularly when it doesn't take itself too seriously.
Amazing start to britpop.
HL: "Know Your Product", "No, Your Product", "Run Down", "Private Affair" Not complaining about finding a new Australian band! The lush production in certain songs clashes somewhat with the two-fisted punk songwriting, and other certain songs could be written by any number of British bands in the 70s. It's still an enjoyable time 3.5 August 14, 2023
This was fun! I think the music got a little too same-y for my tastes, so I probably won’t reach for the whole album too regularly, but some of the individual songs are really great.
Eternally Yours by The Saints is a raw and influential album that embodies the spirit of punk rock. Released in 1978, it showcases the band's evolution from their punk roots to a more diverse sound. Tracks like "Know Your Product" and "Private Affair" feature slashing guitars and propulsive rhythms, capturing the energy of the punk movement. The album's production is stripped-down, adding to its authentic charm. Chris Bailey's distinct vocals drive the album's rebellious message. Eternally Yours remains a pivotal release in punk history, marking a band's growth while staying true to their raw essence. It's a must-listen for punk enthusiasts and a testament to The Saints' lasting impact on the genre.
A good, fairly interesting pop album. Love the brass on it, and the Antipodean grumpiness in the lyrics. Vocals and songs are pretty middle of the road otherwise though.
Eternally Yours, by The Saints, is very meh. It is kinda fun, the sounds and vibes. The guitar riff’s and drums are nice, but the singing is subpar. The only song where the band is somewhat appealing is Lost and Found. Otherwise the British band seems to lack coherence and reference with the instrumentals in the songs. All in all, Eternally Yours is a bad album. Best Song: Lost and Found Worst Song: No, Your Product
An early punk album that didn't get annoying halfway through? The genre must be growing on me. Just the right amount of edge without sounding lame
Average punky sounds
Aussie punk. Good energy but I didn't find anything about it distinctive enough to be truly memorable. Ultimately, I guess that makes it Eternally Somebody Else's.
Never heard of the Saints so happy to listen to them. Some nice tracks and lyrics and a sound I can get behind.
-the very beginning of this sound so much like the strokes -i Love the horns in the back -i really like the slight harder rock version of like. the strokes going on here -i like this band that i had never heard of more than i thought i would -i do like the vibes they created in the studio that day -we Are all so groovy so true king -overall a solid four star album! i enjoyed that greatly
This was pretty good. Never heard of them but I enjoyed it.
No standout songs. Maybe good background music.
Decent early punk album. Not totally blown away.
Solid 70s punk, might relisten eventually BT - Lost and Found - Memories are Made of This - New Center of the Universe
For 1978, this feels way ahead of its time, almost like a treasure chest of hooks and ideas that future generations of bands to plunder. Look at what happens when you add horns to punk riffs – works pretty well, no? “A Minor Version” sounds like an ‘80s anthem written a few years early (with some strong and understated guitar riffs to boot) . The melodious numbers (“Memories,” “Untitled”) hold up better than the full-on ragers which sound generic (if also authentic). One hears pre-echoes of The Jam, The Fall, The Smiths, The Smithereens, Pavement, and so many others on this.
Har för mig debuten är snäppet bättre, men kan ha fel. Väldigt få krusiduller.
Catchy at times but not very memorable. A bit more melodic than other punk albums. By the end of the album I ended up liking it more than when it started. Went from 2 to 3 for me You hear a few punk albums and you’ve heard em all. It’s hard for me to enjoy punk this far into the 1001 generator
This is a very good album, not just the fantastic album opener but above all in the sense of the space, melodies and lyricism that would lead onto the Gobetweens, Triffids and The Church. Good stuff.
I didn’t manage to listen to the whole album but what I heard was alright. 3*
Enjoyed it. Will probably listen again and it may climb the rankings.
Gutes Ding. Kannte ich nich, kann man aber gut hörn. 3-4.
good find 🙏
I had some hopes here, it never happened. This isn't terrible, just bland.
Alright some more punk! At least this time its from a different "island" nation - Australia. Just gonna listen to this one and drop thoughts as they come... Opening track has almost ska-like elements with prominent horns. Progression feels very familiar; doesn't induce much feeling. I found myself tapping along to Lost and Found, and enjoy Memories Are Made of This. Almost reminds me a bit of Flaming Lips in the best kind of way. Vocal mixing on Private Affair does some interesting things with the stereo distribution. Pretty cool IMO. Guitar feels sort of like early The Offspring. Dropping out of the play-by-play mode, I will say that this album is much stronger than I expected based on the ('popular') opener. These guys show a wide range and several songs show really interesting production experiments that pay off. They may be "punk" but their instrumentals have depth that a lot of the early staples of this genre lack. Beachy vibes out of The Perfect Day TBH I haven't had a chance to finish, but based on what I've heard I'm a 4 / 5 here. I plan to listen to the rest later, but do not trust myself to retain my review. This was surprisingly well-produced and varied punk, and I enjoyed it.
not for me.
Olvidable
BL: never heard of before, will see how it turns out AL: thought it was pretty fun. The major problem for me is for a punk album there just isn’t no bite. I’m sure with a better mix & master engineer these problems could’ve been solved but nothing really stuck out and it all felt rather sludgy. This should be a case study on exactly why mixing and mastering is so important. FT: “private affair”, “no, your product” “this perfect day” 2.5/5
Punk + horns = love
Fun punky boys rippin and roaring around. Punk particularly fits the Australian aesthetic in my mind (having never been).
It was fun! I have nothing special to say other than I enjoyed my time on planet earth while listening. 3/5