Suicide by Suicide

Suicide

Suicide

2.46
Rating
23601
Votes
1
26%
2
29%
3
24%
4
15%
5
6%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 9)

I realize not every song out there has to be catchy. Hell, not every song has to necessarily be a "song," but it is always so jarring when something like that comes along, and its incredibly hard to adjust in a timely matter. Such is the case with much of this album, where any sort of normal song structure is thrown out for droning synths, sinister vocals, and an overall oppressive atmosphere. It works for a majority of the album, with its repetitive drive being oddly infectious, albeit many of the songs go on for too long, and I'd even say it has a melancholic feel to it at times, not unfamiliar to Velvet Underground fans. However, what seems to be considered the star of the show is Frankie Teardrop, and I mean that in any which way. Its a piece of avant-garde brutality, both on the mind and the ears. The piercing screams can cause even the most iron-willed listener to shiver, and... I hate it. I know its supposed to make me uncomfortable, but its downright a blight on an otherwise pretty decent record. Its too long, it comes out of nowhere, and in a modern age it doesn't come off as disturbing, rather edgy for the sake of nothing. Its the musical equivalent of a jumpscare, and in that aspect its memorable, but nothing to actually ponder, save for a throwaway line about there being a Frankie in all of us. The rest of the album is a synth-punk classic that earns its notoriety, but that single song bumps it down in such a way I can never see myself listening to this front to back again. Wish I could be enlightened enough to get it, but I'm not, and I really don't care to get there if that's what's awaiting me.

Dog shit. Worst album on the list 0/10

Feels like it’s just constantly building up but no beat drop or changeup. Blue balling tf outa me. Sounds like something I could make in garage band in less then 30 min. Frankie teardrop is fucking wild 😭. The hardest listen of my life.

Just not good

At first, I thought It would be a cool ambient vibe but no; just no. I don't know why it's on this list tbh. I powered through but god, 'Frankie Teardrop ' was absolutely awful. This is not for me.

Sounds like a teenager in his bedroom with a Casio keyboard

After listening to this, I nearly did…

Not good.

I dig this one quite a bit more than expected, given the album cover.

I don't think this is the worst album I have heard on here, but it's a contender! Seriously WTF?

There's a fine line between music and sound. Not sure which side this album is on...

Ok, I acknowledge that it sounds quite timeless and obviously was something very different in 1977. But, seriously, this is more sounds with feverish barking and wailing on top of it, than it is music, and it is definitely not for me.

Before listening: I have no idea who this is. The other bands where I didn't know any songs, I at least had heard of them. I have never heard of this band. I'm guessing late 80s punk. After listening: I ... think I liked it. Very atmospheric; not something I'd actively listen to, but I really like the sound of it. Is it a concept album? I tend to hate concept albums but I liked this one.

This sounds like bad karaoke.

3.9 - An unusual combination of primitive programmed percussions, and queer Elvis talking in his sleep. The showstopper is “Frankie Teardrop” that sets off this radical minimalism into something dark and macabre.

it started out good but then just got progressively weirder 2/5

I especially don’t like Frankie Teardrop

The most essential punk album of all time.

Interesting. Difficult.

C'est toujours agréable d'accompagner un suicidaire pendant sa masturbation, merci Robert.

Mais qui valide les propositions de hurlement de tous ces groupes obscur, n'ont.ils pas des proches pour leur expliquer que non, ce n'est pas agréable dans un morceau de musique ni dans rien d'autre ?

Really enjoyed this. Thoughtful with really experimental elements. Minimalist until the screaming kicks in. Clearly an influence on many sounds that followed.

Strangely interesting for a while but gets old fast. Not into the screaming parts either. Not for me.

So much character in the songs. I like the constant cicadas sound.

Poor Frankie

Started ok, and then not ok.

Note even music some times

Великий альбом, который я не готов слушать каждый день. Тот факт, что музыка из 1977-ого звучит в 2024-ом в принципе довольно современно - главный здесь показатель, мне кажется. Пост-панк в классическом смысле начался в 78-ом, и мне кажется, что вот этот альбом оказал серьезное влияние на многие в частности нью-йоркские группы, вроде Television, Talking Heads, или вот сколько-то отдаленных PiL. То же самое с Daft Punk и их Discovery, который 100% присутствует в местных списках. Я помню, что когда впервые слышал этот альбом, обращал внимание, что это очень catchy песни. И мне кажется, когда удается сделать музыку ну супер-авангардную, которая тем не менее нормально воспринимается - это очень круто. Неужели после прослушивания Ghost Rider или Johnny в голове не играют этот бас, эти рифы? Джо-джо-джо... Джоооони. Лучшая песня - Ghost Rider.

Zelfmoord is inderdaad wel wat je gaat overwegen door dit album

Lekker weer een ouderwets potje oorbloeden

Wat een grafmuziek

Thanks, I hate it.

You know, I pretty much liked it. Definitely a weird vibe, but I just love the combination of droning sounds and spacey effects. It would be great to use as the score of a horror movie. I probably would've rated it higher except a third of the runtime is taken up by the song "Frankie Teardrop" which goes a little too far and tips into halloween sound effects record territory.

Scary and weird 0 stars

This one was super weird and not in a good way. Why was he moaning in my ear? This is not it

Wat een raar album is dit zeg. Er zijn nauwelijks lyrics, de muziek klinkt vreemd en buitenaards en er valt voor mij nog niet echt een thema ofzo te ontdekken... Misschien ligt het aan mij, maar ik word hier niet heel wild van eerlijk gezegd. Frankies Teardrop is een theatervoorstelling, of een grap, of wat dan ook. Het is in elk geval geen muziek. Ik snap dat dit ontzettend veel invloed heeft gehad op latere synthpop albums, maar dit laat maar weer eens zien dat je niet altijd naar de bron moet gaan, omdat die soms gewoon niet zo goed is.

The album reminds me a bit of Massive Attack. But worse.

Difficult to listen to at times, but still fascinating in its experimental sound and ability to create a dark, ominous mood with nearly every track courtesy of the harsh, buzzing oscillation of the primitive synth sound, not to mention the bloodcurdling screams on "Frankie Teardrop". That said, mere artistic merit will not warrant multiple listens, and this is generally too grim and unpleasant overall - not in an awe-inspiring way, but a dingy, dirty, diseased one.

Fuckin noise

I respect this for experimentations sake, but that’s about all I get from it.

Frankie Teardrop 4:37 dronee, hees, 1.5/5 aika jännä :p 2/5

Mix of electric music and rock, text is repeating frequently with echoing. **

Now this is more like it. To be fair I have come across this before in other charts and polls but it's so up my street it's untrue. My family are pleading with me to turn Frankie Teardrop off but I love the screaming. There were other albums and bands before them that tried to experiment (Velvet Underground for instance) but I've always been a sucka for an early synth.

Frankie Teardrop goes insane, very experimental. I liked it but it's too long for the concept. Trance like but the screaming took me out of it. Very interesting, 7/10

There are parts to this I really liked. And then some I didn't

Too avant-garde without the direction. Louis Reed without the feed. It kinda seems like a bunch of dudes got together with a drum machine and a synthesizer and tried to do edgy shit. YEa, it was 77, but whatever

Ghost Rider - 8/10 Rocket USA - 8/10 Cheree - 8/10 Johnny - 7.5/10 Girl - 7.5/10 Frankie Teardrop - 7.5/10 Che - 7.5/10 TOTAL - 42/70

What? Freddie is gonna WHAT? AAAAAGHHHHHHHGHHAHAAAAAAAAAA!!!

You know the theme song from M*A*S*H, 'Suicide is Painless'? Whoever wrote that clearly never listened to this album.

Just very early arthouse style spoken work with electronic beats behind it. Felt depressing throughout most of it.

Let's NOT hear it for Frankie

Ghost Rider Cheree

This was new to me. It was stark and hectic. I liked it

How can anyone enjoy this? It is mostly static and noise, with no clear structure.

Used to like this album a lot. The New York/Lou Reed vibes. The Cherree song. The electronic sound. etc. But nowadays cannot stand the screaming and prefer the Alan Vega and Martin Rev album. But this is still an influential album that certainly belongs to the list.

Pathetic whining kills the somehow interesting staccato rhythms.

Weird. Innovative, but weird and a lil abrasive

No...just no. 1/5

Mikið hrikalega rosalega var ég feginn þegar plötunni lauk. Mér var í alvörunni orðið illt í eyrunum. Öskur og leiðindi og sami taktur og viðbjóður. Ég mun aldrei vilja hlusta á þetta aftur.

Rock mit schnellen melodischen Rhythmen

Heck yeah, it has "Ghost Rider" from my Halloween playlists! And "Girl" is pretty good. Wins 4 stars because I'm in a generous mood; if I gave 4 to Kate Bush for being emphatically herself, even if all the tracks sounded pretty similar, I can do that here.

Not a fan

First time listening to this. Definitely see where this record had many influences on electronic music and goth-punk going into the eighties. A bit of a depressing listen. You have to be in the right mood for this.

Hell yeah! More fuzz!

a good type of experimental

Ghost Rider: 4/5 Rocket USA: 3/5 Cheree: 4/5 Johnny: 3/5 Girl: 3/5 Frankie Teardrop: 2/5 (felt more like a challenge than a song but it did makr me feel something for sure so i'll give that) Che: 3/5

Hard to listen to… so depressing. The X-ray notes said they were ‘confrontational performers’. And I can understand they must have been to be able to create this kind of sound without ending it all immediately afterward.

Like a twisted velvet underground record. After listening it just kind of sounds like a funeral. I’m sure it’s important, but I’m not really into it.

Strong start weak finish

I liked this album a lot until "Frankie Teardrop." But man, I hated that song. It dropped my review two stars.

Somebody talking under their breath for 30 min. No thanks.

Well that was some weird ass shit. Technically speaking, it was like listening to the Doors but not really. Too electronic for me.

Hard no. Sounds like a guy in his parent’s basement messing around with a synthesizer. Plus the name.

Some songs not bad. Others silly

Terrible, F. The only thing I liked about this album was when it ended.

Repetitive hard rock licks, combined with a few other instruments and vocals to provide variation. Not sure why this was included.

1 - This is what it sounds like when you let people high on heroin loose with recording equipment. In all seriousness though, I found it pretty horrible to listen too and I felt the emotions that they intended the audience to feel. The screaming was too much and a bit over the top.

Dafuq. Too weird and kooky for me. The amount I enjoy moaning and screaming in real life is the amount I enjoyed this album. Deliberately stressful and I'm not into it. It was hard not to vote it 1/5 before finishing listening, but in the spirit of being open minded, I finished the album before reviewing (but still gave it a one). If you could vote it 0, I would.

Some trepidation clicking play on this album. Is it going to be more noisy incoherent punk rage? Happy to hear it ain't that. A very interesting electronic industrial droney sound palette - it builds tension, which is enhanced by the slightly nervous whispery vocals. Weird album, weird is good. Fave Tracks: Rocket USA 3.5/5

Francie Teardrop reminded me of the clip where Nasser Hussain put a chair down on David Gower's foot. Other than that I took nothing from this.

Proto a lot of stuff I'm into but not great on it's own

Nope. Nope. Nope.

Rarísimo álbum. Cómo una base rara de electrónica con algún piano o guitarra y una voz tétrica que nunca terminan de acelerar o romper todo.

Shades of The Doors

experimental

The synthie minimalism rock didnt really catch me.

I didn’t like this. What the hell was with the guy moaning his orgasm got an entire song. Doubt I’d revisit this as it really wasn’t for me.

This is fantastic most of the people here are just stuck in their boring dad rock

recht weird, d musig a sich isch no spannend gsi, aber d vocals hends leider versaut :/

Intense; terrifying; puslating; wounded; insane; baby murdering; sexual; animalistic; haunted; progressive; political; toxic; amazing. Best Tracks: Ghost Rider; Rocket USA; Frankie Teardrop

Worst album of the list so far.

Unimaginative and repetitive

I liked the heavy handedness!

Wow. Incredibly powerful lyrics and music that goes perfectly with it to set the mood. Not music you'd whistle while you work, but intense stuff. Album seemed to not be on apple music; went to Spotify to hear it.

This was very disappointing. The same beat every time every song. Sounded fun at first the. just repepatitve

Didn't enjoy it.

This is an odd album that I have heard songs from in isolation and it works much better as an album, was not surprised Springsteen loves it, seems like a huge inspiration for Nebraska, which I love... I do not love this as much but it makes sense and odd that it is not better known. The album gets better as it settles in and moves through its unique landscape.

unlistenable

I considered giving this album 5 stars just for the song “Frankie Teardrop” alone, but I fear all the erotic moaning and whining within “Girl” made me a tad bit TOO uncomfortable, unfortunately knocking this down to a 4.

Extremely repetitive and predictable. Most, if not all songs has a bass/guitar/synth line that just goes on throughout the entire song with some weak lyrics on top.

Interesting. Not something I'd feel comfortable listing to with children in the room.

Getting real sick of sex noises in albums. Cheree was ok but altogether this was pretty bad and borderline upsetting.

I get what they’re doing here, obviously very sharp social critique. It almost feels more like theater than music at one point so I’m not really sure how to rate it

Moody, downbeat, eerie sounding. A bit too morose for my taste.

Hated it. Hated it. Hated it.

Gear: Grado Hemp Mische (2019 Remaster): Vocals mit Hall von besonderer Qualität, unnachgiebige Drum Machine, Mix wohl ungeeignet für Kopfhörer mit heißem Treble (Hifiman Arya), (Remaster) klingt nicht nach einem halben Jahrhundert! Mugge: aufwühlend und mach Puls, "Frankie Teardrop" allein ist ein 10-minütige "Jacob's Ladder"-Abstieg in den Wahnsinn, "Cheree" hat überraschend "freundliche" Vibes Wertung: 4/5

Clearly a huge influence for so much including Nichola Jaar and Darkside. Kind of love it but also won't ever listen to it again and this was my 3rd effort.

Not a fan of this one

It lives up to its name 1.5/5

It's not a perfect album but goddamn if it isn't close. So much music I love sprung forth from this moment and these sounds.

On a relisten, I was struck by how much closer this was to Kraftwerk than I remembered.

so dark and heavy. can feel the influence of this on all sorts of post-punk, early electronic and even new wave on here. Ghost Rider sample used perfectly, both musically and thematically in MIA's Born Free. One of those albums I really appreciate but don't want to listen to often (filed right next to Bauhaus).

frankie nooooo :(

#72. Well that certainly was uhhhh... something, now wasn't it? Like, you know, not something good, but something. 1/5: stop Song added to playlist: Ghost Rider I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link

Interesting and ahead of its time but jesus fucking christ that 10 minute long Frankie song made me want to shut it off. Don't need that shit.

Ah, ta '77 godina - jedna od najboljih godina u glazbi. Ovo je album koji se jednostavno mora slušati u noći. Atmosfera je jednostavno takva.

Awful. Would never listen to this again

This shit sucks donkey dick

Not for me

eerste twee tunes waren best oke, maar daarna werd het slechter en slechter

Pretty awesome post punk band.

A rather unfortunate choice of a name, followed by quite annoying music.

Tämä oli kyllä kamala. Rääkymistä ja huminaa. En ymmärrä.

Weird little noises: the album Hot garbage 0/5

It's clear they were much ahead of their time, but even listening to it at the "right time," I still didn't like it. They influence a lot of good people according to the Wikipedia page, so they deserve some extra points, but not a new listening session.

Sicherlich extrem einflussreich für die spätere Postpunk-Bewegung mit den elektronischen Elementen und der teils düsteren Stimmung, aber musikalisch am Ende auch sehr dünn und repetetiv. Live bestimmt spannender damals. 😉

I wrote a pretty thoughtful review here but then it wouldn’t let me submit it so I refreshed the page and lost it… I am not typing all of that again. Favorite song: Frankie Teardrop Least favorite: Girl

Something about this really did it for me. Perfect length for me to enjoy before it got annoying. Hard carry from Frankie Teardrop.

Known before: Band Cheree Frankie Teardrop 8/10

Known before: Standouts: Rating: -1.5

Known before: / Standouts: / Rating: 3.0

Known Before: No Standouts: No 1.0

Daisy Daisy Daisy Daisy

A few songs save it from a 1. Would never want to hear a man moans without any background or filters.

It's rather dull listen. While there are some nice playarounds with instruments and I'm sure the loops at the time were a new thing, these days I don't find the appeal. It's cocktail rock music in a way.

Wow! Best of all 450 albums I already received in this list. Is what the late 70s and big part the 80s really felt like, not the 'back to the 80s' party bullshit but ununemployement, street mess, nuclear threat. The fascinating, repetitive rhythm in Cheree. The Velvet underground like song Johnny. And then the minimal, paranoid, manic songs Girl and Frankie Teardrop, pure beauty. Guess average will be low as you can't sing along or dance or have sex on it. But for those who also rated it with 5 stars: do listen to the Minny Pops album Drastic Measures, Drastic Movements and Young Marble Giants album Colossal Youth and more happiness is coming too you!

A great way to be put on a list 1/5

I get why people dont like this on here, cuz its surely not for anyone, but damn this record is ahead of its time! Im sure a lot of industrial artists were inspired by this album.

Bleak. I see the influence on future music and other artists. I can't say I'll ever listen to this again.

Giving Frankie a gun seemed like a bad idea

not even worth listening to

I had to go back and forth debating whether I wanted to rank this album according to how groundbreaking it is (I usually give a star just for that even on albums I dislike), or according to how listenable it is. I went with the latter because I never want to listen to this album again. First one on this list I've given a 1 star rating.

Some freaky deaky rock n roll inspired twisted 50s horror story, occasionally sparkles.

This album was pretty bland, then got tremendously grating toward the end. I understand that music is a medium to tell a story, and that everyone has a story to tell, but some of the stories from this album are better left out of published music. The thought of a band exploiting the topic of suicide and employing amoral shock tactics for commercial gain is abhorrent. I see little to no value in this “music” ; one star.

This album was kindof boring. The backing track is the same 30 seconds on a loop. Also the song Girl was kind of disturbing, im not sure how anyone feels good listening to that. 1 star

So influential and also so difficult to listen to - I’ve never heard synth that menaced like that. Still, I’d rather be listening to Alan Vega’s best buddies - Devo. Where are they on this list?

Decent album, fun sounds, accurate depiction of lower class lifestyle

Very weird, very dark, very uncomfortable, very niche. I think it’s actually good - it creates atmosphere, makes you feel. Has Nine Inch Nails vibes. Listens: 3 Fave Track: Most powerful is Frankie Teardrop Rating: 4

Normalmente gosto da vibe mais psicodélica, mas essa é muito pra usar drogas e fritar, não deu pra apreciar muito. Do nada um gemidão... Duas estrelas só pela vibe que por sorte eu curto, se não era uma.

Bom, a própria capa do álbum já dá spoiler da nota já... Músicas extremamente chatas. Não chega a dar raiva igual aquele Psychocandy lá, mas é só extremamente chato mesmo. Minto, a música 6 - Frankie Teardrop dá raiva sim... pra que esses berros cara..... se foder Nem tenho muito o que falar, não entendi a musicalidade delas, não entendi o propósito, o que que era pra ser, não entendi nada. Dava pra tranquilamente ter morrido sem ouvir isso.

Don't listen to this one, ever again.

This is what happens when white people are left to their own devices and try to come up with music

No. Just no. Nothing surprising here except for its inclusion on this list. Not brutal enough in execution be actually dangerous, not comprehensive enough to seem like anything more than a demo released before completion, and not lyrically deep enough to be more than high-school level nihilism rants. Maybe at the time it was revolutionary, but here it just seems boring and uninspired.

Pretty wild for ‘77 but not so much for now. It is repetitive. There’s like the same white noise sound over several tracks.

Nope. Sorry.

WOW that was garbage, mind numbingly boring. How on earth did someone put on a vinyl of this in the late 70s and think "This is what I'm going to spend my time listening to". 1/10, if it wasn't for Cheree sound ok for 30 seconds or so it would be a 0

Ghost rider was cool but the rest sounded too similar

Experimental.

Random noise and talking. Hated. 0/5

Started out better than I was expecting, but got progressively worse........."Girl" made me highly uncomfortable.

It’s a little sparse, but I like what’s going on.

A bit too weird for me

Interesting. Never heard of these guys before but they seem foundational

I didn't enjoy the album, didn't enjoy the style and especially didn't like the screaming near the end of the album.

Interesting sound up front, a little too interesting in the middle and the back half of the album is legitimately haunting

Not a fan of this one.

I take a fat shit on this album every morning.

We'll, don't judge a book by it's album cover I guess. Key track: Johnny

Favorite Tracks: Ghost Rider, Rocket USA, Cheree

I can see how and where it has influenced others, but it just didn't do it for me.

Not an ounce of talent went into this one

UNBELIEVABLE! Such a unique sound! Love it. Standouts: Frankie Teardrop, Cheree, Ghost Rider, Rocket USA, Girl, Johnny, Che, I Remember. Cheree Remix 4.5/5

Don’t think this is for me

interesting stuff i thought

Okay 4/10

It was ok

I guess this is on here because it influenced GOOD bands? I sure didn't like it. I skipped the last 2/3 of "Frankie Teardrop" because the singer decided it was a good idea to just scream into the mic for no good reason. Sorry to anybody out there listening with earbuds. I made it about halfway through the final track before just quitting. It wasn't worse than Frankie Teardrop, but it wasn't any better. Except there was no screaming. It's appropriate that the cover has one star on it. Because that's what I'm giving it. I'd give it 0 if I could.

It's definitely ahead of its time but those droning synths are torture to listen to.

I give this 1 star because it is technically music. But ungodly bad.

Didn't like it at all. 1/5 -S

Essential Tracks: Ghost Rider (Playlist) Cheree Frankie Teardrop

Started strong then got weird for weird sake

Kinda lost me at the cover art. Southbound from there

This was too glitchy and meandering for me. Not very enjoyable.

After listening to this, I understand the name of the artist and album better… I can appreciate art for art’s sake and I personally don’t mind a dissonant soundscape but they lost me on “Frankie Teardrop” with the sudden shrieking. I see the influence of this album and appreciate the sound it may have eventually led other artists to explore, but at the end of the day I just don’t know who would listen to this album regularly. I certainly won’t be.

First on the list I haven't heard. Into a bunch of this. Def need to check out all the bands they influenced - throbbing gristle, soft cell, erasure, bronski beat, yaz, caberet voltaire

Good, solid rock

Every song seemingly has the same synthesizer and percussion in the background, so there isn't a ton of variety here. "Frankie Teardrop" is, of course, a ton listen and that's not including the screaming heard throughout the song. I enjoyed this album more than I expected to and this is so bizarre I think it must be heard.

Unsettling, desolate, sexual, political, sparse. This album is a landmark. The vibe of the droning keyboards, synths, and drum machine and the off kilter crooning, leads to something other worldly. It is very punk in its attitude, it’s minimalistic and it’s edgy. I imagine there are many who would pick this up and hate it because of how eerie and unnerving it can be, but also because of the simplicity of the lyrics. But it is rarely about the lyrics. The lyrics are just enough to convey the framework for a song, as is the case with Frankie Teardrop, but it’s the playing and the mood that is created that really tell the story. This is always a fascinating one to come back to and get completely blown away by again.

One can never have too much reverberated screaming of a Monday morning.

4/10. So, I didn't really like it, but it is pretty crazy that this is from the 70's, and it's fascinating how many successful artists were inspired by this album to make stuff that I actually do like

Hard to believe this came out in 1977. And I didn't hate it as much as I expected. For some reason the craziness was slightly compelling to me - maybe I'm finally coming around to experimental shit with under 100 albums to go! 6/10

3/5. A very intense and quiet album, not planning on listening to it multiple times but it was enjoyable nonetheless, more from a comedic factor for how over the top some of the singing was. It is also, at the same time, insanely terrifying, at least the 10+ minute long track on there. But there is a subtle threatening air throughout the whole album. Would not recommend but also would.

- Suicide is badass - Not at all what I was expecting, some weird ambient electronic stuff - Does not bring good vibes but I guess it fits with the title of the album? - Electronic instrumentals were cool but I didn't really like this tbh

- reminds me a little of the Smashing Pumpkins - sex noises during Girl weren’t appreciated - Frankie Teardrop is jarring

Save for "Frankie" this record has truth-in-labeling issues. Joy Division feels darker (at least in a sophisticated, aesthetically-engaged way Sartre-esque way), though this is eerie-ominous, for sure. And not bad overall, and clearly ahead of its time; indeed, the psychedelic and prog-y flourishes (e.g., organs on "Girl") make it seem borderline pleasant at times. "Cheree" feels modern, certainly predictive of New Wave proper. And "Johny" seems like it wants to be '50s sort of rocker or perhaps an early '80s pop tune. The clicking background hiss (from the drum machine perhaps) feels like iffily-pressed old vinyl or like crickets-cicadas on a summer night in the the South. As for "Frankie," which is boring because plodding rather than suspense-building, one vastly prefers "The End," for its clearer narrative thrust and stronger character development and Morrison's presence On the other hand, one thinks NIN and all that more-enraging-than-artfully-enraged ilk might have taken a page from from these cats and kept it, you know, quieter, which is much more interesting, they should understand.

All of the songs were different sounding than any other group. But, all of the songs sounded alike. And then one of the songs was 10 minutes and ruined the album.

So bad…

I can see why people don't like this album. I think it's incredibly unique and must say I like it. Though I find it odd that Bruce Springsteen was inspired by this album and covered the single Dream Baby Dream.

Hey beeby, beeby, beeby… Ghost Rider set up an expectation that the rest of the record doesn’t always deliver on. But it does stick to the good bits: stripped down, minimalist, lo-fi keyboard with sparse reverb-ed out vocals. I love a couple of the songs on this album… but not as much Frankie or Girl which I find too dramatic and pretty annoying. The music is great though. Music would be a 5 but the irritating songs pull it down to a 3.

I've listened to this band before. It took me awhile to get used to their sound. Overall an enjoyable record even if Frankie is too long.

This was fine. Some of the songs were interesting. Some are WAY to long. I may listen again, but not anytime soon.

I can see it was groundbreaking, but the electronic noise just annoyed me. I did like one song.

HL: “Frankie”, “Ghost Rider”, “Rocket USA”, “Cheree” I enjoy this against all odds. Violates some of my basic needs in music- its melodies are near non-existent, it’s repetitive, it displays its disturbing themes with the subtlety of a sledgehammer- and yet it’s kinda awesome as well. It spreads the cliches and tropes of 50s rock-and-roll over a post-apocalyptic wasteland. It should come with a headphone warning however September 23, 2023

Dude why are you so breathy

C'était vriament juste trop weird,beaucoup de répétition, pourquoi je sais pas trop. Les tounes suggérées apr`s cet album étaient pas mal meilleur et pourtant c'était le même groupe. Peut-etre que c'est leur premier album et c'est pourquoi il a été ajouté à la liste mais sa reste vraiment juste moyen... 2.5

too weird/boring for me

Kermit Sewerslide

In 1977 this album changes music. It's an underground influence that is the reason this list exists. 4/5.

Da e litt rart

Furchtbar hibbelig und trotzdem erstaunlich langweilig. Man sehnt sich nur nach dem Ende. Der schnelle Rhythmus und die Rasseln haben was von native American music (cree song etc, das ist alles tausend mal besser als suicide). Ab und zu mal ein nette Bass line. Aber das Album ist einfach Shit.

Bisschen arg eintönig. Bin für dieses leicht krautige schon manchmal zu haben, aber das hier einfach nach Lied 3 on my nerves gehend. 2,5

Neue Lebensregel: wenn du mir schon ins Ohr stöhnst, dann hab immerhin was spannendes zu sagen. Gänsehaut aber auf die negative Weise.

2/5 Komprimierter Surfrock?? Experimentell

the overwhelming feeling that Dimery puts this in, and not any one of 1000 more worthy must listen albums. Greatest hits are valid. This isn’t.

OK a warning might be nice. Intense. Requiring serious attention, substantial tolerance for noxious psychological stimuli. Functioning as my own ethics committee, I assigned myself an antidote immediately (vagus nerve breathing). Astonishing and Potent. And how obviously Springsteen's NEBRASKA album sound - yeah verily, "Rocket USA" gave us the whoops on Johnny 99, and Frankie Teardrop fed State Trouper. Effective as all ____. But never again.

Influential, I’m sure, but of no interest to me.

At the time, I just never got Suicide. Listening to this album now, it makes a bit more sense. I really like the opening track.and Cheree very much reminded me of early Jesus & Mary Chain. But nothing else here floats my boat. It may be a very influential recording. But not for me.

Like Kollaps by Einstuerzende Neubauten, this is an album that was really influential for me (and lots of other people, as well). The (frankly terrible) industrial band I played in during the 90s was unashamedly influenced by Suicide, partly because of the power of it and partly because we weren't very good, and the simple form was something we could aspire to. The guy who programmed the drum machines (Virtual Mark Selway, RIP) was a huge fan, and we occasionally would let him on the mic to sing a Suicide cover (Ghost Rider or Dream Baby Dream, usually). The album is creepy and disturbing and abrasive and minimal and noisy, and not a pleasant listening experience, really. But it's like they squeezed rock and roll down to its bare essence, and then filtered it back through the limitations of their own way of doing things. But they showed how much you could do with so little; almost no instruments (and certainly no guitars), almost no lyrics, almost no music. And that was a massive realization; you could make compelling rock music out of almost nothing. You can hear Suicide influences all over the place, including as important foundational influences on industrial music and techno. This Pitchfork article has 15 examples of the varied people indebted to Suicide: https://pitchfork.com/thepitch/1232-15-songs-indebted-to-suicides-alan-vega/ ) I am fascinated, in particular, by the way Bruce Springsteen is clearly playing homage to Suicide in his song 'State Trooper'. It's an unexpected influence, but makes sense when you think about it. It also explains why State Trooper is my favorite Springsteen song. I enjoyed listening to this again, and it made me want to call up the surviving members of my old band and see if they want to get back on stage and make some noise. I confess that I rarely listen to this album, but I always find it fascinating and energizing. But I can see why most people would find it difficult, unpleasant, repetitive and scary. It's four stars for me, but I understand why it would be a 1 or 2 for many listeners.

I can see how it's influential and really pioneering for the time, but honestly, aside from Ghost Rider, this didn't do it for me. 'Girl' was serious cringe.

Al menos es corto.

Pas le plus mauvais. Juste trop de chansons bizarres. 5/10

Le genre d'album que je suis partagé, car je n'ai pas 100% embarqué à ma première écoute à cause de comment c'était trop weird parfois (surtout Frankie Teardrop), mais en même temps ça sonne tellement révolutionnaire et en avance sur son temps qu'on ne peut qu'admirer. Clairement ça a été un impact majeur sur la scène expérimentale. Définitivement à réécouter. 7/10

Possibly the greatest album ever made. So minimal and yet layered. The songs are simple and effective. Frankie Teardrop is harrowing, and the 1970s' version of Sister Ray. Cheree adds a little light amongst the shade. Fabulous.

For some reason Sigue Sigue Sputnik comes to mind here. But a lot more stylish. I was expecting something dark, It's actually quite uplifting. Rock 'n' roll should always be dumb and simple. At times it sounds like an even seedier version of Soft Cell. The tape hiss just adds to the overall lo-fi effect. 32 minutes is the ideal time for any album. And 10 minutes of that is taken up with Frankie.

Spoken verse, strange mix, tons of delay and synth-organ. Not something I like.

10/10 one of my all-time favorite punk albums (shit’s so punk it’s practically post-punk)

This album felt a bit like a one trick pony, light synthy sounds over a clicky electronic beat. It was alright to begin with but wore thin towards the middle. Frankie Teardrop was just plain weird. In fact, that is the perfect word to describe the album as a whole

.....dioh mioh... muy tenebroso no me gu

Weird, dark moody record with annoying synths that actually give it the atmosphere you would expect with a band/album title, Suicide. Girl and Frankie Teardrop are both disturbing and embarrassing with a lot of screaming, creepy vibes and hilarity. A challenging, difficult listen, but worth the time if only to hear what they sounded like. Music to torture and punish your friends and family with! Yikes!

One of the strangest albums on this list. The music is so minimalist but I suppose it's punk but also electronic. And also horror? That one 10 minute saga about the man that murdered his family with the 5 minutes of screaming will certainly be memorable. If anything I can say it was ahead of its time.

Should have spent their sunglasses money on a fucking drum machine. How did this stuff get people to riot at live shows?

Too many of these already.

Nothing excitable or special

Listened Before? N Apparently this was influential. Never heard of them. It's noisy and too many mumbled words and keyboards for me. Wikipedia classifies it as synth-punk. Please don't ever call this anything "punk". Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Ghost Rider

Áhugavert. Hefur verið ansi framsækið á sínum tíma.

this one didn't really land for me. I'm sure there are some great artists that took a lot of inspiration from this album (maybe LCD Soundsystem?) but IDK how it belongs on so many lists of best albums

Couldn't get into this one. I like some of the electronic stuff on the list but this one got jangly and annoying

ugh so boring and the vocals suck and the basslines are so repetitive and everything is just so repetitive and butt

Not for me.

The thing about Suicide is they have a cool sound but their songs also kind of all sound the same and have similar structures.

I guess there is some interesting innovation there, probably even more significant at the time. But listening to it today does not do much for me.

i am such a sucker for weird ass fucking sounds that make my ears bleed. “frankie teardrop” is about 8 minutes longer than it ever needed to be. fav songs: ghost rider, cheree, johnny, che.

Unexpectedly boring.

I'm glad I heard this album, I really appreciate the art of this. Music is meant to make you feel things and that's exactly what songs like Frankie Teardrop do. I can fully understand how this is influential and years ahead of its time. I just didn't like it much.

I've never heard of Suicide before. This album fall into an interesting zone. It was good to hear something different than what I might pick for myself. I like some electronic music and I would be interested in hearing more from the band because they sometimes created a sound that I liked, but after listening to the whole album I had to admit that I do not like the album. While there are interesting sounds and portions of tracks that I did like, there were several elements that kept my overall rating below 3 stars. There was droning and heavy repitition ("Rocket U.S.A.", "Girl"), creepy lyrics ("Cheree"), and outright screaming ("Frankie Teardrop").

This is by far the worst thing I’ve ever heard. Captain Beefheart seems like The Beatles in comparison. Seriously. Go awful. I had cringe-induced goosebumps the entire time I listened. When he starts screaming in Johnny Teardrop I feared for my life. How anybody decided this is “art” is beyond me. There’s no musicality to this. It’s a Casio on loop with a shit tambourine sample. The guy talks about a man killing his family in Johnny Teardrop or just outright has an orgasm into the mic on Girl.

This is pretty interesting. I'm a bit surprised I wasn't already familiar with them. Reminds me a bit of Television, but with electronic music in place of the guitars. I could do without some of the screaming in Frankie Teardrop, but otherwise I liked this a lot. The groove in Girl seems to have been lifted from Misty Mountain Hop by Led Zeppelin. Unique and far ahead of its time. 4 stars.

The orgasmic moaning in “Girl” made me even more uncomfortable than the droaning synth on every track. Ugh.

This is brutalist architecture in musical form. And just like brutalist architecture in Building form, it might be trying to say something, but it sucks and nobody likes it.

AAAAAAAHHHHHH!!! My poor ears!

pure joie de vivre

Boriiinn´

This band caught me off guard not only with their name, but also with the music. Really haunting, depressing, scary at times. Can’t say I really dig it, it’s too much out there, and ahh maybe too much drug fuelled? Anyway, some might really love it. 2 out of 10

This album is great and feels like such a refreshing force from this time and place. Just killer minimalist synth-punk.

This album just did not do it for me. I could see a lot of the influences it had on later music, but this just really sucked in my opinion

Very challenging and intriguing album, really cool tracks like Cheree and the menacing Frankie Teardrop, quite an experience.

I’ve heard of this band before, specifically because of the song Frankie Teardrop. I can not recommend enough to put on a god set of headphones, sit in a dark room and crank the volume on that. It is a terrifying experience and is an exceptional showcase of music being a piece of art. Songs I already knew: Frankie Teardrop Favourites: Frankie Teardrop, Ghost Rider This album as a whole is fairly odd but is very interesting. Nothing comes close to topping the jaw dropping nature of Frankie Teardrop, but the songs are still enjoyable in their own ways. I never knew that this was music from the seventies either. I honestly wouldn’t have been able to put a date on it because it feels so much different to anything I’d ever heard before. Give this a try. You might hate it, but you might surprise yourself.

I feel like all of the accolades of this album are gaslighting me. It is beyond boring musically, and it's pretty stunning to think that any of the electronic sounds were ever considered innovative. Everything just feels basic as hell.

I thought this was fun to dance in the shower to, I can only imagine how fun it would have been at CBGBs.

I don't know much about this band other than having heard James Murphy wax poetic about them, saying he got married to Cheree. I can understand why the music alienated audiences, it's uncompromising and there inlies its power. I allowed myself to settle into the repetition of it and really quite enjoyed it while part of me hated it at the same time. Good listen.

A simple formula but an effective one. I can't even imagine how intense a Suicide show at CBGB's would have felt like back in the day. These guys were fucking crazy for going the direction they went with electronic music and I admire their bravery. Only thing that I can think of that preceded them in this regard was maybe Silver Apples, but that wasn't nearly as abrasive. I am addicted to their stripped down sound. It is the genesis if so much that I love. Such an efficiency of sound, nothing is more punk than this.

I don't hate it, but a few of the tracks like Girl are so ridiculous it sounds like they are taking the piss outta the listener. Some of it also annoys, but I do like the general groove formula. I can see why people would like it though.

Expecting punk based on band name alone... Instead we find ourselves in a sparse electro-alternative in the vein of LCD Soundsystem, but super stripped down. I'm really digging the sound so far. Very ahead of its time and confident. Cheree is a low-key jam; twinkling keys layered on top of a fuzzy bass synth with just the right touch of modulation from bar to bar to keep things interesting while the singer wanders on ghostily amid it all. Girl brings straight up sex sounds over top of a back and forth synth baseline with some organ keys on top; can't get over how ahead of its time this all feels -- minimal-electro-psych-pop. Frankie Teardrop is a bit too far for my liking. I understand the premise and commitment, but the electro-scream had me tuning down quite a bit. Was kind of hoping it would rip out into a crazy bass instrumental, but no luck there. 4/5

I was listening to this record via speakers at home, but decided to switch to headphones halfway through the second song because I didn't want to subject the other people in my house to this music. Turns out I was right to do that, because this is an awful album. Apparently it was recorded over four days, and I wish someone had recommended the band to take maybe four more years to mull over whether this was worth releasing or not. It sounds like someone repeatedly drilling into my skull, with an ocassional scream that really pisses me off, to be honest. I will be very happy to never think about this record ever again. To those who love this, more power to you guys! But this album SUCKS

I didn't finish. It became a bit too noisy/avant-garde for me in the office.

Started off loving this album, but really tailed off after the first few songs got a bit too weird to really enjoy. Clearly desveres it’s place on the list, but doesn’t make my regular rotation.

Weird, enerverende

if this came out in 2023 it’d be considered garbage and ignored. but it’s 1977 so everything slightly weird is extremely important. hypnotic, brooding minimal beats with probably off the cuff lyrics. sounds like something a couple of kids made in a garage while pulling an all nighter (realizing later that they were grown ass adults when making this) it’s the kind of thing that sounds so fuckin dumb you think you’re probably too dumb to realize that it’s actually genius. these songs are literally just half baked ideas. one drum loop with a dinky little synth riff and some shitty vocals. i will say though Frankie Teardrop….by far one of the eeriest things i have ever heard in my life. but ya if you were influenced by this good for you i guess.

There's some good, original content. Lots of creative tunes. Some of it was not really my style, but overall, it was pretty good.

1/5 Best: Ghost Rider Worst: Frankie Teardrop

Second time listening to this one. Heard it on a previous listen through a 500 list. I liked it better this time. Still not a favourite but better.

Not my kind of music

Iconic? Maybe. Good? Fuck no. This album sucked.

Suicide is right. Oh my god if this is the worst album in the world I wouldn’t be surprised. The one ☝️ okay thing is that it was only a half hour. One more second and I would have taken the artist literally. Good god.

Ooo this reminded me that I was familiar with the lovely "Frankie Teardrop" - I hadn't heard that once since my wedding reception... This is what happened when you left Tommy the little delinquent punk at home for the weekend in the late 70s with nothing but Oreos and coke and his new cheap little Radio Shack gadgets. Seriously: as low an "effort" as I've ever heard - not just on the 1001 - ever. Straight up in the running for worst album ever released. 0/10 0 stars (i wish).

Front half is pretty good, Girl is one of the creepiest songs I've ever listened to, and then the album truly goes off the rails.

I was intrigued in the beginning but it all became repetitive noise soon after. And that moaning in "girl". Ew

First two are classics so no need to write about them. Cheree precursors about a dozen Spiritualized songs which I love. Such a singular sound, 45 years later basically nothing else sounds quite like it. People not getting this, or just not liking this, is totally understandable, but it absolutely should not be dismissed. Also it's not on here but Dream Baby Dream is an absolute stunner, and far less confrontational than anything here, it's very gentle.

Alan Vega routinely lopped a decade off his age. I'm not sure why, but that takes guts... I know why people like this album, or why people think this album should be liked (not always the same thing). I know that Death in Vegas and LCD would not exist without this album. (A mixed blessing in this household, tbf, but the underlying principle stands.) All that said. I'm going to bed.

Brilliantly different. And years ahead of its time. Frankie Teardrop is a song that belongs in a Gasper Noé movie. It is a deep and troubled journey to hell. Much of the album feels that way as well. The more I listen the more I like it. 3.5/5

Experimental. Una mierda bastante grande.

Zo kan ik ook muziek maken: de hele tijd het zelfde roffeltje herhalen en daar wat doorheen zingzeggen of kreunen. Op de achtergrond wat pingelen op je synthesizer en de plaat is weer klaar. Eerst denk je, het past wel aardig in het rijtje jaren zeventig-space age-platen, maar op een gegeven moment ben je het zat.

Deze band weet blijkbaar dondersgoed wat ze met deze muziek stimuleren ...

Vage intermezzonummers uit een plaat van The Velvet Underground met voornamelijk ruis. Dat vind ik normaal gesproken al irritant als dit soort stukjes 'muziek' tussen echte nummers door komen. Maar Suicide maakt er een heel album van. Wat een verschrikkelijke zaadmuziek is dit.

Music to lose your mind to. I’m surprised the band didn’t fall asleep while recording with how little variation there is in the instrumentals. On top of that the vocals are pretty awful and miserable. 3/10

It, uh, sure is something. I guess I didn't necessarily mind the vocals, if you exclude that blood-curdling screaming in Frankie Teardrop... If every song were like that, this would be getting a 1. Would you believe that the lyrics to that song were improvised? It's pretty obvious if you listen to how straightforward they are. Not the most fun listen at 1 A.M. Would probably be a good Halloween album with how haunting some of the music can be. I didn't hate it, so I can't give it a 1, but I didn't really like how structureless the songs felt. It feels like they just came up with an electronic loop and had Alan Vega sing whatever on top of it. I kind of like his voice, so I guess it's fine, but sometimes I'd lose focus out of boredom. Definitely interesting though, even if I never have any drive to listen to it again. My favourite song was Cheree.

Nei, nei og atter nei

Temmelig fete greier! Minner meg on Aike

Very good if a little difficult